Metacritic User Reviews Can Be Submitted With Just a Score, No Verification Required — 5ch: ‘This Isn’t Functioning as a Review Site’

From our other sites

The story

It’s become a hot topic on 5ch that the game review site Metacritic lets users submit reviews as a score alone, with no comment required and no email or SMS verification. The thread cited examples like GTA 6’s user score sitting stuck at 5.6, while the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake saw its vote count surge from roughly 20,000 to over 40,000, dropping its score from 9.6 to 8.5. Posters also debated the reliability of user scores in general, comparing Metacritic’s system to those of Steam and the PlayStation Store.

What people said

1AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:31
And since you can register with any throwaway email, you can make unlimited accounts — no SMS verification either.
This isn't functioning as a review site at all…
14AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:34
Re: #11
However you look at it, Zelda's the one actually getting hurt by this.
17AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:35
Re: #14
Well, the ones who started it were the 🐷 (slang for Nintendo/Switch fanboys, lit. "pig"), lol
16AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:35
Here's what happens when you filter out the problematic reviews:

[Devastating news for the "barrier-brains" (derogatory 5ch slang for trolls/haters)] Turns out deleting the lies and low-quality comments drops GTA 6's user score even further
https://krsw.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/ghard/1795347620/
19AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:35
Re: #16
Isn't Re: #1 basically proof that the review site itself is the problem?
26AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:40
Re: #1
Re: #16
That just makes GTA look even more finished (dead), lol 😅
51AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:51
Re: #16
A game that came out a little while back had the exact same thing happen — it was called Wolverine, lol
22AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:37
Wasn't the consensus already that any review site letting non-purchasers vote is garbage, and that nothing but Steam reviews is worth trusting?

And yet everyone still lost it over Palworld's scores.
38AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:43
Re: #22
Tare tare taree-i~ www (nonsense meme chant)
39AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:44
Re: #22
Palworld destroyed everything, after all, lol
23AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:37
Lol, what a trash site.
Guess media reviews are the only ones worth trusting now, lol
30AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:41
Re: #23
Media reviews hit rock bottom this time too, though
28AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:40
Huh, only now?
So Re: #1 was hyping this up without even knowing that?
33AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:42
Re: #28
Were you the one rigging it, lol?
41AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:45
[Great Achievement] GTA 6 becomes the #1 highest-rated game of all time on both Metacritic and OpenCritic
https://krsw.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/ghard/1795352748/

Metacritic
https://www.metacritic.com/browse/game/




OpenCritic
https://opencritic.com/browse/all


Guess all that's left is rigging the user score, huh
43AnonymousNov 22, 2026 22:47
Re: #41
OpenCritic rates it highly too.
GOTY confirmed, lol
59AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:00
🐷💢<The metascore's rigged, you bastaaaaaards! RAAAAAAAGH

Uh, isn't it the user score that's wide open to rigging, lol
67AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:04
[Image included] The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake's user score: 9.7 lmaooooo
https://krsw.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/ghard/1794003316/

Hey Switch-bro (ぶーちゃん, mocking nickname for Nintendo fanboys), about this…
73AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:05
Re: #67
Aonuma lmaooooo Far lmaoooooo Cry lol (the laughing "w"s are inserted to spell out "Far Cry")
76AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:06
Re: #67
Pig lmaowwe (🐷, slang for Nintendo fanboys)
77AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:08
Re: #67
lmaooooooooo

