From our other sites
The story
The overseas outlet IGN released a video comparing the performance of the Xbox Series S against the PS5 and PS5 Pro using GTA 6 gameplay footage, racking up over 500,000 views. The video showed the Xbox Series S holding a surprisingly stable ~30fps in some scenes, prompting surprised reactions on 5ch’s hardware/industry (geha) board along the lines of “Everyone said the Series S would be way worse than this before launch.” Others pushed back, pointing out differences in graphics settings and significant input lag. A string of posts comparing the ~30,000-yen Series S to the 40,000-yen-plus PS5 lineup also sparked a broader debate centered on value for money.
@IGN
Translated from English
We compared GTA 6 gameplay performance on the Xbox Series S and PS5 Pro, and the results might surprise you! Check it out here:
Source: video.twimg.com / original post here
What people said
They're nothing alike, obviously
What's surprising is how intense the fanboy hate campaign was before launch, insisting 'the Series S version is definitely gonna look like THIS (garbage)!'
Frame rate's trash too
Damn, that one really landed, lol
Reality is it's getting mocked for not being worth its 120,000-yen price tag
https://pbs.twimg.com/media/HXg8UNTawAAlLD1.jpg
No wonder people can't keep their sanity
PS5 is 55,000 yen,
meanwhile garbage-box S is 100,000 yen lol
No way, the Switch 2's CPU is too weak
The Xbox Series S actually has a genuinely solid CPU spec
Ah, that's why
Makes sense, the Series S shares the same CPU as the Series X
If optimization improves, it might be doable
After all, they managed to ship the notoriously demanding Wilds (Monster Hunter Wilds) on it
it's less that the PS5 Pro sucks and more that the Series S is impressive
Some small-time Japanese game studios kept whining that 'the Series S is a ball and chain' holding development back — you guys are the last ones who get to say that
It's not even holding a steady 30fps, and it's only pulling that off by tolerating 180ms of input lag
Any normal game that shipped with numbers like that would get dragged online
Still true
though there's barely any difference
which, put another way, means the Series S is insanely good
Relax, nobody's actually noticing that lag in practice, so these numbers aren't credible
If the lag were really that bad it'd already be a huge scandal — though now that you mention it, PS5 players do often complain about feeling sick, and PS5's input lag has always been bad to begin with
Keep that in mind!
Under the same conditions, the PS5 costs 40,000 yen and still doesn't deliver even 1.3x the graphics or performance — that's terrible value, what a garbage piece of hardware lol
The Series X is the most stable of the bunch
Number of frames that failed to hold 30fps: Series S had 843, Series X had 50, base PS5 had 1185, and PS5 Pro had 86
People said the PS5 Pro and Series X rarely drop frames while the base PS5 and Series S drop frequently — looks like that's exactly how it played out
The base PS5 clearly suffered the consequences of overreaching to match the Series X's resolution
Series X > PS5 Pro >>> Series S >> PS5
then the Series S alone would've held a stable 30fps on its own, making the PS5 look like the loser,
so instead they forced all versions onto the same graphics settings, making the Series S version heavier too?
Series S: 25fps
Series X: 28fps
PS5: 23fps
PS5 Pro: 27fps
The Series X runs at 120Hz VRR with zero fluctuation
Guess that makes the Series X the strongest
plus you get to play an uncensored version (no content restrictions)
This part got me laughing the hardest
Guess Xbox really is the way to go
FSR 4.1 only just barely covers up through the RDNA2 generation
and the PS5, which is merely 'RDNA2-based' (lol), doesn't make the cut
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
It’s worth noting that the video in question is IGN’s own hands-on comparison, not an official technical benchmark from either manufacturer. The lowest frame rates and dropped-frame counts cited in the thread (e.g., post 95) are also viewer estimates based on visually watching and timing the footage, not official published figures. The main points of debate were that the budget-priced Xbox Series S managed to hold a stable ~30fps surprisingly well, and that the base PS5 reportedly became more prone to frame drops as a result of aiming for the same resolution as the Xbox Series X. It was also noted that FSR4-series upscaling technology is said to be unusable on the PS5, which uses an RDNA2-generation GPU, potentially giving Xbox platforms an edge going forward — a factor that could affect the performance gap down the line. The difficulty of comparing hardware with different price points and performance tiers under the same conditions is behind why opinions were so divided.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry [geha]) thread “[Sad News] World-renowned IGN posts a comparison video of the FSR4-equipped Series S version vs. the PS5 version! Already over 500K views and going viral lol.”


Leave a Reply