Now That Metacritic Scores Don’t Mean Anything Anymore, What Are We Supposed to Trust to Judge a Game?

From our other sites

The story

On 5ch’s Hardware/Industry (Geha) board, a thread titled “Now that Metascores don’t work anymore, how are we supposed to judge a game’s quality?” blew up. Against a backdrop of distrust toward Western media’s review practices, posters offered a string of opinions: relying on Steam user reviews, watching streams and let’s-play videos, or simply trusting your own taste. The discussion spread to Nintendo’s corporate image, the reliability of game-catalog wiki sites, and the way GTA6 has been covered in the press — but no single conclusion emerged.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:11
Sales figures, then, huh.
2AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:13
Just buy it for the box art.
Back in my day we bought records the same way, yadda yadda. (old-timer talk)
3AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:14
Watch gameplay videos.
That solves everything.
101AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:55
Re: #3
On Steam you just find a curator who shares your taste.
4AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:14
Why not watch a stream before buying? If it looks fun to watch, it'll be fun to play too.
5AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:16
Your own judgment, obviously.
Can't you do anything without someone else handing you a score?
14AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:29
Re: #5
Exactly. Anyone who can't function without someone else's rating is finished.
Maybe that matters for work, but in a hobby, whether you enjoy it is all that counts — other people's opinions are irrelevant.
PC gamers tend to think this way, which is why so many indie games keep selling steadily for years. Console players (CS, i.e. PlayStation/Xbox crowd), on the other hand, are obsessed with sales figures, Metascores, and rankings — that's the problem.
6AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:16
Is there even a game that got popular because of its Metascore?
It's always just been a branding tool to lend AAA titles an air of authority.
7AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:17
Trust us.
Well, trust anything but "bonds," anyway.
8AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:18
Just buy based on your own taste.
You're buying it to enjoy yourself, right?
9AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:22
Just watch a stream.
A boring game is boring to watch too, obviously.
10AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:25
Watching streamers who clearly aren't getting paid sponsorships (no "anken" deals) is actually useful.
12AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:29
Only just now realizing it never really worked that well to begin with?
13AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:29
Reference reviewers/streamers with no strings attached who don't pull punches.
Buying on release day with zero prior info is a no-go.
Even digital Xbox purchases can be refunded under the 14-day rule, but doing that every time looks bad — so you still need to wait and see, or let someone else be the guinea pig ("hitobashira").
15AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:40
You just have to dig for what you like yourself.
Dig.
Drill.
16AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:48
mk2 is good enough, isn't it?
21AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:57
Re: #16
That's so nostalgic I burst out laughing lol
Is that even still around? lol
17AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:51
The Metascore number itself means nothing.
Read the actual review text.
18AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:51
It only really worked back in the very early days.
Once a user-review site gets popular, it dies unless it fights tooth and nail to stay fair — just look at mk2.
19AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:54
It's kind of depressing that dealing the finishing blow to review scores just ends up giving streamers even more power.
It'd be fine if it weren't for sponsored deals.
They'll just start saying "give us a glowing review or we won't send you early copies next time" anyway.
22AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:00
Even if they're grudgingly playing it for a sponsorship deal, you can tell just by watching.
26AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:15
Re: #22
Yeah, once the contract period's over, they stop playing it.
25AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:15
I trust the ratings on Game Catalog Wiki.
54AnonymousNov 22, 2026 08:14
Re: #25
That site's seriously garbage — people who haven't even played the game go there to defend it.
30AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:27
Why not just buy it and play it yourself instead?
31AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:31
Re: #30
Because games get sold while hiding their political-correctness content, just like GTA6.
Buying it yourself is way too risky.
And it's not like it'll even sell well.
32AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:34
Re: #30
Contributing to the sales of a boring game affects the sequel too, so it's better not to buy it.
104AnonymousNov 22, 2026 11:07
Re: #30
Can you say the same thing to people who get stuck with a shit game without knowing it and end up furious?
Like with "Dame-jor" (a snarky nickname blending "dame" = no-good with "major," used for hyped AAA games that flopped), for instance.
35AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:36
In the end, Steam reviews and PC gaming just feel like where the real gamers are. Console players (CS) are basically nothing but casuals.
39AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:38
Re: #35
Maybe it's because there are so many casual players, but console storefront ratings are pretty generous.
41AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:50
At times like this, Nintendo really has the edge — they've steadily built up trust over the years and are basically the only company in the industry seen as having a clean image.
49AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:59
Re: #41
In exchange, though, they have very few allies.
I think part of this is that Rockstar paid for coverage, but more than that, if GTA6 doesn't succeed, AAA developers, Sony, Microsoft, and gaming media all end up in trouble — so the gaming press collectively pulled its punches out of self-interest.

Nintendo, on the other hand, only affects Nintendo whether it succeeds or fails, which makes it hard for them to build allies.
That said, if PlayStation keeps moving toward dropping physical discs, Nintendo could gain the upper hand by winning over retail distributors.
62AnonymousNov 22, 2026 08:37
Re: #41
Nintendo doesn't have a clean image at all.
They're doing scummy stuff like the Palworld lawsuit.
88AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:56
Re: #41
That's not true.
Even Nintendo has plenty of garbage games among its second-tier titles and below.
46AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:56
Isn't it kind of dumb to decide what games you play based on other people's ratings?
Back in school I had a friend who only listened to songs in the Oricon Top 10 — are gaming-board (Geha) otaku basically the same?
74AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:10
Re: #46
Oricon is based on sales figures, so there's a chance they were just listening to whatever music everyone else was listening to, in order to have something to talk about.
76AnonymousNov 22, 2026 09:14
Re: #46
Yeah, and a game nobody's playing doesn't give you anything to talk about either.
68AnonymousNov 22, 2026 08:56
This reminds me of how Yahoo used to let users rate all kinds of products, not just games, with user reviews — and it shut down after doing nothing to deal with trolls.
69AnonymousNov 22, 2026 08:57
Re: #68
That's exactly why Steam, where only buyers can leave reviews, is the strongest system.
99AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:46
Trust yourself.
Though I've failed a few times doing that…
100AnonymousNov 22, 2026 10:50
Re: #99
That becomes experience, though — it hurts, but it's not wasted.
Anyone other than the kind of idiot who can't learn anything, like a gaming-board (Geha) troll, can put it to use next time.

Background and Key Points of This Discussion

The Metascore is an index that aggregates reviews from major Western media outlets, and it has carried real weight in the industry — for instance, being written into bonus clauses in development contracts. At the same time, conflicts of interest involving advertising deals and pre-release review copies have repeatedly been pointed out over the years. What divided the thread was the question of “relying on other people’s evaluations” itself: trust in Steam reviews, which only buyers can post, was pitted against the view that people should choose games based on their own personal taste. As for the doubts raised about GTA6 coverage and opinions on Nintendo’s image, no concrete evidence was presented in the thread — these remain simply the individual impressions of the participants, so that point should be kept in mind.

※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry, aka Geha) thread “Now That Metacritic Scores Don’t Mean Anything Anymore, What Are We Supposed to Trust to Judge a Game?“.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *