Koto Takai Set to Leave Tottenham — 5ch: “He Totally Picked the Wrong Club”

From our other sites

The story

British media have reported that Japan international defender Koto Takai, currently with Tottenham Hotspur, could be set to leave the club. Takai joined from Kawasaki Frontale for around ¥900 million (roughly $6 million) in the summer of 2025, but has made only a single Premier League appearance, against Crystal Palace. He is currently out on a second loan spell this season at Belgian top-flight side Sint-Truiden, where he is reportedly continuing to struggle. On 5ch, commenters weighed in on his choice of destination club and the difficulty of adapting to European football, with opinions split between “he should have gone to Belgium sooner” and “it’s too early to judge him when he hasn’t even been given playing time.”

Japan international defender Koto Takai, who came up through Kawasaki Frontale, is currently on loan from Tottenham Hotspur at Belgian top-flight club Sint-Truiden (STVV). With him struggling even at his loan destination, talk has turned to the possibility that he could leave Tottenham for good.

British outlet Football FanCast reported on the 16th that Takai “joined Tottenham from Kawasaki for £5 million (about ¥900 million) in the summer of 2025, but his only Premier League squad appearance came against Crystal Palace in December 2025,” noting the impact of a slow start caused by poor physical condition, before adding the following:

“He was loaned to Borussia Monchengladbach in the second half of last season and sent back out on loan to STVV this season, failing to convince manager Roberto De Zerbi. He will never wear a Tottenham shirt again. The club is expected to cash in on him in January 2027 or at the end of the season.”

