Category: Baseball

  • Keio University’s Hironari Hiroike to Challenge MLB Without Going Through NPB — 5ch: “Let’s See Results First, Then We’ll Talk”

    Keio University pitcher Hironari Hiroike (22) has decided to pursue a challenge in MLB without going through NPB if he isn’t drafted at the October 22 NPB Draft Meeting, Nikkan Sports reported. He throws a fastball topping out at 156 km/h (97 mph), and several US teams, including the Rangers and Yankees, are reportedly interested. His father is Koji Hiroike (53), general manager of the Seibu Lions, and if this comes to pass, he would follow fellow Keio alum Kotaro Tsunematsu (22), who signed with the Cubs last year, becoming the second straight year a Keio player has joined an MLB organization. On 5ch, discussion spread to cover the difficulty of challenging the majors without NPB experience, the attention drawn by his father’s position as a team executive, and the current struggles of Tsunematsu, who went to the US before him.

    Nikkan Sports

    [October 14, 2026, 4:55 AM]

    It was learned on the 13th that Keio University pitcher Hironari Hiroike (senior = Keio), son of Seibu Lions general manager Koji Hiroike (53) and owner of a fastball that tops out at 156 km/h, has decided to pursue a challenge in MLB without going through NPB. If he is not drafted at the October 22 Draft Meeting, he will accelerate the move to the majors he has been harboring. Negotiations would come after the full official schedule concludes, but if realized, he would follow outfielder Kotaro Tsunematsu (22), who signed with the Cubs last year, as the second consecutive year a Keio player has joined an MLB organization. According to sources in the baseball world, several US teams have already shown interest, making his future moves one to watch closely.

    Source: nikkansports.com / Original article here

    2AnonymousOct 14, 2026 05:59
    Go to a good university and get a good dog
    That way you'll be set for life thanks to the seniority system

      (∪^ω^) Woof woof!
    = 〔~∪ ̄ ̄〕
    =  ◎――◎
    4AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:10
    Clawing your way up from the minors is brutal in MLB. In Japan there's still a shot ("wanchan" — punning on "one chance" and the dog joke above) of going straight into the starting lineup on the top team.
    6AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:17
    Re: #4
    That TDN guy made it to the majors in about two years though.
    8AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:20
    Re: #4
    The only Japanese pitchers without NPB experience who've ever made it to the majors are probably Mac Suzuki, Tadano, and Tazawa.
    And they were all first-round-pick caliber.
    60AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:10
    Re: #4
    What about Roki Sasaki?
    5AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:13
    Well, let's see some results first.
    We'll talk after that.
    7AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:19
    Seibu drafts him in the developmental slot
    → "I was moved by GM Hiroike's persuasion, I'll sign with Seibu"
    What are the odds of this actually happening?
    28AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:02
    Re: #7
    In that case, Seibu would need to draft him in that year's draft.
    9AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:20
    Re: #4
    Because NPB doesn't really "develop" players —
    pitch-count management and position assignments are all one-sided.
    10AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:21
    If it doesn't work out, Daddy's probably got a job lined up for him too, right?

