From our other sites
The story
A debate has broken out on 5ch’s “Hardware & Industry” (Geha) board over GTA6 (Grand Theft Auto VI). It was sparked by a new system where repeated criminal behavior leads to a bad ending, along with the poor reputation of protagonists Jason and Lucia. While some praise the graphics and the detailed city design, criticism such as “it’s lost what makes GTA, GTA” and “if it were actually a fun game, it wouldn’t have this many low-score reviews” has been prominent, splitting the thread’s opinions sharply between defenders and critics.
What people said
But "commit a crime, get a bad ending," a cuckold simulator (NTR), and a boring story — if the game itself just isn't fun, there's no fixing that.
Yeah it's unnecessary, but they leaned too hard into RDR (Red Dead Redemption).
Pretty dumb.
Guess we just have to accept it's a cuckold simulator now.
That said, it's getting overwhelmingly positive reviews on the PlayStation Store.
Maybe that means PlayStation users tend to have more "updated values" and prefer politically correct games?
That's exactly why it feels so disjointed from the story.
The world-building is beyond reproach.
If you set the Metascore 99 thing aside, it's easy to imagine that even with a crappy single-player story, the online mode will still be fun.
People are going "wait, really??" because of that 99 score, but the level of detail in the setting is genuinely impressive.
I saw the video version of this.
How so?
They just praise everything nonstop.
Total fanboys.
Sounds like you're reacting to the Ocarina of Time remake posts lol.
They should've just made a game with that level of quality instead.
Huh? That's pretty normal commentary though, isn't it?
RDR2 had that same setup too — needlessly "realistic" (lol) and inconvenient, trashed by actual gamers while critics put it on a pedestal.
I actually loved all that tedium though.
Like when you bring in a bounty and instead of just handing you the reward, they annoyedly toss the bag of money onto the table and you have to pick it up yourself — I thought that was a fantastic touch.
It's fun, sure, bugs and all.
The problem is that it got rated like a masterpiece when it's really just a solid, decent game.
If it were actually fun, you wouldn't get 80,000 reviews averaging 4 or 5 out of 10.
Lol, Jason might be the most hated protagonist the series has ever had.
Not that I'd really know.
Japanese players weren't really the ones leaving those reviews to begin with.
Most of the reviews are from overseas users, and it's those overseas users who are saying "no" to Lucia, Jason, and GTA6's whole system.
If we're just talking gameplay, Japanese players might actually appreciate this GTA more.
Strip out the crime elements and turn the characters into animals, and it's basically Animal Crossing.
I feel like a baseline any open-world game should clear is having objects of all sizes — from the stuff in your hand to things way off in the distance — with systems where you stumble into random events unexpectedly. That seems essential.
That said, precisely because it's such a good simulator, I bet some people will mistake "this feels sensorially satisfying" for "this game is fun."
As people often say, the fun of GTA as a game probably comes from being able to pull off completely unconventional, rule-breaking actions.
Honestly, if Lucia weren't in it, this could be a fun life sim.
But there's no way I'm playing "keep your cheating wife happy," so I'm skipping it.
It'll probably click with people who liked how tedious RDR2 was, but at this point it's basically a different game.
Seriously dumb. If only it were Trevor and Franklin instead.
It really feels under-tuned.
They should've extended development and polished the quality more.
The GTA series was always praised for its story too, you know.
The people defending it by saying "the story's just a bonus" are honestly more like closet anti-fans lol.
Characters
Systems
Story
Frame rate
Uniformly bad, all around.
Yeah, the game itself is just plain badly made.
Japanese players evicting the ugly villagers (Animal Crossing reference).
Guess Japan's no better then, huh.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
GTA6 is the latest entry in the series and had been drawing attention even before release for its high level of graphical fidelity, but what’s fueling discussion in the thread is the system where repeatedly committing crimes leads to a bad ending, along with the poor reputation of protagonists Jason and Lucia. The GTA series has traditionally been a franchise that embraces unconventional criminal behavior as part of the fun, so many users feel that a “commit crimes, get a bad ending” mechanic contradicts the series’ core identity — and that’s the main fault line running through the thread. At the same time, specific figures cited in the thread, like “80,000 reviews” and “a Metascore of 99,” are individual posters’ own claims rather than officially verified data confirmed in this article, which readers should keep in mind. There are also voices arguing that the depth of the world-building deserves credit even if the story doesn’t, showing that the criticism isn’t monolithic. Many commenters also compare it to Red Dead Redemption 2’s “enjoy the inconvenience” approach, with the shift in direction from the same developer’s previous work becoming one of the thread’s talking points.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware & Industry (Geha)) thread “Honestly, GTA6’s biggest problem is that "the game just isn’t fun".”


Leave a Reply