From our other sites
The story
Jubilo Iwata faced Shonan Bellmare in matchday 16 of the J2 League on November 8, taking an early lead in the first half only to concede an equalizer in the 44th minute of the second half, finishing in a 1-1 draw. After the match, manager Tadahiro Akiba made an unusual statement directed at some supporters in the stadium: “If you’re not going to cheer, or if you’re just going to drag the team down, then please don’t bother coming at all.” On 5ch, reactions split between those who saw it as “a manager snapping back at paying customers” and those who called it “a fair response to troublesome regulars who do nothing but jeer without actually cheering.” The thread also expanded into a broader debate about J.League’s unique supporter culture and whether clubs should prioritize casual fans or hardcore supporters.
Nov. 8 (Sun), 21:56 — FOOTBALL ZONE
Jubilo Iwata hosted Shonan Bellmare at home in matchday 16 of the J2 League on November 8, and the match ended in a 1-1 draw. Speaking in the post-match flash interview, manager Tadahiro Akiba addressed the mood in the stadium right after the team let a win slip away with a late concession, sending an unusual message to some supporters: “If you’re not going to cheer, or if you’re just going to drag the team down, then please don’t bother coming at all.”
In the 45th minute of the first half, Iwata attacked down the left side, and midfielder Yuri Lala reacted fastest to a loose ball in front of the goal, hitting a first-time shot. It deflected off a defender and found the net, putting Iwata ahead. However, in the 44th minute of the second half, with the win seemingly in hand at 1-0, Iwata conceded a crushing equalizer to defender Yuto Suzuki — facing his former club, no less — and missed out on all three points.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Was there something different about this one?
Akiba's been in the sports world a long time too, after all.
J.League has its own unique culture of 'supportahs' publicly airing their grievances.
Kind of like a train-spotting otaku lecturing a station attendant.
I don't know about Iwata's supporters specifically, but there are groups out there that cause a ton of trouble for people around them.
Like Akiba mentioned, the worst-case outcome is new fans staying away because of it — stories like that occasionally make the rounds on social media.
J.League's sense of what's acceptable seems off.
Sounds like he was angry at the dirty-jeering troublesome regulars, not the core supporters.
20. Anonymous Iwata fan @at the stadium 2026.11.8 21:35
ID: M4MTBjYmZi >35 >58
There's a group in part of the goal-end stands who don't cheer, don't wear jerseys, and just stand there with their arms crossed during the match — only getting fired up when there's a mistake or a loss.
Sounds like those guys didn't just boo this time, they apparently said something, and that's what set the players off.
Good on you, Akiba. I'm with you on this!
Is it not okay to snap at people hurling dirty jeers?
He's telling them to come at him directly, so I guess it's a one-on-one showdown?
Article says Akiba's point was: if you've got complaints, direct them at me, the manager.
Not to be that guy, but
doesn't J.League tolerate exactly that kind of thing as 'passionate fans'?
They praise hardcore overseas supporters whose whole deal is causing trouble as the good fans who bring the energy.
Every club routinely bans people like that, though.
I don't want a president who tolerates customer harassment ('kasuhara').
Over there, booing during the match happens, but the only ones still kicking up a fuss after the final whistle are hooligan types who are more into causing chaos than into the football itself.
In England, when it's clearly a lost cause, people just leave before the match even ends.
J.League supporters are basically a mix of Premier League-style rowdiness and Bundesliga-style organized chanting.
Huh, that's surprisingly tame.
Plenty of Hanshin Tigers fans in Japan won't even leave with two outs in the bottom of the ninth.
The ones who got called out are exactly the types who aren't there for the football in the first place.
Kind of like that Blue Jays guy, Guerrero, saying something like 'I'll only give my best for the people who truly support me.'
Makes you want to ask what being a pro is even for.
Fans come in all types — some people are just there to watch the football, plain and simple.
Talk like that, and you'll cap your crowd at 2,000.
That's football culture for you — they openly call supporters the '12th player.'
Apparently overseas, people will just walk up to you on the street and say 'You lost, so go practice,' according to Nagatomo.
That's exactly why it's the most popular sport in the world, though. Deny that, and you're in trouble.
He's saying the exact opposite of what the times call for, lol.
This is just going to push casual fans even further away.
Go watch the interview on X.
He's angry that people are doing things that drive casual fans away.
The Japan national team, a while back:
'So close!'
'Just one step away!'
'There's always next time!'
'Go get 'em!'
'Man, we were weak back then.'
Now? Who cares!
Nonomura's the one who's been saying casual fans aren't even needed in the first place.
Then what's the point of adding more matches at the National Stadium and inviting people in?
Some jobless idiot playing armchair Chairman Nonomura is just lame, lol.
they really should stop doing that.
The distance between players and fans matters.
The greeting itself is fine, but handing over the megaphone and having the player air his feelings is unnecessary.
It sounds dramatic, but it feels like a real fork-in-the-road moment.
There are all kinds of people out there.
What they have in common is that even the people hurling jeers paid money to watch.
If you keep excluding people like that, things turn cult-like and off-putting, and you end up alienating the wider public —
kind of like what happens with idol groups.
I don't know if that's a good thing or a bad thing, though.
It's about where you draw the line, right? Cross this point and you're out — violence, death threats, that kind of thing.
If you're going to snap over mere booing, you shouldn't call yourself a pro sport.
Even Kashima, with their ridiculously lenient punishment the other day, still banned people, lol.
Did the guy who ran onto the pitch and punched Honda ever get banned, I wonder?
Background and Key Points of This Debate
Booing itself isn’t unusual in the J.League, but what’s easy to miss from the headline alone is that manager Akiba’s complaint wasn’t aimed at ordinary supporters jeering — it was directed at what’s described as a segment of “regulars in the goal-end stands” who don’t wear jerseys, don’t cheer, watch with their arms crossed, and only raise their voices when there’s a mistake or a goal conceded. The thread drew a contrast with football-watching culture in England (where some fans simply give up and leave before the final whistle, while those who keep up the abuse get written off as hooligans), highlighting a gap with how J.League has historically emphasized supporters as a “12th player.” The debate also touched on club-management questions — whether to prioritize growing the casual fanbase or catering to hardcore supporters — which surfaced as differing reactions to comments from J.League Chairman Nonomura. No single conclusion was reached.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “[J.League] Manager Akiba Angry at Some Supporters: ‘Don’t Get the Wrong Idea,’ ‘If You’re Not Going to Cheer, Don’t Bother Coming’.”
Leave a Reply