From our other sites
The story
An article about a pregnant woman with children who had reserved a seat at a food court by leaving a handkerchief on the table, only to have another family take it while she was buying food, sparked a debate on 5ch over whether “saving a seat with an object” is acceptable at all. Opinions clashed without any consensus: some argued that “a handkerchief has no real binding power, so if the seat’s open, sitting there is fair game,” while others countered that “some venues actually recommend securing a seat in advance during busy times.” The thread eventually drifted into a practical battle of ideas for finding a handkerchief substitute that wouldn’t blow away in the wind.
FORZA STYLE
“Humor is a gentleman’s virtue”
“Excuse me, that’s the seat we saved” — A pregnant woman with children saved a food court seat with a handkerchief. The “unbelievable behavior” of the family that took it while she was buying food 【Expert opinion】
Source: forzastyle.com / Original article here
What people said
With a handkerchief, there's a real chance someone just moves it aside and sits down
Lol, the wind can blow it away sometimes
Also, saving a seat in advance is technically bad manners, you know
Apparently some venues actually recommend securing a seat first
Chain cafes in the city center all say "please check for a seat first" these days
Everywhere's packed like crazy, so it's totally normal to order and then not be able to sit down
I put down a crumpled-up tissue pack
Stuffed with gross-looking tissue paper that looks like someone blew their nose in it, so nobody wants to eat at that table
Some people just don't care either way
At least clean up after yourself… maybe I'll just toss it out of the kindness of my heart
On a crowded day, grabbing a seat first is the rational move
Not true at all
It just makes the congestion worse
Even in a situation where you could sit down with zero wait if nobody saved seats
A single seat-saver can be enough to trigger a whole queue
You get a mass of people standing around holding trays, so it's not as orderly as a line at a bank ATM
At other restaurants too, you order after you're seated — they don't take your order and start cooking before you've actually got a seat
That's just how it works
Whether you're with kids or pregnant has nothing to do with it
Sure, it's rough if you've got nobody to hold the seat, but isn't the actual etiquette to buy your food first and then go find a seat?
So you're fine with the place filling up with "seatless refugees" who've got their food but nowhere to sit?
At places that get really packed these days, the venue itself tells you to secure a seat first
Re: #80
If a handkerchief doesn't count as valid, I guess it's fine to sit at any remaining seats even when there's a seat-holder there
Just lay down a doormat instead
No no, a futon would be better
A futon's hard to carry around, so how about an otaku-style body pillow (a "dakimakura," often printed with anime characters)?
https://image.rakuten.co.jp/itsumostore/cabinet/develop/x1/ja/ja080x1_2.jpg
It's kind of scary how, in his mind, putting a newspaper on a bench makes it his for the whole day
There's also the mindset of "I'm sitting here, so it's my seat" — same logic, different angle
All you've got is a bag, a phone, maybe glasses
You can't really leave any of those behind
And a handkerchief might just blow away
Just use your cape
Just leave your pants there
Is the food court some kind of hellscape or what
I once had someone say "let me sit here next" and then camp right next to me for 30 minutes
Pretty creepy
Maybe a cartridge of "Moero!! Pro Yakyuu" (a retro baseball video game)?
At pachinko parlors, an old phone you don't use anymore is basically required for saving a seat
Whoever wrote this has clearly never raised a kid
If they're kindergarten age, they've probably already graduated from the stroller
Nope, don't get it
Doesn't the phone just get stolen?
I think more places are banning it these days
Heard it got phased out after complaints piled up
It should be fine — with kids in tow, it's scary to leave a child sitting alone while you go order
Handkerchief seat-saving has always been a thing at Japanese food courts
I think it's also a problem for the shop if people buy food with no seat available and end up wandering around — some of them are bound to spill stuff too lol
Background and Key Points of This Debate
There’s no legal rule governing seat-saving at food courts, and policy varies by venue. In recent years, more shops have started advising customers to “please secure a seat before ordering” as a way to manage crowding, and opinions in the thread split along the line of who knew this and who didn’t. The debate boils down to two main positions: one holds that “saving a seat with an object is just a personal rule with no real enforcement power,” while the other argues that “since venues themselves recommend it, grabbing a seat first is the reasonable thing to do.” Both sides have some basis, which is part of why the argument never really gets settled. One easy misconception for readers is treating seat-saving as simply “banned everywhere” or “common sense everywhere” — in reality, the verdict shifts depending on each store’s own policy. It’s also notable that while the original article foregrounded the “pregnant woman” angle, the thread largely moved past that and drifted toward practical tips about how to place items and what to use as substitutes.
※This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (News Express+) thread “【FORZA】… A pregnant woman with children saved a food court seat with a handkerchief. The “unbelievable behavior” of the family that took it while she was buying food.”
Leave a Reply