Is ‘Rubber Soul’ the Beatles’ Masterpiece? 5ch Fires Back: ‘Stop Hyping It as Their Best Ever’

From our other sites

The story

Rolling Stone’s Rob Sheffield, marking the release of a special edition of the Beatles’ 1965 album ‘Rubber Soul,’ called it the band’s “most emotional, most richly shaded, and wittiest” masterpiece — and the piece sparked a lively debate on 5ch’s Geisports Sokuho+ board. Replies piled in championing ‘Abbey Road,’ ‘Revolver,’ the ‘White Album,’ and ‘Sgt. Pepper’s,’ with plenty of skepticism about narrowing it down to just one record in the first place. The discussion ranged from song-by-song favorites all the way to the historical background of recording technology.

11/19 (Thu) 17:15

The Beatles’ 1965 masterpiece ‘Rubber Soul’ is the band’s most richly shaded, wittiest album. With a new special edition just released, Rolling Stone’s celebrated writer Rob Sheffield unpacks its appeal from his own distinctive angle.

Fall is always ‘Rubber Soul’ season. Ever since its release in 1965, this Beatles masterpiece has carried a whiff of autumn about it — the sharp, ringing guitars, the wistful vocals, the pensive lyrics. But this fall, ‘Rubber Soul’ feels more present than ever. A wonderful special edition has arrived, bringing us closer than ever before to John, Paul, George, and Ringo. It’s their most emotional, most richly shaded, wittiest album — their best.

Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

What people said

3AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:07
Old, lame music.
13AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:13
Re: #3
Back in 1965, 4-track recorders weren't even widespread yet — that was the era when Phil Spector was bragging that mono multi-tracking beat a half-assed 2-track setup.
45AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:37
Re: #3
It's a work from about 60 years ago, so if you're not into it, that's just how it looks from the outside.

Re: #13
Back in '65, hits were still mainly mono singles — stereo LPs existed, but there were also "fake stereo" releases that forcibly converted mono recordings into stereo.
It was the Beatles releasing 'Rubber Soul' that kicked off a wave of groundbreaking work from other artists too, and that's when albums themselves started getting real attention.
4AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:08
Isn't 'Sergeant Whatshisname' supposed to be the masterpiece?
5AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:09
across the universe
6AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:09
The turning point from idol group to artist.
7AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:09
It's 'With the Beatles,' you poser.
8AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:11
I hate how a whole world gives you funny looks just for saying you don't like the Beatles.
9AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:11
I was wondering what song this was… turns out it's an album title.
10AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:11
This is basically just an ad for 'In My Life,' come on.
12AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:13
People can have all sorts of opinions, but let me go on record: the White Album is simply not it.
15AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:13
It's the White Album.
You can feel the band's bitter infighting bleeding right through it.
16AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:13
It's gotta be Abbey Road.
The polish on it is on a completely different level.
17AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:14
Everything after this is less a band album and more everyone just bringing in their own solo tracks.
21AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:16
No, look — Revolver's fine, Abbey Road's fine too, and if someone says the White Album, sure, that works too. So then Rubber Soul's fine as well, right? It's all good.
50AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:43
Re: #21
Is that comeback referencing something specific?
35AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:28
The fact that 'Pet Sounds' came out of this as a byproduct is wild on its own.
54AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:45
Re: #35
But back in 1966, this wasn't appreciated in Japan at all.
39AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:32
I've argued about this with a ton of Beatles fans over the years, and the ones that usually come up as the masterpiece are these four:

"Abbey Road"
"Something," "Here Comes the Sun," and "Come Together" are the best three — the medley is also incredibly fun and creative.

"Revolver"
"Eleanor Rigby," "Here, There and Everywhere," and "I'm Only Sleeping" are fantastic.

"White Album"
"While My Guitar Gently Weeps," "Sexy Sadie," "Happiness Is a Warm Gun."

"Rubber Soul"
"In My Life," "Norwegian Wood," "Michelle" — "In My Life" especially might be the Beatles' best song ever.

