From our other sites
The story
On November 17, Kawasaki Frontale announced that it has secured the future signing of MF Minato Otani (20), currently enrolled at the University of Tsukuba, who will join the club starting January 2029. Despite his small frame — 170cm, 65kg — he boasts an impressive track record: an Inter-High School championship while at Shohei High School, and MVP honors at the All Japan University Football Championship as a freshman after enrolling at Tsukuba. Opinions on 5ch were split — some hailed him as “the biggest shock since Mitoma,” while others raised doubts about his size (“170cm might cut it in J1, but beyond that will be tough”) or questioned the timing of his discovery (“finding him at 20 is way too late”).
On November 17, Kawasaki Frontale announced that MF Minato Otani of the University of Tsukuba has agreed to join the club starting January 2029. News of the prospect, who had been drawing attention since his high school days, sparked reactions like “No way” and “What an absolute monster.”
Born October 1, 2006, Otani is 20 years old, stands 170cm, and weighs 65kg. After coming up through Takatsuki Minami AFC and Amazing Academy, he attended Shohei High School and is now a sophomore at the University of Tsukuba, set to graduate in 2029.
A technically gifted midfielder who mainly plays as an attacking midfielder or inside midfielder, he won the Inter-High School championship back in high school. In last year’s All Japan University Football Championship, he played a key role in his university’s title run and was named tournament MVP as a freshman.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
170cm, huh. There've been plenty of so-called "geniuses" this size before.
You only really find out once they go up against the world.
Sounds like the second coming of Ryunosuke Sato, who's completely frozen out in Spain right now.
Even at 170cm, there are examples like Nagatomo making it to Inter, or Sakamoto making it to the Premier League.
Don't hype him up too much — compare him to an actual soccer player.
"New Otani" sounds better.
Nah, it'd be "Kotani" instead, lol (a pun swapping the "Ō" [big] in Ōtani for "ko" [small])
Mitoma-level talents don't just pop up every day, you know
Use your head a little, lol
That came sooner than I expected
Mitoma, Nagato, and Ito all turned pro after college and became regular starters for the national team
If he were truly that great, wouldn't he turn pro without going to college (or drop out to do it)?
And the shortest guy on that squad was Nagatomo at 170cm
There happens to be just the right guy for that
Honestly, I haven't felt that way since Mitoma.
I thought Hirakawa at least would develop, but he's been no good since his injury
Like with Ito and Mitoma, maybe for late-developing Japanese players it's better to finish building up physically in college before heading to Europe
That's because their scout is short too — Mukojima, who used to be at Shimizu S-Pulse
Guess that's a weird way to put it though
The people tracking players that closely through high school and college are a hardcore subset even among soccer nerds — it basically never reaches the general public's eye
But there are guys who grow a ton in college, you know
Like Mitoma or Ueda
Messi, Maradona
Messi, Maradona, Ortega, Miccoli
I'm 178cm and 67kg.
Oh yeah? What sport do you play?
Nice try, toothpick (meaning: scrawny)
And the second-greatest player in soccer history is 165cm, for what it's worth
Background and Key Points of the Debate
2029, the year Otani is set to join, is when he — currently a sophomore — is scheduled to graduate. In Japan it’s common for promising college players to be locked down early with a pre-arranged “set to join” announcement while still enrolled, and this is another case of that pattern. The “Mitoma-level” comparisons flying around the thread aren’t just hype — Kaoru Mitoma himself rose to prominence through the University of Tsukuba’s national college championship before joining Kawasaki Frontale directly, so Otani is following almost the exact same path, which makes the comparison come naturally. At the same time, his 170cm/65kg frame is considered small even by J1 standards, let alone international ones, and the thread was full of skepticism (“can he really hold up at that size?”) alongside counterpoints noting that players like Nagatomo and Sakamoto succeeded in Europe despite being around 170cm themselves. As for the “discovered too late at 20” criticism, posters pushed back by pointing out that both Mitoma and Ueda saw major growth after entering college, suggesting that high-school-era evaluations alone can’t fully capture a player’s ceiling.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Soccer] 20-year-old prodigy set to join J1 powerhouse: “Are you serious?” National MVP as a freshman… one of the best midfielders of his generation: “Mitoma-level, right?”.”
Leave a Reply