From our other sites
The story
A thread titled “The reason GTA doesn’t suit Japanese players is that they’re not good at freedom unbound by rules” appeared on 5ch’s Hardware & Industry (Geha) board. Some pointed out that GTA6’s beefed-up NPCs actually restrict actions that were possible in the previous game, while others countered that titles like Animal Crossing and The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild sold well in Japan despite offering plenty of freedom. The debate gradually narrowed down to one question — whether people who don’t enjoy in-game violence simply “can’t” or just “choose not to” — with many pushing back against sweeping generalizations based on national character.
What people said
I don't like it when there aren't set rules
A linear path feels safer
Other than getting saddled with debt at the start, it's all freedom after that
Yeah, because stuff you could do in the last game, you can't do anymore
Just watch foreign players' gameplay videos — they immediately start shooting people, running them over with cars, kicking dogs on the street, laughing the whole time
Before you get to 'Freedom! I'm gonna kick a dog!' you stop and think 'does this even accomplish anything?' — I think that's just why people don't do it
To begin with, there aren't that many people who even try to enjoy committing violent acts in games
And when there are, it's only when some game-like buffer softens it — like the target being invincible or just an object — there's no culture here that treats killing as pleasurable
Tell that to Re: #23 — the one who didn't just leave it at 'it's a game' but brought up 'Japanese people' instead
Is that really okay?
Unlike you, other people can tell the difference between games and reality, so they're fine
Re: #29
What you're saying is contradictory
First you say 'is that really okay?' and then you say 'well, it's up to each person' — what even are you
Re: #29
> If you suddenly drop Japanese players into an environment where anything goes, they freeze up and can't do anything
That's not saying it 'doesn't suit' Japanese people, that's making a huge blanket claim that they 'can't' do it
Is shooting people and kicking dogs in a game really worth picking this big a fight over?
Go read Re: #26 again and think it over
[Breaking] GTA6 is done for because the NPCs are too strong lmaooooooooooooo 😰
https://krsw.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/ghard/1795129028/
NPCs are 'free' enough to teleport and beat a sniping player to death
GTA was always that kind of game to begin with, so what's the point of saying that
It's a shoot-'em-up with gangs and mafia running around in it — what's the point of showing off how 'well-behaved' your national character is?
But don't stop there and go pestering the people who just don't see value in it and don't bother doing it, slapping a 'Japanese people are like this' label on them — cut that out
As for the guy who started the whole 'Japanese people are like this' complaint, yeah, that's exactly what I'm asking — is that really okay?
Isn't the reason the topic stays this shallow just that the setting doesn't grab people's interest?
For example, even Japanese players in Skyrim will test out a newly upgraded weapon on a guard who's just doing his honest job, strip him of everything, and kill an NPC who's done nothing wrong just because they don't like their tone
There was a video that set GTA in Japan that got a lot of buzz
I think a lot of gamers would want to play a GTA-style game set in Japan
There's a whole yakuza film tradition to draw from, after all
Even in Japan, I don't think it would be getting much buzz if streamers weren't playing it
I think people just aren't that interested in American society and can't really relate to it
If it were set in Japan, like Yakuza/Like a Dragon, I think it'd be a lot easier for people to get interested
If you're gonna do it, why not go bigger — like staging a coup against the state, climbing to the top of the country, and waging wars of invasion against other nations?
So the West is finally catching up to Taikou Risshiden (a classic Japanese strategy game about rising from peasant to ruler)?
You're free not to buy it
You're the one fixating on shooting people and kicking dogs on your own
You're just interpreting it however's convenient for you
It's '*if* you're suddenly dropped into an environment where you're told anything goes (freedom)' — that's the point
I never said freedom itself makes people unable to do anything
'If you're suddenly dropped into an environment where you're told anything goes (freedom), Japanese people freeze up and can't do anything'
Is that really the point you're trying to make?
I honestly have no idea what you've been trying to say this whole time
Or what you're even hung up on
> If you suddenly drop Japanese players into an environment where anything goes, they freeze up and can't do anything
What I'm trying to say is simple: 'can't' and 'won't' are different things
This is a game — it's not heavy enough to justify writing something as dramatic as 'can't' the way you did above
'If ID:5O5YOmQM0HAPPY is suddenly dropped into an environment where anything goes, they freeze up and can't do anything'
It's just a matter of doing it or not in a game — it shouldn't go that far
That kind of 'freedom' honestly isn't fun and isn't something I even want
Background and Key Points of This Debate
The GTA series has always sold itself on the freedom of a lawless world built around gangs and mafia, and debate over its depictions of violence has flared up repeatedly overseas as well. The titles raised for comparison in the thread — Animal Crossing, The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild, and Skyrim — all offer plenty of freedom and still became hits in Japan, so a “high degree of freedom” alone can’t fully explain why some games don’t catch on there. Within the thread, several posters pushed back by arguing that not enjoying in-game violence is a separate issue from only being able to act within a rule-bound environment, and many participants questioned the logic behind the claim itself that “Japanese people freeze up when given freedom” — worth keeping in mind while reading.
※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware & Industry / Geha) thread “The reason GTA doesn’t suit Japanese players is that the freedom of not being bound by set rules doesn’t suit Japanese people.”
Leave a Reply