11 Anonymous (desperately trying) sage 2026/11/07 (Sat) 07:23:04.08 ID:wHyq0MMY0
This is the 'real deal' right here
69AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:04
People have been saying for years that both media scores and user scores are garbage — why's this news only now?
Even within the same outlet, scoring is sloppy: sometimes bugs or frame rate issues tank a game's score, sometimes they don't.
70AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:05
Re: #69
And yet Mr. 🐷 (Nintendo fanboy) was strutting around bragging about it
79AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:09
Even Steam reviews, supposedly the most trustworthy, can be gamed by buying the game, leaving a review, then refunding it.
83AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:11
Re: #79
At least Steam marks refunded reviews as "refunded," so it's not as bad
85AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:12
Re: #79
The PS Store gave that infamous Wolverine game a 4.61/5 — that's how bad it is.
Definitely the least trustworthy one, lol
86AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:12
Re: #79
Go too far and you get banned, so it's probably still the most reliable overall.
Though it does have the problem of being swayed by Chinese user reviews.
88AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:13
It was so easy to make an account that I went ahead and left a bad review, lol
89AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:14
Re: #11
The "barrier-brains" putting in this much effort for something meaningless, lol
91AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:15
Re: #89
No no, the point is bombing the games that the 🐷 (who think user scores actually matter) love most with bad reviews, lol
94AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:17
Re: #91
"The games the 🐷 love most" — you mean GTA 6 with its 5.6 user score? lol
96AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:19
Re: #91
In Japan, this would pretty straightforwardly count as "obstruction of business by deceptive means"…
100AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:21
The "barrier-brains" who think user scores actually matter are review-bombing Ocarina of Time, adding about 20,000 votes and tanking the score — but of course it's always "the pig did it," lol

>Ocarina of Time (Switch 2)
>11/20: score 9.6, 21,403 votes ttps://web.archive.org/web/20261120200835/https://www.metacritic.com/game/the-legend-of-zelda-ocarina-of-time-2026/
>Right now: score 8.5, 40,572 votes
101AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:22
Re: #100
This whole story started with the 🐷 anyway, didn't it? lol
104AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:23
Re: #100
[Image included] The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake's user score: 9.7 lmaooooo
https://krsw.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/ghard/1794003316/

11 Anonymous (desperately trying) sage 2026/11/07 (Sat) 07:23:04.08 ID:wHyq0MMY0
This is the 'real deal' right here
108AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:27
Hey, "barrier-brain" — you've been review-bombing Ocarina of Time all day long right now, happily tanking its score because you think user scores actually mean something…
People are calling you out on it, lol

98: Anonymous (desperately trying) 2026/11/22 (Sun) 18:56:51.29 ID:i4cZ7yZp0
Re: #97
Nah, I don't think anyone takes user scores seriously anyway — it's a garbage system where you can make infinite accounts and rig it endlessly.
Don't tell me you've actually been taking it at face value this whole time? 😦
111AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:34
Re: #108
Lol, that clearly hit a nerve.
Guess the only thing you can brag about is a user score built on infinite fake accounts, lol
114AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:37
Re: #111
So you're the one who's actually been taking it seriously? If you've got a problem, take it up with this guy:

98: Anonymous (desperately trying) 2026/11/22 (Sun) 18:56:51.29 ID:i4cZ7yZp0
Re: #97
Nah, I don't think anyone takes user scores seriously anyway — it's a garbage system where you can make infinite accounts and rig it endlessly.
Don't tell me you've actually been taking it at face value this whole time? 😦
115AnonymousNov 22, 2026 23:37
Re: #111
If you actually want to raise GTA 6's user score, you'll need at least 10,000 accounts, lol
Good luck with that, lmaooo

Background and Key Points of This Topic

Metacritic’s user score has long run separately from its Critic score, under a system that lets anyone register and post without proof of purchase. Because there’s no identity check such as email confirmation or SMS authentication, it’s technically possible for one person to create multiple accounts and vote repeatedly on the same title — this kind of mass voting has been a point of controversy with past high-profile titles like Palworld as well. As for the score swings cited in the thread for the Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time remake, there’s no way from the outside to tell whether the surge came mainly from favorable or critical votes, and no evidence has been presented pinning it on “manipulation” by any specific person or group. Steam reviews have likewise faced allegations of coordinated score manipulation via refund abuse, suggesting this vulnerability isn’t unique to Metacritic — it’s a broader challenge facing any system that collects post-purchase ratings from an unverified public.

※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry (Geha)) thread “[Sad News] Turns out Metacritic has a sloppy setup that lets you post user reviews with just a score, lol.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *