Sato Ma-chan’s Sweet Potato Curry Sparks Fierce 5ch Debate

Written by

in

Morning Musume’s Sato Ma-chan sparked a heated debate on 5ch after making curry with sweet potato instead of the usual potato, using a recipe she learned from fellow member Hattori-kun.

Swapping in a sweet ingredient for potato drew criticism from some (“heresy,” “it’s just like pineapple in sweet and sour pork”), while plenty of others defended the choice (“surprisingly works,” “we always put it in too”). The thread eventually spiraled into discussions of sweet potato potato salad and takikomi gohan (seasoned mixed rice).

1Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 19:54:35.85
That's heresy…
4Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 19:57:16.15
It's so cute that Ma-chan actually made the recipe Hattori-kun taught her
6Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 19:58:31.89
Can't be that different from potato, right?
7Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 19:59:18.25
So it's basically pineapple in sweet and sour pork?
9Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:00:06.11
I think sweet potato works
Though it does fall apart easily when it simmers
11Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:00:46.44
Fun fact: sweet potatoes are actually grown in Hokkaido too
12Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:01:19.66
Ruu-chan, look at Ma-chan
See, it's a sweet potato (boron!) (a joking "ta-da!" sound-effect meme)
17Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:03:25.20
>>12
Put that mukago away (a small yam bulbil — keeping the joke going)
16Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:03:01.03
We normally have pumpkin or sweet potato in ours too
18Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:03:30.63
Kind of worried whether Hattori-san will make it as a full member
20Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:04:07.26
Onion and beef is really all you need, right?
21Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:04:36.27
>>20
Oh, a fellow believer!
24Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:06:14.35
>>20
That's because that's bourgeois curry
22Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:06:05.46
I think something sweet like carrot works well in curry
23Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:06:05.92
I hate that grainy texture when the potato breaks down
25Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:08:42.38
I wonder if sweet potato salad would actually taste good
33Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:25:52.13
>>25
My grandma used to make that
I still prefer regular potato though
Now that I think about it, the older generation really loves sweet ingredients
40Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:37:05.13
>>25
Kind of like a twist on candied sweet potato (kinton)
Just don't put mayo in it
26Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:11:29.67
Don't do it, it doesn't work…
Sweet ingredients don't belong in curry
28Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:16:20.04
Ruu-chan's charm is unbeatable
29Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:23:29.20
From the illustration I thought she was eating Curry Meshi with sweet potato as a side, but it's actually about putting it in as an ingredient
32Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:25:34.41
Because she talked about it during the MC — apparently the Hattori family uses pumpkin or sweet potato instead of potato
34Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:26:53.98
Ma-chan, please post about how it turned out after you made and ate it, pretty please
36Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:30:25.05
I've seen sweet potato salad sold as a deli item at the supermarket
37Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:31:19.95
For sweet potato or pumpkin, cream cheese works better than mayo
38Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:31:26.26
I've made sweet potato takikomi gohan (rice cooked with seasoned ingredients) before — it was delicious
39Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:32:08.02
Come to think of it, this year's SATOYAMA curry had sweet potato in it too
41Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:37:17.65
I saw a roasted sweet potato vending machine recently
43Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:38:29.25
They say 'imo-kuri-kabocha' (sweet potato, chestnut, and pumpkin — the classic trio women are said to love), but is there such a thing as chestnut curry?
44Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:39:11.70
No way can I do sweet potato in curry lol
45Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:39:48.27
Shkmeruli (a Georgian chicken and garlic dish) has sweet potato in it, so curry should be fine too
46Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:41:16.32
Ma-chan's team mild curry after all
47Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:41:29.62
Don't remember where or when, but I have a memory of eating sweet potato curry as a kid
Maybe at some neighborhood kids' club camp or something
48Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:43:15.58
Today's overly sweet sweet potatoes would be too much, but the old-fashioned kind would be fine
49Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:44:10.73
Deep-fried as a topping, sure, but simmering it in the curry? Not convinced
50Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 20:49:24.88
Stew, fine, but curry? No way
53Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 21:04:34.35
You can absolutely put sweet potato in curry. Its sweetness pairs well with the spice, giving you a fluffy, delicious result. It's popular to use in place of potato, or paired with pork or chicken.
54Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 21:07:05.77
Wasn't there that commercial with Tamori and Rie Miyazawa eating it with potato mixed in? Mashed potato or something?
That looked tasty
56Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 21:11:15.13
High-end curry doesn't usually include potato-type ingredients
57Anonymous2026/08/21(金) 21:12:46.64
Guess not many people put sweet potato in?
It goes really well, though

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project) thread “Sato Ma-chan puts sweet potato in curry wwwwwwww.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *