From our other sites
The story
On November 20, Japan’s Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism released draft guidelines aimed at preventing disputes over “doorstep delivery” (oki-haitatsu), the practice of leaving parcels at a designated spot such as the front door. Under the proposal, delivery is considered complete the moment a parcel is placed at the designated location, meaning any damage or theft after that point would, in principle, not be covered by compensation. Public comments open the same day, with a formal decision targeted by the end of the year. On 5ch forums, backlash was swift, with users saying things like “I’m switching back to face-to-face delivery” and “there’s no way to prove it was stolen,” while reactions also split depending on whether people had delivery boxes or security cameras at home.
On the 20th, the Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism released draft guidelines spelling out the scope of delivery companies’ responsibilities for “doorstep delivery”—leaving parcels at the front door or another designated spot—in order to prevent disputes. The guidelines state that a parcel is considered delivered once it’s placed at the designated location, and that any damage occurring afterward will not be covered by compensation. Following a public comment period that began on the 20th, a formal decision is expected by the end of the year.
The draft guidelines spell out the roles and responsibilities of everyone involved across a range of delivery methods, including doorstep delivery, parcel lockers, and convenience-store pickup.
Regarding compensation for damaged parcels, delivery companies will be responsible if the damage occurred before handover. After handover, the guidelines explicitly state that theft and loss, too, will in principle fall outside the scope of compensation.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Yeah, there's no other choice at this point
So face-to-face delivery is now a tolerated paid option, huh?
Seriously the worst
Wait, you actually shop on Amazon?
If you set it to hand-delivery, you can still claim compensation if it gets stolen, right?
Doorstep delivery is actually the lesser evil
Even when you're home, they just dump it in the delivery box at the apartment entrance anyway
It's the drivers who'll be the ones in trouble
Nothing good ever comes from the government sticking its nose in
Re: #7
I only use doorstep delivery because I don't want to deal with people in person—that doesn't mean it's fine for a driver to steal it and pin it on "theft"
and then some delivery worker just comes right back and swipes it
Exactly this
I'm done with doorstep delivery, switching back to redelivery
A certain Am●az●on is already doing exactly that to people
and delivery straight to your home becomes a paid optional extra
>PUDO
It's convenient, but only works for small items
Wonder how much it actually costs to maintain those lockers
PUDO only really works properly for Yamato or Amazon orders
With Sagawa or Yu-Pack it's redelivery-only, and even then the sender has to give the OK
Yu-Pack doesn't even stick to the time slot you request
I asked for 12-2pm and it showed up in the morning
Honestly, Yamato's the only one actually putting real effort into cutting down redeliveries
The current government is the height of incompetence
At this rate, isn't charging a fee for redelivery coming soon?
Rakuten Securities isn't getting shut down either, is it?
Keidanren (the business federation) is basically foreign capital at this point
and since they're the ones pulling the government's strings, there's no way we get a sane policy out of this
Katayama just fired off another "this is regrettable" statement, as usual
who's supposed to tell the difference, and how, lol
That's the whole point—they're not going to bother figuring it out
"It was broken." "Oh, I see." End of story
When it broke doesn't matter at all
Because hey, you used doorstep delivery, didn't you?? lol
They might start deliberately shipping broken items on purpose
Since you never requested doorstep delivery, you should be free to complain about that
Depends on the company's policy
If they've adopted doorstep delivery in line with the guidelines, they're off the hook; if the guidelines let you opt out and they ignored it, they're liable
Beyond that it comes down to a civil suit
Somebody's bound to actually sue over this eventually, so it'll hinge on how that turns out
They leave it and snap a photo
but there's no way to tell afterward if someone came back and took it
Install a camera and you're fine
What a hassle
Things have gotten sketchy enough lately that maybe I should get one
The recorder's fan is surprisingly loud, you know
they said it doesn't even work out to 1,000 yen an hour
Bet some of them team up with "yami baito" recruiters (shady under-the-table gig work tied to crime rings), lol
Sounds like bonus time just rolled around
That's what I always do
That's exactly the practice this article says is going away
They'll just leave it and walk off
Don't complain even if it's broken
If they drop it, they'll just sprint off and call it a "doorstep delivery"
Nah, if it's broken they'll tell you when they ring the bell
In that case I go check it and receive it myself
Background and key points of this debate
Doorstep delivery spread with government backing as a way to cut down on redeliveries, with companies like Yamato Transport also keeping photographic records of completed deliveries. These new draft guidelines lay out a framework in which a parcel counts as delivered the moment it’s placed at the designated spot, shifting responsibility for it afterward onto the customer—with the main aim of easing the burden on delivery companies. What divided the thread was, first, the point that even with photo records, it’s hard for customers to prove exactly when something broke or whether it truly arrived safely, and second, frustration with the real-world practice of companies switching to doorstep delivery without authorization even when face-to-face delivery was requested. At the same time, households with delivery boxes or security cameras face lower risk, and the way reactions split along those lines is a nuance easy to miss from the news coverage alone. Also worth noting is the schedule ahead: public comments opened on the 20th, with a formal decision targeted by year’s end.
※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (News Speed+) thread “No compensation after ‘doorstep delivery’—Transport Ministry drafts guidelines on damage and theft.”
Leave a Reply