From our other sites
The story
India’s high-speed rail project was supposed to introduce trains based on the E5 series (and eventually the E10 series) used on the Tohoku and Hokkaido Shinkansen lines. But in 2024, the Indian government announced it would instead adopt the “B28,” a train being developed by domestic manufacturer BEML, and on November 1st released footage of an inspection tour of the company’s factory. The signaling system is also reportedly being considered for a hybrid setup combining European standards, prompting some voices in Japan to call it a “bait-and-switch.” Reactions on 5ch split between those who blame lax contracts and weak negotiating on Japan’s side, and those who see this as typical behavior for emerging economies prioritizing domestic production.
Although the “Japanese Shinkansen” system was once adopted for India’s high-speed rail project, India’s recent announcements appear to be walking that back — drawing accusations of a “bait-and-switch” from the Japanese side. What’s really going on here? Is India really entirely to blame? Let’s take a calm, clear-eyed look.
(Part 1 of 2) (Writer: Hiroki Maebayashi)
● Is the “Shinkansen” approach in jeopardy? What is India’s high-speed rail project?
Source: diamond.jp / Original article here
What people said
If the contract specified 'everything made in Japan,' sure, that'd be a breach — otherwise, not really.
>First, the plan was for India to introduce trains based on the E5 series used on the Tohoku/Hokkaido Shinkansen (switching to an E10-series base from the 2030s onward).
But in 2024, the Indian government suddenly announced it would use the "B28," a train developed by domestic manufacturer BEML instead.
On November 1st, India's National High Speed Rail Corporation (NHSRCL) announced that the country's Transport Minister had toured the B28 factory. The official photos clearly show seats and car-body frames still under development.
>Having once adopted the Japanese Shinkansen system, India is now considering domestic development and a mix of European standards instead — leaving the Japanese side blindsided, with people calling it "a bolt from the blue" and "a bait-and-switch."
Japan's negotiating skills are way too weak.
They should've locked the whole contract down from the start
and written in penalty clauses for any reversal.
Exactly this.
There are way too many naively honest Japanese executives who don't even operate on the assumption that foreigners might not keep their word. It's a real problem.
Taiwan also adopted Japanese-made trains, and in the end it went with European-style signaling too.
Like someone said above, a system that can fall back to single-track operation in a pinch probably looks more appealing than Japan's double-track approach.
JR should be aiming at developed countries instead, like Hitachi does.
Poor Toshiba, who went after the US market… (´・ω・`)
You guys just don't have what it takes to do business!!
Yeah, honestly I think that's true.
Japan's been called an economic superpower, but that was just because the products were good — sales and negotiating ability have always been weak.
About that —
in the end, they decided not to resume importing used trains from Japan after all.
Australia went Japan → France → US for its warships, and came right back to Japan in the end.
If Japan can't make it work with Australia, it probably won't work with most other countries either —
that's probably why they rely on Hitachi and Toyota for commercial vehicles instead.
That's just normal for most of the world.
Kind of envious of that 'just treat it like a home appliance' mindset.
Guess that way of thinking is the same everywhere, huh.
No wonder Suzuki sells so well there lol
Taiwan, which bought Japanese Shinkansen trains, also runs a mixed/mishmash system, and so far nothing's gone wrong.
Japan's Shinkansen might be excellent, especially for tightly packed schedules, but honestly, the cost-performance is bad.
The reason Japan's operating systems tend to lose out to Western rivals is that the West's killer line is basically, 'But Japan had the Fukuchiyama Line derailment too!' (the 2005 JR West commuter-line crash)
The logic being: if even a regular commuter line can have a major accident, the system must actually be dangerous.
Once that card gets played, Japan's operating systems don't have a strong comeback.
'we should've just stuck with the Japanese Shinkansen.'
Indians don't do regret.
Didn't India already overtake Japan in GDP?
And apparently even Indonesia — a country Japan used to look down on — is projected to pass it too, around 2030 lol
Background and Key Points of This Topic
India’s high-speed rail project was set, under a 2015 Japan-India agreement, to use trains based on the E5 series (eventually E10 series) from the Tohoku/Hokkaido Shinkansen. In 2024, however, India announced it would adopt the “B28,” a train developed by domestic manufacturer BEML, and is reportedly also considering combining the signaling system with European standards. The thread split over whether this counts as a breach of contract or reasonable nurturing of domestic industry, with some blaming Japan’s weak negotiating position and loose contract terms, and others noting that it’s typical for emerging economies to raise their domestic-production ratio. A common point of confusion is that the Shinkansen approach hasn’t been scrapped wholesale — only part of the trains and signaling is being swapped out. As the thread itself points out, Taiwan’s high-speed rail also pairs Japanese-made trains with European-style signaling, and a hybrid system doesn’t automatically mean failure.
*This article is an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (News Speed+) thread ‘[Bait-and-Switch] India’s High-Speed Rail Was Supposed to Choose the “Japanese Shinkansen” — So Why Did It End Up with “Indian-Made Trains, German-Made Signals”?‘.
Leave a Reply