    Must be nice being a Keio kid.
    12AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:32
    Come to think of it, what's Tsunematsu up to these days?
    16AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:37
    Re: #12
    Apparently he got married. Well, if you can afford to get married while still in the minors, he's probably got other options even if baseball doesn't pan out.
    48AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:37
    Re: #12
    He broke his wrist this season and has
    only played in 6 games.
    13AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:33
    Well, he's not top-tier talent so I think it's a "sure, go ahead" situation. That Tsunematsu guy only went to America because he went undrafted too.
    14AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:34
    He seems like he'd do decently in NPB, so why bother?
    He could just live comfortably with Seibu.
    15AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:36
    Did Hiroike really rise all the way to GM despite not having much of a pro playing record?
    27AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:01
    Re: #15
    He's the key figure behind this year's Seibu resurgence on the front-office side.
    Seems like a pretty capable guy.
    37AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:15
    Re: #15
    Having a good playing record doesn't automatically mean you're good at the job either. He was probably just a competent professional in his own right.
    17AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:37
    So that Hiroike's son grew into such a fine pitcher.
    The father himself hurt his shoulder and played as a fielder through high school, college, and corporate-league ball, yet still entered the pros as a pitcher.
    If he hadn't hurt his shoulder, he might have become an incredible pitcher.
    18AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:37
    Even if it doesn't work out, top companies will hire him just for having taken the challenge, right?
    20AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:43
    I'd rather have Iiyama Junior than Hiroike Junior.
    33AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:06
    Re: #20
    Who the heck is Iiyama?
    21AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:44
    The father's career history is way too interesting.
    44AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:28
    Re: #21
    Hiroike gives off a strong Hiroshima image, but
    far from having no connection to Seibu,
    he was actually a member of the Seibu Lions Fan Club
    as a kid,
    so he's basically one of the longest-standing Seibu Lions fans there is.
    22AnonymousOct 14, 2026 06:44
    His dad is a guy who carved out his own path to the pros too.
    41AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:25
    By the way, Rintaro, 22, who signed with the Marlins this year, will be in the rookie league next year,
    and Morii, who signed last year, is currently in a lower-level A-ball league.

    If they don't produce results within a few years, they'll be cut.
    It's not like they'll wait eight years for you the way they did for Neo.
    —
    https://ja.wikipedia.org/wiki/日本人のマイナーリーグ選手一覧

    ① MLB — Ohtani, Yamamoto, Seiya, and others
    ② AAA — Chicago's Nishida (2023)
    ③ AA — Athletics' Tomioka (2020)
    ④ High-A — Seattle's Oyama Seiichiro (2025)
    ⑤ Low-A — Athletics' Morii (2025), San Diego's Moriki (2026, formerly Hanshin)
    ⑥ Rookie — Cubs' Tsunematsu (2025), Miami's Sasaki Rintaro (2026)
    46AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:31
    Re: #41
    Is Nishida actually pretty amazing?
    49AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:37
    Re: #46
    > Re: #41
    > Is Nishida actually pretty amazing?

    Nishida is definitely one of the success stories.
    He went from Tohoku High School to a US college, then
    got picked in the 11th round (329th overall) of the 2023 MLB Draft.
    From there, he made it to the majors in just three years.

    He's small (168cm/5'6"), but he probably got noticed for being able to play a
    heads-up, detail-oriented brand of baseball.
    42AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:25
    Let's be honest, Big-Six-league Keio is a pain to deal with.
    They don't impose an obvious round cutoff,
    but there's an atmosphere where the baseball team's pride makes them resist low-round or developmental picks.

    Even though Kiyohara's son himself says he doesn't care about that,
    the coach and the OBs (alumni) around him make a fuss about it — of course he doesn't get drafted.
    45AnonymousOct 14, 2026 07:30
    Re: #42
    That's probably why Tanida Seigo went undrafted too.
    56AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:03
    Guys who take on challenges like this are fools.
    Giving up from the start and doing nothing, like us, is the real win.
    57AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:08
    Re: #56
    There's no winning or losing.
    In Dragon Quest terms, you're still level 1.
    71AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:23
    Re: #60
    Still, that guy built his record as a pro first, so it's totally different.
    82AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:34
    Re: #71
    As a reply to that post it works fine and isn't wrong.
    72AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:23
    There are tons of pitchers out there who can only throw hard.
    85AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:38
    Re: #72
    Why is the Dodgers' Enriquez — a flamethrower on the level of Mizurowski (was that the name?) — stuck as like the 5th reliever in the bullpen?
    If he's got heat like that, he should just learn three more pitches and start instead.
    He's throwing 164 km/h (102 mph) without even trying hard.
    84AnonymousOct 14, 2026 08:37
    Well, if you're a Keio grad, making some memories in the US before slipping into a top-tier company might honestly be smarter than floundering around in NPB.