Source: football-tribe.com / Original article here

What people said

3AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:29
A player who can't even cut it in Belgium
4AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:30
Guess he didn't develop as much as hoped.
Center-backs can be late bloomers, but injuries are brutal.
Tomiyasu probably won't get another national team call-up either.
6AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:30
He had offers from other clubs too, but got lured in by the Premier League bait and picked Tottenham.
Totally picked the wrong club.
7AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:30
A player of this caliber actually got into Tottenham?
Must've been chasing that Japan money.
8AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:30
Somebody give Oda some advice — he's about to choose the thorny road too.
20AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:37
Re: #8
Takai went straight from the J.League to Europe, so wouldn't that backfire on him?
77AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:24
Re: #8
Bet that blowhard quietly ends up at the "Phantom Giants" after stalling for time, lol (a dig calling the Yomiuri Giants baseball team 虚人 "empty/fake men" instead of 巨人 "giant men")
10AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:33
If Hotspur ("hot spa") isn't working out,
go to Cool Sauna instead (a pun riffing on "Hotspur" sounding like "hot spa")
13AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:34
Re: #10
I was about to write that he should just go to Cool Poco instead (continuing the hot/cool joke — Cool Poco is a Japanese comedy duo)
12AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:34
Guess you get written off if you haven't built a track record in Europe.
Or maybe his lack of progress with the language made him look unmotivated.
14AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:35
He looked like a lump of pure potential when I saw him with the national team — funny how things turn out (a play on words: 鎌足/Kamatari echoing 塊/kamari, "a lump [of potential]")
15AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:36
Maybe he should just go back to Kawasaki —
that team's defense is way too leaky.
16AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:36
Should've just gone to Sint-Truiden from the start.
18AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:37
A second loan spell is basically a one-way ticket at this point.
Wouldn't be surprised if this turns into a permanent move to Sint-Truiden.
19AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:37
Thanks to Son Heung-min they've raked in a ton of Korean money and huge popularity among Korean fans,
so this time they probably figured a Japanese player like Takai could do the same for Japan money and popularity with Japanese fans.
22AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:38
He was at his absolute brightest when he shut down Cristiano Ronaldo in the ACL (AFC Champions League).
23AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:38
Oh, it was already mentioned —
even Totoro (a cute nickname for Sint-Truiden/STVV) isn't working out for him?
24AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:38
Seems like he's taking it easy out there.
Guess going back to the J.League is the only option left.
25AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:38
Come to think of it, same with Ryunosuke — if you're heading to Europe in your early twenties, Belgium's the move.
Or else the Netherlands or Bundesliga 2.
Young players shouldn't even consider anything outside those three options.
31AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:43
Re: #25
Even at Celtic, winning a starting spot is seriously competitive.
Getting actual playing time, and gauging how strong your rivals within the squad are, matters a lot.
45AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:48
Re: #25
Most of the national team regulars — Endo, Minamino, Ueda, Mitoma, Doan, Tanaka, Tomiyasu, Itakura — basically all took that route.
Kagawa's Dortmund situation was just a special case.
26AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:40
Thomas Frank aside, getting written off by De Zerbi too — a coach who's all about build-up play — is rough.
27AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:40
Not even cutting it in Belgium — that's really rough.
29AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:42
Kita, Ichihara, Takai — none of the young center-backs are breaking through. Tough outlook from here.
40AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:46
Re: #29
Kita at Real Sociedad B looks the most promising.
Ichihara's still a notch behind.
46AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:49
Re: #29
Pinning hopes on the younger generation — Motosuna, Mendy, lefty Takeuchi, that group.
41AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:47
It ended in a flash because of injuries.
Miyaichi got cursed by injuries too —
Japanese players just can't handle a league like the Premier League where even training involves brutal physical contact.
Better to go through Belgium first to get used to it before anything else.
53AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:56
Re: #41
Takai, buddy! How about first toughening back up with Hiroshima's training — the kind so brutal they say you could wring money out of it?
56AnonymousNov 17, 2026 16:57
I say this every time, but Sint-Truiden may technically be "overseas," but it's really just a favoritism slot — not a club worth going abroad for.
There are guys who stepped up after going through Sint-Truiden, but I have my doubts it was actually because of Sint-Truiden.
70AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:19
Re: #56
They've contributed to Japanese soccer more than anyone else in recent years, though.
66AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:17
Re: #60
I had zero memory of Nakamura ever being there.
Was he the only Japanese player that year?
69AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:18
Re: #66
It was like a six-month loan, so he only played a handful of games.
78AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:24
I'm an Antlers fan here — please trade us Sekigawa for him.
80AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:26
Re: #78
Go develop Udemba instead.
79AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:25
Tottenham, known for their player development, signed him, so he must have some talent.
Not sure what exactly Takai's missing though.
84AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:29
Re: #79
Tottenham doesn't really have that reputation.
Even Kane grew up through loan-spell hell — it's not like "Kaspa" actually developed him.
93AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:46
Kawasaki Frontale players just don't cut it abroad.
94AnonymousNov 17, 2026 17:49
Re: #93
Wao's doing just fine over there, though.

Background and Key Points of This Discussion

Takai joined Tottenham from Kawasaki Frontale in the summer of 2025 for an estimated transfer fee of around ¥900 million, and the size of that fee alone made him a player of considerable expectation and attention. However, he has made just a single Premier League appearance, and has instead spent his time seeking match action in Europe’s second-tier leagues — on loan at Borussia Monchengladbach in the second half of last season, and now back out on loan at Sint-Truiden this season. In the thread, questions about his transfer strategy — specifically “which club to choose” — stood out even ahead of concerns about his own adaptability or physical condition, with commenters drawing comparisons to established national team regulars who eased into European football via less high-profile leagues such as Belgium, the Netherlands, or Germany’s second division. At the same time, some voices questioned Tottenham’s development environment itself, or whether he suits manager Roberto De Zerbi’s tactical approach, so it’s worth noting that this isn’t necessarily being concluded as a simple lack of ability on Takai’s part. It should also be noted that the original article’s phrase “he will never wear the shirt again” is not a confirmed decision but rather a local media outlet’s assessment.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisportsokuho+) thread “[Soccer] Koto Takai Set to Leave Tottenham! “Not at Premier League Level” — Who Are the Transfer Candidates?“

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *