From our other sites
The story
A thread titled “NISA Crashes and Burns for Good” on 5ch’s morningcoffee board drew a wave of reports that NISA assets built up through regular investing earlier this year had fallen back to where they started at the beginning of the year. Some pointed out that the S&P 500 is still up slightly year-to-date, and that converted into yen it’s actually a net gain. Opinions split between those who see the dip as a buying opportunity for continued investing and pessimists who declared this year’s investments a total waste, with one case drawing particular attention: someone who bought Kioxia stock through NISA’s growth investment quota and took a massive loss.
Sounds like something big is going on
What’s happening here?
Source: x.com / original post here
What people said
but it all snapped right back to where it started the year, making this whole year's investing completely pointless lol
Rising then falling is actually worse for people dollar-cost averaging
Wait, what
Weren't people on Kenmo (a 5ch board) laughing nonstop about their NISA gains just the other day?
As in 'nai sa' — 'there's nothin' there' (a pun on NISA sounding like the Japanese for 'there's none')
https://www.yuhikaku.co.jp/static_files/18447_figure_4-4.pdf
When it's falling: bargain sale
The S&P 500 is only +0.76% year-to-date
and you call that 'way higher' lol
Because in yen terms it's up more than 5%
Government bonds are done for too
The only ones left to buy in after that are dogs
Stock market 101
You said the exact same thing during the Bitcoin crash too
but it's actually a great time to start regular investing
Everyone else should've just kept the money in savings
The leftover money's been flowing into defense stocks, and even so we're seeing this
If the US actually hikes rates by 0.5%, it won't recover for 10 years
If anything, the best-case scenario for long-term investing is staying at rock bottom the whole way through and only spiking right when you're about to sell
No it's not — your average cost basis is a moving average, remember
Shouldn't you fill it up gradually bit by bit to smooth things out?
If you dump the full annual limit in all at once and then something like the Lehman shock hits and it tanks, can you ever recover from that?
This year, only the lump-sum-at-New-Year's crowd won
I've only got like 500,000 yen to my name
Re: #60 Someone chasing 'oku-ri-bito' status bought Kioxia through NISA and is now bragging about their massive loss on X
Kioxia
June: 110,000
Now: 22,000
A whopping 80% off!!
Background and Key Points of This Topic
Following the 2024 expansion of the NISA system, it became a permanent framework allowing up to 3.6 million yen per year (1.2 million yen in the regular investment quota, 2.4 million yen in the growth investment quota) in investment gains to go tax-free with no time limit. Because it’s designed around long-term, continuous investing, it was never meant to be judged by short-term price swings. The split in opinion on the thread comes down to this difference in assumptions: the view that “a dip is a buying opportunity if you’re investing long-term” is closer to the spirit of the system, while the view that “this year’s investments became pointless once prices fell back to where they started” only looks at short-term gains and losses. It’s also worth noting that some posters reported big losses on individual stocks — NISA’s tax-free allowance covers not just regular investment-trust funds but also individual stocks under the growth investment quota, meaning picking the wrong stock can genuinely lead to major losses under the system.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “NISA Crashes and Burns for Good.”
Leave a Reply