From our other sites
The story
Yamaya, best known for its spicy cod roe (karashi mentaiko), has announced on its official website that it will not limit the number of rice refills at its affiliated all-you-can-eat restaurants. The statement was prompted by a viral social media post claiming a customer was banned from a store after asking for 15 rice refills, though Yamaya says it has been unable to confirm that any such ban actually occurred. On 5ch, the thread mixed skepticism that the post was fabricated (‘uso-matsu,’ slang for a suspiciously self-aggrandizing made-up story) with debate over how explicitly stores should set rules for big-eating customers and all-you-can-eat etiquette.
[Full article] Yamaya affirms it will continue its all-you-can-eat service, says rice refills will have ‘no limit,’ statement issued in response to SNS post – Sports Nippon
November 18, 2026, 13:58 — Sponichi Annex News Team
Yamaya, which runs “Yamaya Communications” and manufactures and sells spicy cod roe, issued a statement on its official website on the 18th regarding a social media post concerning the all-you-can-eat service at its restaurant chain.
Source: sponichi.co.jp / Read the original article here
What people said
Probably fabricated (uso-matsu).
If she's a woman who can eat 15 bowls of rice and loves posting on social media,
she should've been spamming big-eating brag posts and already gone viral for that.
But there's no past history of big-eating brag posts from her at all, is there?
They can't even confirm it happened — so what exactly is there to 'un-ban'?
The store itself would know, so they should just check whether she was really banned or not.
You think HQ didn't check with the actual store?
Sometimes you just let it go to smooth things over. The truth disappears into the dark.
s://pbs.twimg.com/media/HW0D6lSbwAA23-o.jpg
The guy who was lecturing everyone about manners is about to transform into a troublemaker and show up himself.
Unlimited refills aren't even unusual — would that really cause a flood of people?
The only unusual thing here was the woman who claimed (likely fabricated/uso-matsu) that she got banned.
If there's a flood of trouble, they can just end the service then. This incident alone is too weak a reason to end it now.
There are plenty of people these days who exploit loopholes in the rules or just act outrageously.
Unless someone's smuggling food out in a container, there's a natural limit to how much rice a person can eat. People who go wildly beyond that are extremely rare.
The store itself put out a statement saying it's fine — it's not your place to complain about it.
If they were going to set conditions, they shouldn't have advertised 'eat all you like' in the first place. And besides, the store already said it won't set conditions, so your complaint is misdirected.
That 'reading the room' era basically ended by the early Showa period — that was the surveillance-society era of neighborhood watch groups (tonarigumi) and the like. We're not in that kind of era anymore, so now it's more of an 'as long as I'm fine, that's all that matters' mindset. My grandparents didn't get along, but my grandma just gritted her teeth and endured it because divorce looked bad to the neighbors. I don't think that era was actually a good one.
The most harmful type is the person who's convinced they're one of the considerate, room-reading ones, but whose idea of 'reading the room' is completely off the mark. (´・ω・`)
It's near a university, so I'm sure there were definitely people who went on massive eating binges.
Free extra noodles just puts light eaters at a disadvantage — better to make the first extra serving free and charge for any after that.
That wasn't because of binge eaters — it's because flour prices went up sharply.
With that beef bowl chain thing — the store itself even made a poster saying 'feel free to eat it this way,' and then some totally unrelated third party started making a fuss calling it bad manners lol
From the store's perspective it's probably like, 'who gave you the authority to push your own personal rules on everyone else?'
The fact that the store doesn't ban it — or even recommends it — doesn't make it any less tacky on a personal level. The guy who piled his bowl with mountains of red pickled ginger just earned himself disapproval, that's all.
'Tacky' is a subjective judgment — you need to understand that first.
Slapping a label on something based on your own subjective view, then mistaking that for an objective, universal opinion — how shallow is that. You should start by questioning your own 'common sense.'
All that happened is he did something others found distasteful and got disapproval for it, yet he's retreating hard into victim mentality.
A collection of individual subjective views is literally what makes up the general, common viewpoint.
At an order-style buffet, someone ate more than 20 servings of ice cream, and after that, ice cream disappeared from the menu entirely.
There has to be a limit! Big eaters are nothing but a nuisance!
The 'limit' is something the store decides, not something you decide.
And the store has explicitly said it's continuing the service.
A YouTuber who binge-ate at the restaurant mentioned in Re: #90 said that at first the bowls were chilled, but as the refills kept coming, they switched to room-temperature bowls — commenting along the way, 'they probably ran out of what they'd prepared,' while still asking for more refills. And apparently they casually mentioned that the next time they visited, ice cream had vanished from the menu.
Unbelievable.
Every all-you-can-eat restaurant should post a 'no competitive eaters' notice.
Yamaya's actual position is that they can't even confirm the ban happened, so the whole point of contention is different.
You're still arguing a hypothetical lol.
Can you not understand that your standard for 'tacky' differs from other people's? Your subjective opinion isn't shared by the majority, you know?
For example:
– Crowding into a New Year's sale is tacky
– Lining up from the morning for a free gift limited to the first 100 people is tacky
– Diligently collecting points is tacky
– Eating until you're full at an all-you-can-eat place is tacky
– Taking refills at a free-refill place is tacky
– Buying discounted items at the supermarket is tacky
…and so on.
Everyone draws the line between 'tacky' and 'not tacky' differently, based on their own subjective view. What YOU think is tacky is just your own personal rule — it's not a shared understanding with everyone else. You need to understand that first, or people will start avoiding you as a self-righteous person.
You're really the type to retreat into feeling like a victim of baseless persecution, huh.
Both the beef bowl chain case and this one — far from being 'self-righteous,' plenty of people shared the same reaction. He just did something tacky and earned disapproval for it. Why won't you just accept that reality?
They said on TV the other day that mentaiko hasn't gone up in price as much as other foods, so it's fine.
Isn't it just unsold leftover stock? Not that I'd know.
Background and key points of this discussion
Yamaya is best known for its spicy cod roe (mentaiko), but this statement concerns its affiliated all-you-can-eat restaurant business, a separate matter from its core mentaiko operations. The statement was prompted by a viral social media post claiming someone was banned from a restaurant after asking for 15 rice refills, but since Yamaya says it cannot even confirm that a ban actually took place, the truth of the original post remains unconfirmed. On the thread, skepticism toward the post ran alongside debate over how explicitly restaurants should codify rules for handling big-eating customers, with some users drawing comparisons to the earlier controversy over red pickled ginger toppings at a beef bowl chain. There was also a note that ramen shops limiting free extra noodle servings is often due to rising flour prices rather than measures against big eaters — worth not confusing the two.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News Flash+) thread “[🍚] Yamaya affirms it will continue all-you-can-eat service, states no limit on rice refills, statement issued in response to SNS post.”

Leave a Reply