From our other sites
The story
A, a public high school teacher in the Chubu-Tokai region and a member of Japan’s ’employment ice age’ generation, has worked as a temporary teacher for 27 years. Even at their current school — the 13th they’ve worked at — they still haven’t landed a permanent position, and take home only around ¥160,000 a month. An estimated 1.4 million people nationwide hold public-sector jobs under non-regular statuses such as ‘fiscal-year appointed staff,’ and many of their contracts are set to lapse again this coming March. On 5ch, the thread split sharply between posters who found the situation pitiable and others who shot back that ‘staying non-regular for 27 years is on them’ or ‘that’s just personal responsibility’ — turning the discussion into a reflection of the divide within the ice-age generation itself, between those who ultimately succeeded and those still struggling.
What people said
Bengoshi JP News Editorial Desk, November 20, 2026, 09:58
'For me, it all comes down to just one year.' That's how A, who teaches at a public high school in the Chubu-Tokai region, put it. A graduated from university in March 2000, squarely in Japan's employment ice-age generation. Their 27 years of experience has all been as a temporary teacher, and their current school is the 13th they've worked at. They run a homeroom class and serve as a club activity advisor — and every March, they move on to the next school.
That's a contradiction in terms, huh.
There's nothing contradictory about it — they're just non-regular public-sector staff.
Being public-sector personnel doesn't automatically mean top-tier corporate pay and cushy benefits anyway.
The risk's bigger there, though.
Seriously, it just doesn't pay off
and there are plenty of highly educated people in that boat too.
Don't blame Takenaka or Koizumi for it — the sheer size and social clout of the baby-boomer generation was off the charts.
But the baby boomers numbered around 2.6 million births, and their kids, the 'dankai juniors,' topped 2 million too — a pretty huge cohort in their own right.
When that generation gets old, their sheer numbers alone will be society's payback, I guess.
Must be seriously lacking in ability.
They're clinging on because they want to get promoted to permanent status.
Once a civil servant goes permanent, it's smooth sailing for life.
get into a good elementary school,
get into a good middle school,
get into a good high school,
get into a good university,
become an elite career civil servant,
marry a good wife,
raise good kids,
buy a good house,
buy a good car,
and take care of your mom and dad in their old age.
Do all that and your life's set.
Preschool entrance exams, grade-school entrance exams — oh my, such life-determining matters indeed 💩 (mocking an affected, 'posh-lady' speech style)
Seriously, exactly that.
90% of the ice-age generation are civil servants or full-time employees earning an average of ¥5-6 million a year.
Plenty of them are married, raising kids, and have bought a house or condo.
Sure, some struggled with job hunting, but that was decades ago now.
There were plenty of chances to recover, weren't there?
For ice-age people who are still non-regular or unemployed today, I'm afraid you have to call it personal responsibility, don't you?
There's no recovering your pension contributions, you idiot.
if you just live a normal life and put in a bit of effort, you should be clearing roughly ¥10 million a year by your 40s.
Anyone who doesn't get there, ice age or not, just hasn't tried hard enough.
'Blame the ice age' is nothing but an excuse from people who are simply incompetent.
No you don't, and the real incompetent one is whoever chalks everything up to 'did you try hard enough.'
they're clearly victims of the era, but still.
If I were in that generation, I might've taken revenge on society by now lol
It's nothing compared to the wartime generation —
they were dragged into a wrongheaded war and sent on kamikaze missions.
The generation right after them got to enjoy peace and spent their time on student protests.
Complaining about the ice age is just being soft.
Gen Z says, 'Welfare's ours now.'
Even though their generation's population is shrinking,
the number of young welfare recipients has shot up sevenfold.
If it were true, it'd be a much bigger deal by now.
Sometimes someone who's clearly talented but seems to have 'issues' gets kept on a non-regular contract for a few years just to be watched.
Sometimes someone whose skills are terrible and who's nothing but trouble gets stuck non-regular for almost 10 years.
But if they stick it out and don't quit, they usually get made permanent around year 10.
27 years non-regular means this person is seriously something else.
It depends on whether this is about public-school teacher hiring specifically, or just a generic company story that happens to share the 'non-regular' label.
We lost touch after that so I don't know what happened, but why not just cut your losses?
Go switch to a different industry already.
They've been calling it a 'teacher of last resort' (demoshika kyoshi — 'I guess I'll be a teacher') since the Showa era —
graduates who couldn't make it anywhere else always end up becoming teachers.
That's not a civil servant, that's just a part-timer.
Exactly this.
Calling it 'civil servant' is just wrong.
Anyone who doesn't know what a 'fiscal-year appointed employee' is will get the wrong idea reading that term — they really should stop using it.
Why don't they just become a permanent employee?
Probably because they haven't passed the teacher exam.
They're probably taking it every year, if they want to be a 'senko' (slang for teacher) that badly.
90% of the ice-age generation built solid positions for themselves through their own effort.
Getting lumped in with the 'loser' ice-agers makes my blood boil.
>solid positions
Where, exactly? (lol)
Aren't they all temp agency staff these days?
Civil servants stack all the customer-facing jobs — the ones that get chewed out by residents — with temp staff.
They make temps clean up after their own screwups.
Isn't this just their own fault?
Even among the ice-age generation, the ones with actual skills are earning just fine.
Honestly, the ice-age generation has managed to survive for years as non-regular workers or unemployed NEETs —
and that's thanks to their bubble-era parents.
Since they're bound to inherit from their bubble-generation parents anyway, the ice-age generation isn't miserable at all.
Wasn't there talk of raising inheritance taxes specifically targeting the ice-age generation?
The ice-age generation's parents are the baby boomers.
It's the yutori and Gen Z generations who have bubble-era parents.
You've got a bunch of this mixed up, don't you?
Background and Key Points of the Debate
As posters on the thread themselves pointed out, the term ‘non-regular civil servant’ is confusing to begin with. Most such positions fall under a system called ‘fiscal-year appointed staff,’ in which local governments re-appoint workers on one-year terms — meaning that, regardless of ability or performance, there’s a risk every March that the job simply ends. For teachers, this situation persists until they pass the exam for a permanent position, which is how someone like A in the article ends up repeating one-year appointments for 27 years straight. The thread split over whether to see this structural problem as bad luck specific to the ice-age generation, or as a matter of personal choice and insufficient effort. The ice-age generation faced a sharp drop in new-graduate hiring slots when they entered the job market, but even within that generation there’s a wide gap between those who landed full-time or civil-service jobs and those who stayed non-regular — and that very divide is what plays out as the thread’s central conflict.
*This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (News Speed+) thread ‘Ice-Age Generation, 27 Years as a Teacher, Still Stuck at ‘¥160,000 a Month’ and Unable to Pay Into Pension — 1.4 Million Non-Regular Public Workers Face a ‘Non-Renewal Crisis’ Looming This March.’

Leave a Reply