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    Among Japanese pitchers who went straight to the majors without going through NPB, only a handful — Mac Suzuki, Kazuhito Tadano, and Junichi Tazawa — actually managed to stick in MLB. Roki Sasaki, whose name came up in the thread, is a different case: he was posted after building a track record in NPB first, so the premise doesn’t match Hiroike’s situation. Meanwhile, Hiroike’s father, Koji Hiroike, is drawing attention less for his own playing record than for his reputation as the front-office figure credited with Seibu’s roster-building behind this season’s resurgence — turning jabs like “he got promoted despite a thin playing record” into, in effect, a fair acknowledgment of his front-office skill. The comparison repeatedly cited was Kotaro Tsunematsu (22), who signed a minor-league deal with the Cubs last year but has struggled this season — hitting .150 in just 6 games after a wrist fracture — serving as a recurring example of how hard it is to aim directly for the majors. The thread’s discussion settled into two overlapping threads: “how difficult it is to challenge MLB without going through NPB” and “this is a path only available because of his Keio background and family circumstances,” mixing genuine evaluation of his ability with pointed commentary on his social background.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “Keio’s Hironari Hiroike leaning toward an MLB challenge, drawing interest from multiple teams including the Rangers and Yankees — following Keio alum Kotaro Tsunematsu (22), who signed with the Cubs last year.”

  • Chunichi Dragons Announce Departure of Four Coaches: Nobuhiko Matsunaka, Ryosuke Hirata, Eiji Ochiai, and Yutaka Nakamura

    On October 13, the Chunichi Dragons announced that four coaches — Nobuhiko Matsunaka, Ryosuke Hirata, Eiji Ochiai, and Yutaka Nakamura — will be leaving the team at the end of this season. Matsunaka spent his entire playing career with Daiei/SoftBank and was crowned the sole Triple Crown winner of the Heisei era in 2004; he had served as Chunichi’s batting coach for the past two years since 2025. The team’s announcement gives no reason for the departures, but on 5ch the main topic became speculation about bad blood between Matsunaka and Kimiyasu Kudo — currently with SoftBank and expected to become Chunichi’s next manager. Opinion was split between those who blame Kudo’s side for the rift and those who say the problem lay in Matsunaka’s own conduct as a player.

    On the 13th, Chunichi announced that four coaches — Nobuhiko Matsunaka, Ryosuke Hirata, Eiji Ochiai, and Yutaka Nakamura — would be leaving the team at the end of this season.

    Matsunaka spent his entire playing career with Daiei/SoftBank and was crowned the sole Triple Crown winner of the Heisei era in ’04. He became Chunichi’s batting coach starting in ’25 and spent two years coaching the team’s position players.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    8AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:29
    Did Kudo and Matsunaka ever patch things up?
    9AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:30
    Matsunaka went to PayPay Dome to cover the Japan Series in person, but was only allowed to report from behind the backstop netting
    11AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:31
    Fine that these guys are leaving, but what are they gonna do for income next year?
    12AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:31
    There's a rumor Matsunaka and Kudo are on bad terms — is that actually true?
    28AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:38
    Re: #12
    There's a lot of speculation, but here's the thing:
    in 2015, Kudo's first year as manager, Matsunaka started the season in the farm league and never got called up even while hitting close to .300.
    He finally got a first-team spot in a meaningless late-season game after the standings were already decided.
    He was hoping to keep playing, but retired right after.
    Just from that alone, it's hard not to assume there was bad blood.
    67AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:09
    Re: #12
    It's not just Kudo — he's disliked by pretty much everyone connected to the Hawks.

