From our other sites
The story
Vissel Kobe goalkeeper Gonda Shuichi, in an interview, questioned the modern soccer trend of prizing a GK’s “footwork/distribution skills” above all else, saying that focus is “actually unique to Japan.” His point: a keeper who can’t stop shots should never be rated highly, yet in Japan all the attention goes to passing ability. On 5ch, many pushed back by pointing to top overseas keepers like Neuer and Ederson as proof that footwork is valued worldwide too — while others raised the recent debate over Zion Suzuki’s save performances and the view that Japanese youth development tends to overrate small, technical players, splitting the discussion.
Kobe GK Gonda Shuichi lays out his own theory on the footwork skills now demanded of modern goalkeepers
In football in recent years, a goalkeeper’s “footwork technique” has rapidly grown in importance. In an era that praises keepers for joining the attack as essentially an extra field player, Vissel Kobe’s Gonda Shuichi — who has also played in Europe — quietly feels something is off about that trend. We dig into a theory of goalkeeping that only looks genuine coming from someone who has actually fought on the field. (Reporting and text by Yusuke Konishi, FOOTBALL ZONE editorial team / Part 2 of 5)
“What is the true essence of being a goalkeeper?”
Source: football-zone.net / Original article here
What people said
The point is it's meaningless unless you're at that level
As power and speed keep climbing like they have in other sports, there's no stopping this trend no matter what
Ederson: "Yeah, fair."
Ter Stegen: "Yeah, fair."
Zion: "…Is that really so?"
I don't really picture Ederson making many saves
but I guess that's unavoidable since he's just that dominant
Does Gonda actually know much about goalkeeping at Europe's elite clubs and top leagues?
Does he know much about the coaching and players at Japan's youth level?
Ogihara's face is faintly coming to mind (riffing on the meme phrase "it faintly comes to mind")
Japanese soccer is attacking soccer — building up from the keeper, raising possession, seizing the initiative, and breaking teams down with passing!!
Well, saving shots is just the baseline since he's a pro — build-up play is the extra factor layered on top that gets evaluated, isn't it?
Gonda, forget soccer, is your reading comprehension okay?
"Just the baseline"…
There's a real gap between an 80 and a 100, you know?
Does "baseline" mean you think everyone's tied at 100 on shot-stopping?
You're the one with the weak reading comprehension here.
That said, judging who's better at "saving ability" gets really technical — you'd probably need to be at goalkeeping-coach level to call it.
Footwork skill, on the other hand, even an amateur can spot at a glance.
So it's entirely plausible that on the ground, at scouting level, something like "can't tell who saves better between these two, but this guy's footwork is better so he gets picked" is actually happening.
Rather than demanding build-up play from the GK, I'd rather
field players practiced their throw-ins a bit more.
Is there even a single strong team out there that's bad at throw-ins?
That's a case of the means becoming the end.
Thought that was a Japanese specialty (e.g., "running soccer"), but I guess it's the same overseas too
The experts are saying those were no-chance shots the GK had no way of reaching anyway.
Ever since the World Cup it's been nothing but no-chance shots — poor Zion (´；ω；｀)
Someone who's never even properly played soccer, let alone gone pro,
is using Gonda as ammunition to pontificate about world soccer
Goalkeeping really was Japan's weak spot for ages.
Kawashima especially was the type to roar and fly off the handle even when a goal was his own fault
Background and key points of this debate
In recent years, goalkeepers for Europe’s top clubs and for national teams that regularly feature in the Champions League have come under strong pressure to show “footwork skill” — joining the attack through passing and build-up play. This stems from high-press, possession-oriented tactics becoming mainstream, with the GK effectively treated as an 11th field player. That said, as pointed out in the thread, elite keepers like Neuer, Ederson, and Ter Stegen are world-class not just at footwork but at shot-stopping too — so it isn’t simply a case of “they play because they’re good with their feet.” Gonda’s comment is really aimed at a Japan-specific concern, that domestic youth development tends to overrate passing over saving, and isn’t a rejection of the broader overseas trend itself — a nuance that’s easy to misread.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “[Soccer] The “footwork-first” trend is “actually unique to Japan” — Gonda Shuichi sounds the alarm… modern soccer’s blind spot: “the thing pros need least”“.
Leave a Reply