How Much of a Masterpiece Is Gundam SEED, Really? 5ch: “Without the Gundam Name, It’d Be Garbage”

From our other sites

The story

The thread kicked off with a post saying, “I want to talk about what makes Gundam SEED great,” and the discussion spread to cover comparisons with the Universal Century Gundam shows, character assessments, and gripes about the sequel “SEED Destiny.” Posters brought up the story behind how Strike Freedom’s name was changed from an earlier candidate, and noted that the series has posted the best box-office numbers of any Gundam film. But it wasn’t all praise—harsh takes flew in too, like “without the Gundam name, this would be judged as garbage.” Opinions also split over comparisons to Yoshiyuki Tomino’s works and over assessments of director Mitsuo Fukuda’s style.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:30
I want to talk about what makes Gundam SEED, one of the most highly rated Gundam shows, so great
2AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:32
If it ain't Universal Century, it ain't Gundam
3AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:33
Compared to everything that came after, this is as good as it gets
4AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:34
Sure, it's well made, but it's inferior to Unicorn
6AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:36
"Newtype" was always such a vague concept, so "Coordinators"—people born special through genetic engineering—were way easier to understand
7AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:37
They swapped out the heroine, then the sequel just tossed her aside like she wasn't needed anymore—that garbage development killed my enthusiasm
9AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:38
The most hype scene in SEED was when Kira comes back from the dead, suits up in Freedom, and fights for the Earth Forces
10AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:39
Strike Freedom is just way too strong
21AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:43
Re: #10
Every time I hear "Strike Freedom" it sounds like a Salisbury steak dish and I can't help laughing
11AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:39
Kagari's voice actress actually complained to the director, saying she couldn't accept her character being treated that way
12AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:40
They bolted way too much extra junk onto that mobile suit—seems like it'd catch way too much air resistance to move well in the atmosphere
13AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:40
Athrun's basically a player who swaps girlfriends left and right
15AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:42
The Gundam where the characters go full nudist in the theme song
16AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:42
Making the previous series' protagonist the final boss sounds like a hype concept for SEED Destiny, but… what even was that?
17AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:42
At least it's got fewer haters than the Fukui-written Gundam shows (novelist Harutoshi Fukui, who wrote Unicorn and Narrative)
18AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:42
It's got the top box office of any Gundam movie, so isn't it the most popular?
19AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:42
They even made a brand new movie, and it's the highest-grossing Gundam film ever—the franchise just can't top SEED anymore
20AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:43
The script's basically a rehash of Tomino's Gundam, yet it gets treated as a masterpiece, lol—it's just fujoshi (female Gundam fangirls) making noise
23AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:44
What was Rau Le Creuset's actual goal, anyway?
26AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:45
If SEED or Unicorn were original, non-Gundam stories, nobody would rate them this high—without the Gundam name, they'd be garbage
28AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:46
The only positive thing about SEED Destiny is that Shinn and Lunamaria's voice actors actually got married in real life
31AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:47
I can't even remember the face of the guy who was originally supposed to pilot Strike
32AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:48
Re: #21
It was originally going to be called "Super Freedom Gundam," but because of the "Super Free" scandal (a notorious 2003 Waseda University gang-rape case), they changed it to "Strike Freedom"
36AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:50
Normal people actually watch SEED, but something like Unicorn only gets watched by hardcore fans
44AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:54
Re: #36
Normal people don't watch Gundam at all, come on
45AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:55
The sequel suffered because Destiny, not the Chairman, was the final boss
47AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:56
Re: #45
I really wish they'd stop making bosses who can't even fight
48AnonymousNov 19, 2026 11:57
Gundam should've been sealed away for good after Char's Counterattack
52AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:03
Re: #48
Huh? It's succeeded as a massive franchise though
51AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:03
In 00 there's this girl who's constantly trying to kiss the hero, and it felt so "otaku anime"-ish that I dropped it—does SEED not have that kind of thing?
53AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:04
Re: #51
SEED's got its own horny characters too
60AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:12
Re: #51
If anything, SEED's otaku content is even higher
62AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:16
GQuuuuuuX was boring—just like Eva, it was great at the start and fizzled out from there
64AnonymousNov 19, 2026 12:21
Re: #62
You mean the one where the director's a Nogizaka48 otaku and stuffed it full of Nogizaka references?

Background and Key Points of This Discussion

Mobile Suit Gundam SEED aired in 2002, and its introduction of “Coordinators”—genetically engineered humans—in place of the abstract “Newtype” concept is credited with making the setting easier to grasp. Its sequel, SEED DESTINY, drew mixed reactions for making the previous series’ protagonist the final boss, and opinions split in the thread as well. On the naming of Strike Freedom, posters noted that an earlier candidate name was dropped because it resembled the name of a real-life scandal—behind-the-scenes trivia that’s hard to follow for readers unfamiliar with the series. The thread also touched on how the theatrical film series has posted major box-office numbers in recent years, feeding into the view that “the franchise can no longer top SEED.” At the same time, harsher opinions argued that “without the Gundam name, it wouldn’t be rated this highly,” and the thread was split between valuing the work’s own quality versus crediting the series’ brand power.

*This article was compiled by excerpting and summarizing the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “How Much of a Masterpiece Is Gundam SEED, Really?“

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *