From our other sites
The story
A thread on 5ch’s Hello! Project board titled “What today’s Hello! Project lacks is members with that ‘elegant big-sister’ feel” took off, with names like Kudo Yume, Arisawa Ichika, Tanimoto, and Ebata coming up one after another. Some said that looking back across the group’s whole history, Maimi is about the only one who really fits the “elegant big sister” mold, and the thread split over how to define that grown-up quality as something distinct from just having a cute idol face. Others brought up height, a clean-cut look, and vocal power as criteria, turning it into a debate that went well beyond simple taste in looks.
What people said
https://stat.ameba.jp/user_images/20260922/21/juicejuice-official/ac/9a/j/o1080144015824581807.jpg
Ise
Inoue
Tanimoto
Satoyoshi
Can't think of anyone besides Maimi
Actually there just isn't one
Wada, Sasaki, Kasahara, sure
but there's nobody active now
though if her figure holds up, Hirayama's on a good track
Kanato's basically giving queen vibes
It's more like 'grown-up and put-together'
Especially in idol circles, where it's all cute/loli types, so the word gets used that way even more
Forget where though
Rei Rei kind of gets shortchanged, what with everyone around her being tall or getting praised for vocal skill
Background and Key Points of the Discussion
Hello! Project frequently brings in new members while they’re still in their teens, so the group as a whole tends to skew toward a “cute” image. As a result, members with a grown-up “elegant big sister” air are relatively rare, and even looking back across the group’s entire history, the thread could only really settle on a handful of names like Maimi and Ebata. Posters also pointed out that “kirei” here isn’t being used as a straightforward judgment of looks, but rather to describe a sense of cleanliness and composure — a different axis from simply ranking facial features. Several people cited height and vocal power as conditions, suggesting it’s not just visual factors but a member’s overall stage presence that defines that “big sister” feeling.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread ‘What today’s Hello! Project is missing is members with that ‘elegant big-sister’ feel.’






Leave a Reply