From our other sites
The story
The overseas version of ‘GTA6’ is stirring debate on 5ch’s Live News General board (なんでも実況G), with users saying its violent content is far more graphic than Japan’s CERO-rated domestic release. Clips posted online show grotesque details—like dismemberment—that are absent from the Japanese version, splitting the thread right down the middle: some call it “too gory” and say it “should be censored,” while others say they “want to play the overseas version” and ask “what’s even the point of censoring it?” The debate also spilled over into a broader discussion of what actually makes GTA fun as a series in the first place.
Honestly, maybe the gore-cut Japanese version was the better call after all…
Source: video.twimg.com / Original article here
What people said
Seriously, that's too gory
This is overkill
Didn't expect the new GTA to go this far
This is basically a gore-generating machine at this point
It always just struck me as something middle schoolers going through a rebellious phase would be into
I played one of the games briefly as a kid and never got what was so fun about it
The violent set pieces are famous, but is the story actually any good?
This is basically a massacre at this point
Running people over is already a massacre
No way I'm buying this
This one deserves to be censored
Same as how people ask "what's the point of Zelda's water physics?"—Nintendo fanboys praised that to the skies, so it's probably the same deal here
This is exactly the GTA I've been waiting for
I want to play the overseas version
There was something like that in Phoenix: Life Chapter (火の鳥生命編, a manga/anime by Osamu Tezuka)
The level of detail is insane
But it's so open-ended you don't know what to do with yourself
If you're the type who can find your own way to enjoy it, it might be the best thing ever
Background and Key Points of the Debate
The reason game content differs between Japanese and overseas versions is that, in order to meet the review standards of CERO (the Computer Entertainment Rating Organization), publishers often self-censor excessive violence for the domestic Japanese market. The GTA series in particular has repeatedly sparked discussion over the years for these differences between its overseas and Japanese releases, and this latest footage is simply the newest chapter in that pattern. What stood out in the thread was that two separate debates ran in parallel without ever converging: one over whether the content should be censored, and another over what actually makes the series fun as a game in the first place. It’s worth noting that whether violent video games actually affect real-world crime rates has no established academic consensus, and the claim raised in the thread that such games have a ‘cathartic’ or calming effect isn’t a well-supported mainstream view either.
*This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Live News General board) thread “[Sad News] Overseas GTA6 Is Way Too Gory.”
Leave a Reply