From our other sites
The story
A thread on 5ch asking users to name the “most overrated food, honestly” took off, with sushi sparking the biggest debate. Nominations ranged widely, including sushi (“it’s just raw fish on rice”), Jiro-style ramen, and Turkish cuisine (“supposedly one of the world’s three great cuisines, but all anyone actually knows is kebab and ice cream”). On sushi, opinions split hard between those calling it “mass-produced fast food” and those defending it as “an art form that brings together diverse ingredients into one shape,” with the debate even reaching back to its Edo-period origins. Commenters also raised doubts about other supposedly high-end foods, including Shine Muscat grapes, Kyoto cuisine, and eel.
What people said
It's just raw fish on rice
You're not a construction worker, you don't need that much white rice
Eat ten pieces and that's basically a large bowl of rice anyway
It was originally cheap fast food meant to fill you up on rice
Don't need that stuff
That's not the point
It just lacks variety as a dish
It's nothing but raw fish and rice
Add anything more and it's not sushi anymore
If anything, it's an art form that pulls together countless ingredients into one shape
It's literally just sliced
Ridiculously expensive with basically no flavor
I always bring my own dark soy sauce and just dump it on
Some people just get the wrong idea and act all pretentious about it
In America, sushi's considered a health food
trace it back and it's basically the McDonald's of the Edo period
My oshi [favorite idol] was really into it for a while, so I tried it just to have something to talk about
Honestly, it was a total nothing food lol
Anyone paying over 3000 yen for that stuff is an idiot
It always just tastes like sports-drink-flavored grapes to me
Kyoho grapes taste way more like actual grapes
Everything's turned into a sugar-content-above-all-else cult these days
Feels like eating wax
Background and Key Points
Nigiri sushi is said to have spread during the Edo period as a quick, casual meal sold from street stalls — a very different origin from today’s high-end sushi restaurant culture. The thread reflected that divide, with opinions split right down the middle between “it started as cheap fast food” and appreciation for the technique behind nigiri and its combinations of ingredients. Some pointed out that in America, sushi has become established as a health food, underscoring how the same dish can be valued completely differently depending on the country and era. Shine Muscat grapes are a branded variety marketed on their high sugar content, but some commenters questioned the very obsession with sweetness itself — an angle that’s easy to overlook, since it puts the underlying assumption that “expensive equals delicious” up for debate. The observation that Turkish cuisine, despite being called one of the world’s three great cuisines, is known to most people only through kebab and ice cream is also an interesting example of the gap between reputation and actual familiarity.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Honestly, the #1 Most Overrated Food Is wwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwwww.”
Leave a Reply