Those four, basically. Abbey Road and Revolver especially.
53AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:45
Re: #39
Wait, what about "Tomorrow Never Knows"?
83AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:29
Re: #39
That's quite the song selection — like something straight out of Dr. Bowie's playbook.
47AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:41
For me personally it's: 1. Please Please Me, 2. With the Beatles, 3. A Hard Day's Night, 4. Beatles for Sale.
This isn't intentional — it genuinely lines up this way based on pure preference. In other words, my favorites happen to match the release order exactly.
Guess that just means I love rock'n'roll at heart.
62AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:51
Re: #47
Sounds like Eiichi Ohtaki (famed Japanese musician/producer) was also shocked by the shift on 'Rubber Soul.'
Though four years later, that same Ohtaki ended up joining a gloomy rock band in the vein of Moby Grape.
48AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:41
In order of how much I like them:
Revolver
Magical Mystery Tour
Rubber Soul
Sgt. Pepper's
Abbey Road
Let It Be
71AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:09
Re: #48
It genuinely annoys me how underrated the title track 'Magical Mystery Tour' is.
You rarely find a song that crams in that many different arrangement ideas.
That ending piano part especially is just so cool.
60AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:48
I get where you're coming from — it does have a lot of simple, great songs. But stop pushing it as THE masterpiece.
67AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:01
Re: #60
>Read the OP
It's literally an ad — of course they're going to hype it up, that's the whole point.
63AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:52
Gotta be 'Michelle.' There's no other choice. It's sad how underrated it is, but one listen and you'll get it.
78AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:17
Re: #63
I wonder if the part that sounds like it slows down midway is intentional.
65AnonymousNov 20, 2026 14:55
Going Red Album → Sgt. Pepper's in that order is the easiest way to get into the Beatles.
90AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:40
Re: #65
Back then, Toshiba was the only label pressing Japanese LPs on red vinyl (regular black pressings existed too).
Its selling point was the dust-resistant "Everclean" coating, but the sound quality was terrible.
That said, it was normal for Japanese pressings of Western music from that era to sound bad in general, not just Toshiba's red vinyl.
Also, by the CD era, "Red Album" would instead refer to the red/blue best-of compilations.
69AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:08
Every album is great except Yellow Submarine.
84AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:31
Re: #69
It's a masterpiece just because "Hey Bulldog" is on it.
The insane arrangement on "Only a Northern Song" is also amazing — the melody itself is a perfectly solid tune, so turning it into something that weird takes real skill.

"It's All Too Much" is great fun with the guitar going all-out aggressive.

The reason Yellow Submarine gets underrated is that half the album is really George Martin's album.
72AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:12
Gotta be Revolver and the White Album.
82AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:25
Re: #72
This right here.
Among the later albums, these two are a clear cut above the rest.
Dropping the idol-band image after 'Help!' was absolutely the right call — in fact it feels like they couldn't have gone any further without changing direction. Though 'Help!' itself was also a masterpiece.
86AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:35
Honestly, aren't the Beatles themselves overrated?
Sure, they sold like crazy, but by today's standards that's basically just a hugely popular idol group, right?

If sales were the only measure of greatness, Japanese music would consist of nothing but AKB48 and Nogizaka46.
91AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:41
Re: #86
It's the Beatles + George Martin combo that's the real genius there — you have to give them credit for that.
And on top of that they were incredibly prolific. Just being that prolific is already a serious talent in itself.
87AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:35
Nobody really wants to admit Sgt. Pepper's is great, huh.
93AnonymousNov 20, 2026 15:44
Re: #87
No no — both the songs and the album as a whole are genuinely well made. But "A Day in the Life" is just so incredible that it makes everything else on the album feel comparatively weak by contrast.

Background and Key Points of the Debate

Released in 1965, ‘Rubber Soul’ is widely seen as the turning point where the Beatles shifted from an idol-style rock’n’roll band into one defined by songwriting craft and authorship. Several replies in the thread touched on this framing, and from there the debate split over whether ‘Revolver,’ ‘Sgt. Pepper’s,’ the ‘White Album,’ or ‘Abbey Road’ deserves to be seen as the true peak. The dividing line tends to fall between judging by individual song quality (citing standouts like “Something,” “Eleanor Rigby,” or “In My Life”) versus judging by the cohesion of the album as a whole — with those favoring later records, where the band’s unity had started to fray, talking past those who value that cohesion. A couple of lesser-known points added depth beyond simple taste comparisons: the technical backdrop that 4-track recorders still weren’t widespread in 1965, so mono multi-tracking was the norm, and the fact that the Beach Boys’ ‘Pet Sounds’ — itself influenced by ‘Rubber Soul’ — went largely unappreciated in Japan at the time of its release.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisports Sokuho+) thread “[Music] Is ‘Rubber Soul’ the Beatles’ Masterpiece?“

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *