From our other sites
The story
On TBS’s “Matsuko’s Unknown World,” Matsuko Deluxe introduced Akira Toriyama’s “Dr. Slump” as something that “blew her mind,” remarking that “if you just dismiss it with a word like ‘stylish,’ it sounds cheap — it felt less like manga and more like incredible design art,” comments that sparked discussion on 5ch’s Geinou/Sports News+ board. Toriyama died in 2024 at age 68. On the thread, many posters rated “Dr. Slump”‘s artwork above “Dragon Ball”‘s, with some arguing his drawing skill peaked around the “Chrono Trigger” or “Dragon Quest IV” era, and others tracing the evolution of his style in detail — including how his technique of drawing teeth and gums when characters opened their mouths wide went on to influence later manga.
Nov 17 (Tue), 9:55 PM
Talent Matsuko Deluxe (54) appeared on TBS’s “Matsuko’s Unknown World” (Tuesdays, 8:55 PM), which aired on the 17th, and revealed a manga that “blew her mind.”
The episode covered “manga symbols” used in comics, and when the talk turned to Akira Toriyama — who died in 2024 at age 68 — she said, “If you just dismiss it with a word like ‘stylish,’ it sounds cheap — Toriyama’s work felt less like manga and more like incredible design art.”
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Even in DB, before Goku grew up, there was that one-of-a-kind Toriyama mecha work too.
After the Cell arc it started feeling like he was just being forced to keep drawing.
Kinnikuman
Dr. Slump
One Piece
How old were you when you stopped buying Jump?
Dunno about now, but back then they ran 3 new series every 10 weeks,
so even a crappy series would get about 10 weeks on the shelf.
Give me your horse racing picks — I'll just bet the opposite of whatever you say.
but it was popular with absolutely everyone — people were drawing their own Arale portraits, it was a massive boom whether anyone says so or not.
That's some seriously impressive reading comprehension you've got there.
Exactly, lol.
"Toriyama IS Dr. Slump"… yeah, I already know that.
He was on Tetsuko's Room (the iconic talk show) back during the Dr. Slump era, too.
He probably really wanted to pump out a ton of mecha with the Poipoi Capsule.
Sorry, it's Hoipoi Capsule.
Better correct that or someone's gonna chew me out.
Feels like the Dragon Quest IV era was the real peak to me.
The art in Sand Land was ridiculously good too, though.
For cool-looking art, yeah, that was the peak.
The pacing's great, you can blow through it in one go.
The good stuff is only up through volume 16.
Sure, Dr. Slump brought in that technique of drawing the back teeth and dental detail in 3D when a character opens their mouth wide.
But we didn't need an okama (slang here for Matsuko, a cross-dressing TV personality) telling us it "revolutionized manga."
That's often said these days, but emphasizing the inside of the mouth
was already a popular technique in "Otoko Oidon," "Gaki Deka," "Makoto-chan," and others —
so at the time, I didn't personally find it all that revolutionary.
Hisashi Eguchi — Susume!! Pirates
and then comes
Akira Toriyama — Dr. Slump
that's how it goes.
Exactly.
For illustration-style characters, wasn't Macaroni Horenso first?
And the one who was directly influenced by it was Hisashi Eguchi.
Pure art, honestly.
That's what sent the bar for drawing fundamentals demanded of Japanese manga artists
shooting way up.
Artists who couldn't keep up either got weeded out
or retreated into ecchi stuff, only practicing women's bodies.
His drawings are completely in motion.
There's no other manga artist like that.
The invention of the Special Beam Cannon (Makankōsappō).
I skipped through Dragon Ball too.
Oh look at me, being a contrarian, so cool.
he's actually a guy who quit his design company job with zero manga experience,
and entered a Shueisha rookie contest he happened to notice just to make ends meet,
and that's how he became a manga artist.
Maybe the most successful NEET (not in education, employment, or training) of all time.
By Dragon Ball, he'd learned how to cut corners.
Apparently Super Saiyan was invented because he wanted to cut corners (less hair to draw/color).
Also, whenever drawing something got tedious, his solution was just to blow it up.
And it had this gentle world with no real villains in it.
Jump still had a lot of hardcore fighting manga back then,
so I think it struck just the right balance.
> And it had this gentle world with no real villains in it
Torishima (his editor, also known by the nickname Mashirito): "Facts."
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
Akira Toriyama passed away in March 2024 at age 68, so this discussion carries something of a memorial undertone as well. Matsuko’s comments make “Dr. Slump” sound like a “hidden gem only now being rediscovered,” but as posters in the thread point out, that’s a bit misleading — the series was already a nationwide sensation back in the early 1980s alongside its anime adaptation, popular enough that “everyone was drawing their own version of Arale’s face,” and it was fully appreciated at the time. The thread’s debate breaks down into two main points: first, whether “Dr. Slump” or “Dragon Ball” shows off the stronger draftsmanship, and second, when Toriyama’s artistic peak actually fell, with several posters pointing to the “Chrono Trigger” or “Dragon Quest IV” era. As for the claim that his technique of drawing the inside of a character’s mouth influenced later manga, some pushed back, noting similar techniques existed before Toriyama — so the simple “revolutionary” framing draws some disagreement too.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “Matsuko on ‘Dr. Slump’: “It blew my mind — might be my favorite.” “Toriyama’s work felt less like manga, more like incredible design art.”.”

Leave a Reply