From our other sites
The story
On November 16, the Giants announced that seven players on their women’s team — Rina Kanaman, Natsuki Aimi, Nozomi Abe, Hinatsu Yamashita, Miu Tanaka, Ayaka Osada, and Momoko Noro — will leave the team at the end of December. The team, founded in December 2021, is now in its fifth year, and with these departures, none of its founding members remain. On 5ch, discussion started with the point that the name “Giants” gets confused with the Yomiuri Giants baseball club, and ranged across the uniform design, the shortage of opponents to play against, and income concerns stemming from the team’s status as a club team rather than a pro outfit — all reflecting broader issues facing women’s baseball.
At the Giants women’s team’s unveiling in December 2021 (from right): Kazutomo Miyamoto, Hinatsu Yamashita, Kiyoshi Yoshiyasu, Rina Kanaman, Ayuri Shimano, and then-manager Tatsunori Hara
[Women’s Baseball] Seven Giants Women’s Team Players Depart, Founding Members Now at Zero
On the 16th, the Giants announced that women’s team players Rina Kanaman, Natsuki Aimi, Nozomi Abe, Hinatsu Yamashita, Miu Tanaka, Ayaka Osada, and Momoko Noro will leave the team at the end of December.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Thing is, there's no baseball team actually named "Giants."
Already getting put on someone's ignore list this early in the day — what a piece of work.
So do you read it "Kinman Ririna-chan"?
Guess "real-life Hachinai" didn't work out after all (´・ω・`) (Hachinai = a baseball-themed idol mobile game)
I remember Wakasa Seikatsu (a health-supplement company) working hard to promote women's baseball —
turns out after that they went and formed a women's team.
Is it the material, or baseball uniforms in general — or honestly, probably both.
Seriously, what is it with how hopelessly uncool these women's baseball uniforms look?
I live in Fuchu now, which might be one of the Giants Women's so-called "home towns," and sometimes there are banners with the players' faces up along the street by the station — but they have zero appeal, honestly lol.
I think baseball caps and uniforms just completely cancel out whatever beauty or charm a woman might otherwise have.
They slide into bases, so shorts like in softball are a no-go.
A lot of people don't get that distinction, huh lol
It was ticketed, but it drew more fans than women's baseball does.
That's kind of sad.
Apparently they tour elementary schools around the Tama area, but the kids just stare blankly.
Japan actually had women's pro baseball too, right after the war (1950).
If a kid is seriously aiming to play baseball, maybe she's happy to wear a Giants uniform no matter how uncool it looks?
Still, instead of something this dorky, making it more girl-friendly might actually inspire more kids to look up to it.
I'd think it means more to play in the same uniform as pro teams like the Giants or Tigers and at least be treated as an affiliated team.
But joining doesn't mean much income either — they're treated as a club team.
The reason fewer kids play baseball is that mothers have come to hate the hassle of carting their kids to it.
So maybe increasing the number of women's baseball players will get those same mothers to let their kids take up baseball… and grow the player pool.
Jaiko (a play on "Giant" — also the tomboyish character from Doraemon)
These days you'd call it the "Female Titan" (a nod to Attack on Titan)
they can't keep playing around forever.
That's fine, though, isn't it —
it's just playing pretend.
Background and Talking Points
Giants Women is a hardball (not softball) women’s baseball team the Giants formed in December 2021. It’s run separately from the Yomiuri Giants as a club team, so its players’ treatment differs from that of contracted pro players. Japan has no unified professional league for women’s hardball baseball; a women’s pro baseball organization existed in the past, but it has since disbanded. Some in the thread speculated that the departures stemmed from friction between the players and management, but the team hasn’t disclosed its reasons, so that remains unsubstantiated speculation. Opinion split between those criticizing the uniform design and presentation and those who simply praised the fact that these women play hardball at all — a divide that reflected differing views on how women’s sports are perceived.
※This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuhō+) thread “[Women’s Baseball] Giants Women’s Team Loses 7 Players — Zero Founding Members Left After Five Years.”
Leave a Reply