From our other sites
The story
A Yahoo! News survey on “one-hit wonders” sparked discussion when the song voted #1 beat out Eito’s “Kousui” (Perfume). The original article noted that Yuki Koyanagi’s “Count Your Kisses ~You Were Mine~” landed at #4, but on 5ch’s Geisoku Sokuhou+ board, commenters immediately objected: “Koyanagi isn’t a one-hit wonder.” The thread went on to name act after act with multiple hits — CCB, THE BOOM, Misato Watanabe, Crystal King — spiraling into a debate over definitions: “Does this even count as one-hit?” “Isn’t this more like two-hit wonder territory?”
Fri, Nov 20, 11:00 AM
Artists who burst onto the scene like a comet, scored one mega-hit, and then vanished. Even without a follow-up hit, they’re still remembered — “oh yeah, that one” — every time the song plays. We surveyed readers on the songs and artists that once swept the nation and that people would still want to hear today. Which “one-hit wonder” sticks in your memory?
The songs that still feel great belting out at karaoke never really go away.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Nah, Koyanagi's had several hit songs…
Koyanagi doesn't belong on this list
and sure enough, someone already said it.
There are a ton of actual one-hit wonders out there — what even is this ranking?
Yamane
CLASS
GAO
Daijiman Brothers Band
JAYWALK
Masatoshi Ono's a two-hit wonder — he's the Hunter x Hunter theme guy.
JAYWALK counts as two-hit too if you split their summer song from their winter one.
Masato Shimon isn't a one-hit wonder though.
Tom Cat also did the Fist of the North Star 2 theme, so that's two hits.
They're known for the Fist of the North Star song, but the one that actually sold was 'Furare Kibun de Rock'n' Roll.'
The Fist of the North Star 2 song is addictive though.
Usually even the follow-up to a hit
ends up selling decently.
Pop Con (Yamaha's contest for new songwriters) grand-prize winners
are a goldmine of one-hit wonders,
but even they tend to have a second song that does okay.
Theme songs sung by idols, actresses, and other non-musicians count too.
Like the Nausicaä of the Valley of the Wind theme — and if 'didn't write it themselves' counts, that makes Pikotaro one too.
Necke's 'Csikós Post' —
the one that's always played at school sports day.
Apparently Necke has no surviving sheet music besides this piece.
They've got the Fist of the North Star song too, you know.
Re: #55
Apparently they've been living off Japanese royalties for decades, so that's the 'ultimate one-hit wonder' (´・ω・`)
There's 'Mou Tomodachi Janai' (We're Not Friends Anymore) and 'Kimi ga Iru' (You're Here).
Ayumi Nakamura gets called that too.
Aladdin
CCB
Yoshito Machida
Not CCB, come on.
CCB's a two-hit wonder.
CCB was a top idol band for like two years.
these guys are basically Hall of Fame one-hit wonders, right?
Not KAN, come on.
this one song alone turned into a Bon Odori (summer dance festival) staple in Brazil lol
'Sweet Emotion' — case closed lol, owned lol
THE BOOM
THE BOOM had hits beyond 'Shima Uta' too — 'Manatsu no Kiseki' and 'Kaze ni Naritai' both sold well, and 'Hoshi no Love Letter' is well known too.
Monpachi (MONGOL800) has more than just 'Chiisana Koi no Uta' — there's 'Anata ni' and 'Mujun no Ue ni Saku Hana' too.
THE BOOM has 'Kaze ni Naritai' besides 'Shima Uta.'
If Pikotaro counts,
Moody Katsuyama is way more of a one-hit wonder.
Thought he was on par with 2700's 'Migi Hiji Hidari Hiji' (Right Elbow, Left Elbow), but then there's also AMEMIYA's 'Hiyashi Chuka Hajimemashita' (Starting Up the Cold Noodles).
There's 'Gingira Paradise' too.
'Yume no End wa Itsumo Mezamashi' and 'Doremifa Daijobu' —
I bet you've heard these.
BB Queens have more than that — 'Doremifa Daijobu,' 'Shogenaide yo Baby,' and others.
Yoko Takahashi
Naomi Tamura
LiSA
To the average listener, these are basically one-hit wonders.
Already mentioned above, but to the average person BOOWY counts as a one-hit wonder too.
Background and Talking Points
“One-hit wonder” has no official definition, so in survey-driven features like this one, whichever song sticks in respondents’ memory gets picked — meaning artists with multiple hits often get lumped in as “one-hit wonders” anyway. That looseness is exactly why names like Yuki Koyanagi, CCB, THE BOOM, and Misato Watanabe kept getting corrected with “no, that’s wrong” throughout the thread. Commenters also pointed out that singers behind anime theme songs — like the “Fist of the North Star” or “Hunter x Hunter” themes — tend to get labeled “one-hit wonders” even though that’s not really seen as their signature work, which highlights how this kind of feature is driven by audience memorability rather than actual chart performance. The article doesn’t mention it, but it’s worth noting these rankings are usually based on survey respondents’ impressions rather than airplay, streaming, or sales data, so the same song can rate very differently depending on the generation of the person answering.</analysis>
<parameter name="board">mnewsplus
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuhou+) thread “‘That One-Hit-Wonder Song’ Ranking — The Overwhelming #1 That Beat Out Eito’s ‘Kousui’…“
Leave a Reply