From our other sites
The story
On 5ch’s “Nandemo Jikkyo G” board, a poster who says he’s still buying Weekly Shonen Jump at age 34 started a Q&A thread. It began after someone doubted whether he really buys it, prompting him to post a photo of the latest issue as proof. Alongside the classic debate of paper versus digital, the thread covered a wide range of questions — series he didn’t realize had ended, what he thinks is the worst series of all time, and how his manga tastes have changed since childhood. When someone pointed out how it looks to others for a man in his 30s to be reading Jump, the poster took it in stride.
What people said
Here ya go
Paper's just better, y'know
Digital feels kind of flavorless somehow
Last time I couldn't get a copy because of the One Piece card promo, so I had no choice but to buy digital, and yeah, it just felt lacking somehow
Still keeping up with the ninja thing, huh
I've been into it since the "Amenofuru" arc
But honestly, isn't it about time you just canceled the subscription?
I stopped reading about 15 years ago
I already know about One Piece and Hunter x Hunter
Apparently the second-oldest series after One Piece these days is "Robot-ko," so you probably don't know most of the rest
Not counting Hunter x Hunter, that is
Waku Waku
Yunbol
And some dinosaur one, forget the name
I think I read Korokoro until about age 9
I don't think I was that into Anpanman
Thomas though, yeah, I liked him
Ever won anything?
I used to send a lot of them back in the day, but I've never won
I just look at the prize page these days thinking it must be tough coming up with new giveaway ideas every time
Gotta be about as rough as a high schooler reading Korokoro Comic
Yeah well, I guess that's how it looks from the outside
Nope, never
It's a manga, that's just how it is
I could tell Demon Slayer had that special spark right from the start of its run
By "subscription" you mean they'd just hold a copy aside for them?
Unrelated, but did working at the bookstore come with any discount perks there?
Guess I've finally transcended humanity
Couldn't get one, so I ended up buying the digital version
Got caught off guard — figured a place out in the countryside like mine would be fine, so it kind of freaked me out
To give hope and courage to students and corporate drones facing the gloom of a Monday morning
Though honestly, middle-aged guys are probably the real target audience
In that case, wouldn't students be a target audience too?
No idea who that is, but I guess I'd ask for a handshake first
I found chapter 1 interesting, so I stuck with it out of patience — it was rough going until the Hashira (Pillars) started showing up
When the Pillars first showed up, their characters still felt kind of undefined
Background and Key Points of This Topic
Weekly Shonen Jump’s print circulation has dropped sharply in recent years from its peak of several million copies, and it’s not unusual for longtime readers to simply age alongside their subscription. The thread split between the “pragmatists” — who argued that since you throw the magazine out after reading it anyway, digital should be good enough — and the “paper purists,” who feel digital just doesn’t have the same feel, with the poster explaining his attachment to paper through a past experience of being forced to settle for a digital copy when physical issues sold out. He also didn’t push back on the comment that reading Jump in your 30s is “rough,” treating it as a remark about generational perceptions of readers rather than a critique of the work itself — a distinction worth keeping separate from any judgment of the manga’s actual quality. It’s also worth noting that the poster’s memories of ended series and his picks for “worst ever” are purely one reader’s subjective impressions, not established facts.
*This article is an excerpt and summary based on the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “I’m 34 and still buy Shonen Jump — got questions?“.
Leave a Reply