    It's all on Matsunaka.
    13AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:31
    Probably Kudo's call.
    At the very least, it looks like he's decided these four aren't needed under him.
    16AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:32
    I mean, who'd even want to be coached by Hirata anyway
    17AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:33
    Doesn't make sense for the coaches to stick around when the manager's changing
    19AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:34
    If Kudo's the manager, there's no way Matsunaka stays
    20AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:35
    Is Hirata getting a retirement ceremony?
    21AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:35
    Does Matsunaka even have anyone he's on good terms with in the first place?
    22AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:35
    The decisive falling-out between Matsunaka and the Hawks was during Akiyama's time as manager, and Akiyama and Kudo have been close since their Seibu days, so yeah, this outcome makes sense.
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:40
    Matsunaka's always been that self-centered type wherever he goes
    36AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:46
    I don't think a weak team that's been fighting for last place for years is suddenly going to pull off a miracle championship just because the manager and coaches changed, but at least trying to change is a good thing.
    They should also rethink their reinforcements and draft strategy.
    42AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:50
    Re: #36
    Like this year's Yakult — if Murakami had stayed, they probably would've made the Climax Series, no?
    39AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:48
    Matsunaka was brought in by Inoue in the first place.
    Ochiai was planning to leave together with Tatsunami, but only stayed on because Inoue asked him to — so of course he's leaving now.

    What's surprising is Hirata leaving, and are they not cutting Asao?
    85AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:19
    Re: #39
    Asao's still popular, so…
    48AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:53
    Is Matsunaka actually banned from the Hawks organization or something?
    99AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:25
    Re: #48
    Forget banned — he's been erased from the legend tier, scrubbed from the team's history entirely.
    Of course he wasn't invited to the recent Hawks alumni game either.
    Even TV won't touch the subject, despite his wife being a former Fukuoka announcer.
    None of the Hawks players even bring him up.
    The only exception is Matsuda, who — being the airhead he is — mentioned him briefly about some offseason training thing.
    52AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:56
    If Kudo's the manager, maybe they can get some players out of SoftBank
    104AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:27
    Re: #52
    Jojima from the Hawks front office seemed happy about the idea that the two teams could cooperate on various things, saying it's easier since they're in different leagues.
    55AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:00
    When Matsunaka came to the stadium to give his farewell greeting after leaving SoftBank, Kudo was incredibly cold toward him.
    I thought Kudo was being harsh, but
    seeing Matsunaka's behavior afterward, it seems like there was a lot of fault on his side too.
    109AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:30
    Re: #55
    Matsunaka's the one with way too many problems.
    He's beyond just selfish —
    he disrupts the atmosphere and breaks the organization down.
    62AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:07
    The general consensus seems to be that Matsunaka's conduct as an active player was a serious problem.
    Maybe he's turned over a new leaf since then, though.
    68AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:09
    Re: #62
    Unless he's willing to cheerfully take on equipment-manager duties like Irai did, I doubt Kudo would ever accept him.
    114AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:32
    Re: #62
    Matsunaka isn't even self-aware enough to have turned over a new leaf.
    Doesn't look like he thinks he's in the wrong at all.
    73AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:11
    Matsunaka leaving is good news.
    Now maybe the players will actually start practicing seriously.
    92AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:21
    Re: #73
    The Dragons' hitting slump isn't Matsunaka's fault ("Chuni Dora" is a nickname for the Chunichi Dragons)
    88AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:20
    We all knew Matsunaka was leaving, but Hirata's a different story, right?
    (´・ω・\`) (a shrugging emoticon)
    110AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:31
    Re: #88
    As a third-base coach, his situational judgment was terrible — basically a broken traffic signal
    91AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:21
    Guys like Matsunaka and Nakamura Norihiro who are way too full of themselves are exactly the type Kudo hates most
    94AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:22
    Re: #91
    Kudo's the bigger egomaniac himself, as always
    96AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:24
    There are so many legends like Iwase, Kawakami, and Masa (likely Yamamoto Masa) — so why Asao and Yamai?
    105AnonymousOct 13, 2026 19:28
    Re: #96
    If that logic held, there's no way Inoue would've been picked

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    Matsunaka was the slugging centerpiece of the old Daiei/SoftBank Hawks, crowned the sole “Triple Crown” winner of the Heisei era in 2004, and had served as Chunichi’s batting coach since 2025. The team’s own announcement gives no explanation at all for the departures and doesn’t even mention Kimiyasu Kudo by name. The repeated talk in the thread about bad blood with Kudo is speculation built on the assumption that Kudo will become Chunichi’s manager next season, with posters pointing to the fact that back in 2015 — Kudo’s first year as SoftBank manager — Matsunaka hit close to .300 in the farm league yet was never called up to the first team. Views on the cause are split, though: some blame Kudo’s handling of the situation, while many others say Matsunaka’s own conduct as a player created friction within the organization. What readers should be careful not to misread is that the direct causal link between the departure and Kudo is not a fact confirmed by the team’s announcement — it remains pure speculation on 5ch.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] Chunichi Dragons Announce Departure of Four Coaches: Matsunaka, Hirata, Ochiai, and Nakamura.”

