From our other sites
The story
A user who played GTA6 for about 10 hours posted on 5ch’s Hardware/Industry (“Geha”) board asking, “No offense, but what does this actually beat Tears of the Kingdom at?” — and it turned into a full-blown debate. The poster complained that “it’s nothing but fetch quests, no dungeons, no real combat” and that “there’s never a moment of discovering an unknown world,” questioning what edge the game has beyond graphics. Replies split for and against, circling around whether a real-world city setting works, how much freedom the crafting/physics gimmicks offer, and whether a mod culture exists for it.
What people said
Field exploration amounts to nothing more than driving around in a stolen car or helping some NPC push their car out of the mud — no dungeons, no combat with enemies either.
Is there anything besides the graphics?
The story's so painful, maybe they should make it a rehab program for criminals instead.
It's just endless, hollow fetch quests.
Seriously, this.
It's all just real-world scenery, so there's zero sense of wonder.
There's no ancient ruin quietly tucked away in a dense, overgrown forest or anything like that.
Though Elden Ring's underground area actually got more negative reviews than positive ones, lol 😁
Might actually be fun if you played it with VR gear.
If it got VR support, just taking a walk through it might be fun.
Fun, right?
Isn't this supposed to be a game about committing crimes? I don't know, but
shouldn't a higher villain meter be a good thing?
Right now it's just the base framework, so it's not that interesting.
On that front, the PS5, which can't use mods, is a platform that can't bring out the game's fun.
Sure, but then — how is that any different from GTA5?
The graphics and sheer volume are impressive, but the gameplay itself hasn't advanced one bit.
Then Minecraft, where you can craft literally everything, must be the greatest game ever.
Though that goes for Tears of the Kingdom too.
What are you talking about? This is a game that force-restarts the mission if you wander off to explore mid-mission.
A shrine where you're stripped of all your gear and have to wipe out enemies in an anti-gravity room is still about 500 million times more fun than this game's garbage fetch quests.
— that kind of thing gets a pass, but GTA's abundant activities and collectibles don't? I genuinely don't get the double standard.
The cave collectible where you beat up that one enemy is about as fun as GTA6's card collecting.
Though Tears of the Kingdom also packs in a ton of far more interesting gameplay on top of that, lol.
I know opinions on games vary person to person, but did you honestly find GTA6 more fun than Tears of the Kingdom?
Since Tears of the Kingdom inevitably gets compared to Breath of the Wild, I found it disappointing — the Ubisoft-style collectible grind, the fiddliness of Zonai crafting, and how it gates crafting behind a tedious battery-expansion grind just to pad out playtime.
Despite having both an underground realm and a sky realm, Tears of the Kingdom had none of the Breath of the Wild excitement of "what's beyond that mountain?!" that makes you want to adventure.
There's some truth to that, but that's comparing it to Breath of the Wild — the question was about comparing it to GTA6.
I'd guess opinions are split on whether people prefer Breath of the Wild or Tears of the Kingdom.
I enjoyed Tears of the Kingdom myself, but I still can't forget how fresh Breath of the Wild felt, so it's genuinely hard to decide which one I'd vote for.
Just accept it wasn't for you and go play something else.
Who exactly IS this game for, then, lol.
If you're playing it yourself it'd probably just piss you off, but watching it in a video is funny.
Wait, is this Final Fantasy XV?
Apparently that's a parody of an actual real-life incident.
Meanwhile in Zelda, you can't even cut down an NPC.
The reason exploring in Breath of the Wild or Elden Ring is fun is precisely because it's an "unknown world."
In a real-world setting, climbing to the top of a building just gets you… an AC unit, lol.
Just because you got on a plane doesn't mean there's a hidden floating castle in the clouds, right? lol
All you end up with is impressions like "is this an MS Flight Simulator" or "an Ace Combat with no objective."
Flight Simulator is about roleplaying as an airline pilot
(there are channels run by real aviation-accident analysts who play it)
Ace Combat is a shooter, so the scenery-appreciation angle is thin, but in GTA, which leans heavily on driving, the janky car handling is a pretty fatal flaw.
It makes you motion sick, and getting in a car thins out the NPC count, so you can't even enjoy mass-running-people-over as much.
"Fiction is more fun to explore than reality" is actually a pretty interesting take.
So then, if a new fantasy open-world Witcher or Elder Scrolls game came out, that would be fine?
The problem is there's nothing to actually do once you explore.
And the main story missions are garbage boring too.
But what's actually fun about this one, I wonder.
There IS a monster in it — the player, killing random bystanders they have no grudge against.
That's more of a Saints Row thing.
Though I guess we can't hope for that series to come back anymore.
There's also the monster named Lucia who won't die no matter how much she gets shot.
Disarming barrier (the gay bar, where your weapons get confiscated)
Defense magic (the woman screaming in the car)
Teleportation (closing the gap on the sniper)
Phase-through magic (the airplane)
Alright! That's basically fantasy!
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
GTA6 is Rockstar Games’ new open-world title, and one of its selling points is its meticulous recreation of real-world cities. Tears of the Kingdom, on the other hand — the latest Nintendo Zelda title following on from Breath of the Wild — has been known for its unknown terrain, sky ruins, and free-form puzzle-solving using physics-based gimmicks. The thread split over whether a “realistic, real-world city” or a “fictional, unknown world” generates more excitement for exploration, with some on the GTA side praising the sheer volume of crime-action content and the depth of its NPC design. Worth noting: this thread reflects one person’s impressions after only about 10 hours of play shortly after release, not a definitive verdict on the game as a whole — long-term assessments, including how much mods will expand it, may well change.
※This article excerpts and summarizes the 5ch (Hardware/Industry, “Geha”) thread “I’ve played GTA6 for about 10 hours now, and no offense, but what does this actually beat Tears of the Kingdom at?.”
Leave a Reply