From our other sites
The story
A post asking “Is it true that even Osakans eat Gindaco?” drew responses from Osaka residents on 5ch’s Nandemo Jikkyo G (Live News) board.
Commenters pointed out that Gindaco locations in Osaka are concentrated inside shopping malls, so they’re rarely spotted around town, and that the company’s headquarters is actually in Gunma Prefecture. The thread also spiraled into a taste showdown between local takoyaki shops and Gindaco.
What people said
The stores haven't gone out of business, have they
Oh…
Guess they're eating it in secret then
It's just tourists eating it
It's a store, I don't get why they'd need to hide it
I love that "this is exactly what a takoyaki set meal should be" feeling
People in eastern Japan who only know Gindaco's flavor probably can't appreciate it
I don't want to eat something like that
You wouldn't even need rice with it
Even though Gindaco is from Gunma
Tonkin people have taste buds that think 'Osaka takoyaki is bad,' so even when they visit, all they can eat is Gindaco
This
The one from the old lady at the candy shop was delicious
So unless you have a reason to go to a mall, there's never really a trigger to eat Gindaco
Yeah, it's common in food courts
There's one at Takatsuki Station too
Gindaco's out of the question, honestly
Is it famous in Osaka?
If you don't know it, you're basically a fake Osakan
Whoa
It was pricey, but it was gooey and delicious
And once it cools down, the oil seeps through and it turns into a disgustingly greasy mess
No need to buy it
Kukuru's the one that's expensive
Is there anyone who actually goes to Kukuru?
Re: #66
Seems like it's on the level of getting called a 'fake Osakan' if you don't know it
It's about on the level of a Tokyoite not knowing Hidakaya (a cheap noodle/Chinese food chain)
Osaka's takoyaki shops are full of foreign staff these days too, you know
I went to Wanaka in Shin-Osaka the day before yesterday and everyone working there was foreign
Can't you just make Osaka-style takoyaki at home?
Gindaco actively hires foreign workers as a policy (there are even foreign staff in management)
Osaka has the highest density of takoyaki shops per square area anywhere — go check out some other independent takoyaki shops before you say that
So when people say 'Osaka takoyaki,' does that mean independent shops? Are the famous chains not 'real' Osaka then?
I went to the recommended spots — Wanaka, Kukuru, Koga-ryu — and I'm pretty sure they all had foreign staff too
So what's the appeal of eating them in Kagawa or Osaka specifically? I think it's that you can get cheap, consistently good udon or takoyaki at basically any shop
I don't know about Kagawa's udon, but Osaka's takoyaki has gotten pricey lately
People look down on the deep-fried style, but if you ran a blind taste test with the general public against most shops, they'd probably lose
The way people hedge with 'that's not real takoyaki' or 'it's too expensive' basically means they're admitting defeat
That's called 'modan-yaki' (modern-style okonomiyaki)
It's delicious as its own distinct dish
By the way, a lot of shops toss in the yakisoba without seasoning it separately beforehand, but the shops that season the noodles separately before layering them under the okonomiyaki somehow taste better
Background and Key Points
Gindaco’s full name is “Ganso Osaka Takoyaki Gindaco” (“Original Osaka Takoyaki Gindaco”), a branding choice that borrows Osaka’s culinary identity even though the chain, operated by Hotland Co., was founded and is headquartered in Gunma Prefecture, deep in the Kanto region far from Osaka. That gap between the name and the geography is exactly what one poster flags when noting Gindaco is “from Gunma,” and it matters because Osaka takoyaki is a genuinely dense, competitive local food culture — countless independent stalls and shops, often run by longtime owners, compete on small margins in a city famous for having more takoyaki shops per square kilometer than almost anywhere else in Japan.
The thread’s real fault line isn’t “do Osakans eat Gindaco” (commenters agree they do, mostly in mall food courts) but whether Gindaco’s mass-produced, manualized product can actually compete on taste with Osaka’s independent shops. One camp calls it merely serviceable, propped up by nostalgia and hedging about “authenticity”; another argues that in a blind taste test, most small Osaka shops would lose to Gindaco, framing complaints about price or “realness” as concession rather than critique.
What the thread never quite settles is that the “authentic vs. chain” divide it keeps invoking is already blurry: commenters note that famous, well-regarded Osaka chains like Wanaka, Kukuru, and Koga-ryu now also rely heavily on foreign staff, the same practice used to dismiss Gindaco as inauthentic. Readers unfamiliar with Japan’s service-sector labor shortage may not realize that staffing patterns say little about a shop’s regional pedigree or recipe.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Is it true that even Osakans eat Gindaco?”.
Leave a Reply