  • Chunichi Dragons Part Ways with Coaches Matsunaka, Hirata, Ochiai Eiji, and Nakamura Yutaka — 5ch: “The Coaching Staff Was Actually Fine”

    On the 13th, the Chunichi Dragons announced that four coaches — Nobuhiko Matsunaka, Ryosuke Hirata, Eiji Ochiai, and Yutaka Nakamura — will leave the team at the end of this season. Speculation is strong that Kimiyasu Kudo will take over as the new manager, and this coaching shake-up is seen as part of a broader restructuring in which the front office is said to be holding the reins on personnel decisions. On 5ch threads, some posters said the accomplished Ochiai shouldn’t have trouble finding his next job, while many others noted it’s hard to predict where Matsunaka or Hirata will land next. The discussion also grew heated over conflicting views: some argued the coaching staff itself wasn’t the problem — the manager was — while others took issue with the team filling the roles mostly with former players (OBs).

    1AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:26
    On the 13th, the Chunichi Dragons announced that four coaches — Nobuhiko Matsunaka, Ryosuke Hirata, Eiji Ochiai, and Yutaka Nakamura — will be leaving the team at the end of this season.
    2AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:27
    Ochiai Eiji's got the track record to land anywhere, really
    But Matsunaka and Hirata…
    Wonder what they'll do
    3AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:28
    So they're bringing in coaches from SoftBank, huh
    4AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:28
    I actually thought Matsunaka was pretty decent, but I guess he just doesn't click with Kudo?
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:42
    Re: #4
    Matsunaka was brought in by Inoue
    Same prefecture (Kagoshima), same generation
    I think Inoue was a year or two above Matsunaka in school
    Since Inoue resigned, Matsunaka's probably stepping down too
    5AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:28
    Well, they can't exactly poach Kurano or Torigoe…
    8AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:29
    It's all the sketchy ones left, lol
    And Asao staying on makes it even funnier
    12AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:33
    Will Nakamura Yutaka head back to the Fighters or the Tigers, I wonder
    13AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:33
    Hirata had already been pulled from third-base coach duty, so this was expected
    15AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:34
    Word was Kudo has zero say in personnel and it's all "ChunDra" (the Chunichi front office) calling the shots, but I guess they read the room enough to cut Matsunaka lol
    19AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:35
    Re: #15
    They said they'd at least listen to his input, so it's not like he has zero say at all
    18AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:35
    Hirata will probably just go back to being a commentator and YouTuber and take it easy
    Wouldn't be surprising if another team scoops up Matsunaka
    Asao and Yamai are probably future manager candidates, so they probably didn't want to tarnish their résumés
    21AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:36
    Hirata will probably leak all kinds of inside info on Yakyu Ikkan (a baseball talk show/YouTube channel) or something
    22AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:36
    Is Kudo actually confirmed?
    25AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:37
    Re: #22
    He said so himself at a talk show
    23AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:37
    I remember Hirata running a yakiniku (Japanese BBQ) joint or something — didn't realize he'd become a Chunichi coach
    24AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:37
    Yamai and Asao should just step down on their own
    26AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:38
    Yamai staying on as coach…
    This team's got zero drive
    27AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:38
    I would've loved to see it if Kudo became manager and Matsunaka his coach
    29AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:39
    Didn't expect them to keep even Asao, who "Donden" (a pundit's nickname) said should be fired
    Guess the merch sales must've been that good
    30AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:39
    Come to think of it, if Kudo — who's actually managed before — is taking over, they don't need HC Shima anymore, right?
    31AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:40
    The coaching staff was actually fine
    It was the manager who was the problem
    34AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:44
    Ochiai did say he'd quit together with Tatsu(nori) back then
    Matsunaka and Hirata's exits look front-office-driven, so Kudo probably isn't thrilled about that
    Shima might be better suited for something like Yakult's farm team
    35AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:45
    Ochiai Eiji was practically the leader of the "Chunichi Reform Coalition"
    Wish he could've at least joined the front office and kept pushing reforms
    42AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:49
    Re: #32
    Matsunaka's from Kumamoto though
    82AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:04
    Re: #42
    I meant to write "same Kyushu" and typo'd it
    54AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:53
    If you spend as much money as SoftBank, you can basically build another SoftBank — but is Chunichi willing to spend that much?
    69AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:58
    Re: #54
    SoftBank took many years to get where they are too, it'll take a long time to reach that same scale
    61AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:56
    The coaches who stuck around must've recognized Kudo's got real ability
    So he must be good
    Kudo's got a great eye for talent, that's why he's won so many titles
    66AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:57
    Re: #61
    It's sad as a fan knowing Manager Kudo's reputation is going to crash and burn over the next few years 😭
    73AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:00
    Re: #69
    Even Oh alone took 10 years
    78AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:01
    Re: #73
    It took 5 years just to get to the raw-egg incident (fans famously threw eggs at his car during a losing streak)
    83AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:05
    When Kudo first took over, he brought in Iraki and Sekikawa as coaches even though he barely knew them, so I don't think he's particularly picky about that
    88AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:10
    Re: #83
    Well, SoftBank's going to win no matter who the coaches are
    97AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:14
    Matsunaka's stats after winning the Triple Crown were just brutal
    But he still brought in guys like Iguchi as coaches, so maybe he's surprisingly cut out for coaching after all
    99AnonymousOct 13, 2026 18:15
    Re: #97
    In 2005 he won two of the three crowns, and his batting average was still good in 2006
    He dropped off in 2007 but bounced back a bit in 2008
    It's really from 2009 onward that it got bad

