Warning About Chinese EVs Met with Pushback: “Tesla’s Just as Bad”

From our other sites

The story

A former Canadian national security advisor sparked discussion on Lemmy’s Canada board (c/canada) after calling Chinese-made EVs “computers on wheels” and saying she personally wouldn’t buy one, citing concerns that personal data could end up in Chinese hands. In response, commenters repeatedly pushed back, arguing that the data-collection problem isn’t unique to Chinese EVs and applies just as much to American automakers like Tesla. Others countered that what really matters isn’t the data handling itself but whether you trust the Chinese government, splitting the discussion into two camps.

“A Computer on Wheels”: Former Canadian Security Advisor Says She Wouldn’t Buy a Chinese EV

Source: web.archive.org / Read the original article here

What people said

2Anonymous2026-11-18 11:00
This isn't just a Chinese EV thing. Every modern car is basically a computer on wheels at this point. Honestly, the data Tesla collects worries me just as much. Isn't the real problem that the data is being collected at all, rather than where it ends up going?
10Anonymous2026-11-18 11:04
Makes me wonder if there's an automaker from a country more trustworthy than an authoritarian state like China.
4Anonymous2026-11-18 11:34
Still beats having my data end up in America's hands.
7Anonymous2026-11-18 12:09
Fair point, agreed.
8Anonymous2026-11-18 12:51
Exactly this. She was advising a former provincial premier while carrying around a 'computer' in her pocket that ships data straight to a president. Wild when you think about it. I get it though — being cheap and easy to get your hands on is exactly what makes this a real threat.
5Anonymous2026-11-18 12:31
Wish we could just vote for someone who'd actually pass rules or laws banning this kind of thing!?
6Anonymous2026-11-18 12:13
Yeah, from what I've heard, a lot of those cars are nearly as bad as Tesla, which people call an 'iPhone on wheels.'
9Anonymous2026-11-18 13:23
Exactly. Whatever powers the car, it doesn't change the kind of data being sent out.
12Anonymous2026-11-18 11:22
Still think it matters, though. The Chinese government is one of the regimes you simply can't trust, and the issue runs deeper than just data security or privacy.

Background and Key Points of the Debate

Behind this remark lies growing wariness toward Chinese-made EVs across Canada and other Western countries. While security officials have singled out a specific country’s automakers, commenters on the thread repeatedly pointed out that data collection is a problem for connected cars in general — and Tesla is no exception. In reality, modern vehicles constantly collect driving data and location information, and “which country’s company the data gets sent to” is a separate question from “whether this kind of collection should be allowed at all.” The split in opinion comes down to which point people weigh more heavily: distrust of the Chinese government specifically, versus the view that American companies are just as untrustworthy. What’s easy to misread here is that this debate isn’t about some technical flaw unique to Chinese EVs — it’s fundamentally a question of governance and trust over who ultimately gets access to the data being collected.

※This article is a translated and edited excerpt from the Lemmy c/canada thread “‘A computer on wheels’: Former Canadian security advisor says she wouldn’t buy a Chinese EV.” Our editorial team is responsible for the translation.

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *