From our other sites
The story
On the TV Asahi program “Matsuko & Ariyoshi’s Temporary Paradise” (aired on the 20th), Matsuko Deluxe questioned why white rice is served last at ryokan meals, saying she “can’t accept it,” and Ariyoshi Hiroyuki agreed, saying “everyone has complaints about it.” This sparked a thread on 5ch, where many users explained that serving rice last follows the established etiquette of kaiseki (懐石) and kaiseki (会席) cuisine — serving rice as the finishing dish — and pointed out that this order is meant for banquets accompanied by drinking. Meanwhile, simple opinions like “just ask for the rice to be served first” and comparisons between the meal-serving styles of ryokan versus hotels also piled up, sparking debate over the reasoning behind the serving order.
Matsuko Says There’s “Something I Can’t Accept” About Ryokan Meals; Ariyoshi: “Everyone Has Complaints,” “I Keep Believing, Believing, and Always Getting Betrayed”
The TV Asahi program “Matsuko & Ariyoshi’s Temporary Paradise” aired on the 20th, featuring celebrities Matsuko Deluxe and Hiroyuki Ariyoshi.
On the theme of “dishes that go well with white rice,” Ariyoshi said, “I don’t really do the thing where you pile on pickles and eat huge bowls of rice.”
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here
What people said
You eat your rice and side dishes at breakfast anyway.
That's what's called kaiseki (会席, banquet-style) cuisine.
With kaiseki (懐石, tea-ceremony style), the rice and soup come first.
Don't go on about some fancy ryokan like that, I wouldn't know.
Even when I do stay somewhere, it's a hotel.
These days, don't they need to attract foreign tourists just to get by?
Copying that style is basically the inn saying, "We're a high-class establishment."
Every place I've been has had everything laid out from the start, like a set meal or a kaiseki spread.
Get that straight first.
Have you only ever stayed at business hotels?
I'm broke, so I wouldn't know lol
Maybe expensive ryokan do courses and cheap ones do trays?
Places that do that are the ones where rice comes out last.
The two celebrities are being humble here, but these days society has gotten so poor that even that kind of rhetoric doesn't land anymore.
If you told the two of them what's in Re: #52, I bet they'd have a real moment of realization.
The day they stop having those moments is the day they're finished as mainstream TV personalities.
Without constant self-awareness, they have no reason to exist.
even outside a ryokan you get handed a menu and the rice comes at the end of the course, right?
Have you never been to a funeral and gone all the way to the crematorium?
Do you just not have any relatives you keep in touch with?
What region's local custom is that?
What about that is supposed to be something to envy?
Do they just throw it away if it's not finished?
A true master never leaves any behind — they'd eat it even if their stomach were about to burst.
Background and Key Points of This Debate
The order in which rice is served differs between kaiseki (懐石) and kaiseki (会席) cuisine. In its original form, kaiseki (懐石) etiquette calls for rice and soup to be served first, but kaiseki (会席) cuisine, which assumes a meal built around drinking, is generally structured to serve appetizers first, with rice served last as the finishing course. One reason ryokan dinners often follow the banquet-style (会席) format is a business practice: it makes it easier to get guests to order extra drinks or additional à la carte dishes. The disagreement in the thread centered on non-drinkers’ complaints that this order is unnecessary for guests who don’t drink, versus defenders arguing “that’s just the etiquette of banquet-style dining, so it can’t be helped” — making this less a matter of simple taste and more about the economic logic behind the serving style. The thread also noted that ryokan dining styles aren’t uniform: some inns serve a structured course like kaiseki, while others bring everything out at once on a single tray (o-zen), with the difference often tied to price range and the inn’s class — though the original source article didn’t dig deeply into this point.
*This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Entertainment/Sports News+) thread “[Entertainment] Matsuko: “There’s Something I Can’t Accept” About Ryokan Meals — Why Does the Rice Come Out Last?… Ariyoshi: “Everyone Has Complaints”.”
Leave a Reply