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    Of the four coaches whose departures were announced, Eiji Ochiai and Yutaka Nakamura had long handled infield and baserunning instruction, Ryosuke Hirata was in charge of outfield defense, and Nobuhiko Matsunaka — brought in from SoftBank — handled batting. On 5ch, all sorts of speculation is flying about next season’s setup and who actually holds the reins on personnel decisions, but the only fact the team has confirmed is that the four coaches will leave at the end of this season; as of this writing, no successors or next destinations for any of them have been decided. Views on the coaching staff itself are also split, with some supporting the shake-up and others questioning why only the coaches are being replaced when the manager was the real problem — readers should keep the speculation in the thread separate from the facts the team has actually announced.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Chunichi Announces Departure of Coaches Matsunaka, Hirata, Ochiai Eiji, and Nakamura Yutaka.”

  • Shinnosuke Abe’s Reported Return to the Giants Draws Comment from Rakugo Star Tatekawa Shiraku — 5ch Fires Back: “He’s the One Who Took Baseball Away From Himself”

    Rakugo performer Tatekawa Shiraku posted on his own X account about reports that former Yomiuri Giants manager Shinnosuke Abe will return to the team, writing “I hope they welcome him back as manager” and “In the end, they took baseball away from the father she loves so much…” His comments became a hot topic. Abe had resigned as manager amid a power-harassment (pawahara) scandal, and Shiraku’s remarks were clearly meant to support his comeback. On 5ch, though, reactions leaned far more critical than sympathetic, with posts like “He’s the one who took baseball away from himself” and “Why is some outsider speaking for his daughter’s feelings?” standing out — opinion split over whether to weigh Abe’s own responsibility or his family’s situation more heavily.

    October 13, 2026, 16:00

    Rakugo performer Tatekawa Shiraku (63) updated his “X” account on the 12th, commenting on reports that former Yomiuri Giants (professional baseball) manager Shinnosuke Abe would be returning to the team.

    Shiraku brought up the news, saying, “Word just came in that the Giants are preparing to bring back former manager Shinnosuke Abe — who resigned over a power-harassment scandal — in a senior role.” He then shared his thoughts: “For now, I’m glad. Of course there are people saying it’s too soon and all that, but personally, I’m genuinely happy about it. If possible, I’d like them to bring him back as manager, though there are probably various hurdles in the way.”

    Source: tokyo-sports.co.jp / original article here

    2AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:26
    5AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:27
    Do people in Tokyo actually laugh at this guy's rakugo?
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:44
    Re: #5
    Never even watched it, and I have zero desire to waste my time doing so.
    7AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:29
    He's the one who took baseball away from himself.
    11AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:31
    Re: #7
    Exactly this.
    The guy saying it is probably so wrapped up in the moment he doesn't even realize he's basically trashing someone.
    14AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:32
    Matsumoto, Nakai, Tsuzuki, Abe…
    This guy sure goes soft on anyone who causes a scandal.
    80AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:16
    Re: #14
    On the flip side, name one celebrity Shiraku's actually gone after?
    85AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:20
    Re: #14
    Tatekawa Shiraku went easy on Kaishu Sano and Junya Ito too.
    15AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:33
    No guarantee she actually sees him as "the father she loves so much," though.
    16AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:36
    Why's some outsider speaking for the daughter's feelings?
    18AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:37
    I don't really mind either way, but it makes you wonder what the point of accepting his resignation in the first place even was.
    22AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:37
    His backer is the second-generation head of Maruhan (the pachinko giant), you know.
    Even the Giants can't just cut him loose that easily.
    He'll probably do a senior-director type role for 3-4 years, then it's Abe Administration: Part Two after Yoshinobu.
    24AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:39
    > "In the end, they took baseball away from the father she loves so much."
    86AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:20
    Re: #24
    That's basically saying the daughter is the one in the wrong.
    39AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:46
    First recorded case of Chappy (slang for ChatGPT) "socially killing" a human being.
    40AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:47
    What's that supposed to mean?
    Even as a defense, that's just dumb.
    43AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:48
    The Giants can do whatever they want now that Nagashima, Harimoto, and Oh have passed away.
    45AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:50
    Nothing but bad debt collected — feel sorry for whoever's the next manager.
    47AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:52
    Classic Shiraku — delicacy goes out the window the second he wants to make his point.
    51AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:54
    He "understands the daughter's feelings"…?
    Oh, so he quit rakugo to become a spirit medium (itako)?
    That might actually suit him better, good luck with that.
    62AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:04
    Re: #51
    He can't even understand his own wife's feelings, so there's no way he understands his daughter's.
    52AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:54
    Tatekawa Danshi's greatest masterpiece just spoke!
    83AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:19
    Re: #52
    No, that'd be Shinosuke.
    53AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:54
    Why would this guy have any clue how the daughter feels…
    55AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:58
    He got drunk and committed domestic violence.
    The daughter is the victim.
    Blaming the victim is straight-up Showa-era thinking.
    56AnonymousOct 13, 2026 16:59
    This guy's only saying it to boost his own likability.
    Bringing Abe back as manager now would get nothing but backlash.
    61AnonymousOct 13, 2026 17:03
    Re: #56
    It all depends on what he'd actually do once he's back.

    Background and Key Points of This Story

    Shinnosuke Abe resigned as Giants manager amid a power-harassment scandal tied to a domestic dispute, and the reports of his return to the team are essentially a follow-up to that episode. As a television personality, Tatekawa Shiraku frequently comments on both entertainment and sports news, and he has made headlines before for defending celebrities caught up in controversy. The split in this thread ran along two lines of criticism: that Shiraku was “too sympathetic toward someone who resigned through his own fault,” and that it was “inappropriate for an outsider to speculate about a family matter” in the first place — in both cases, the pushback was really aimed at Shiraku’s remarks themselves. Worth noting: no details about the resignation or the family situation beyond what’s in the original article have been confirmed on 5ch, and many of the speculative comments in the thread are unsubstantiated. The text also doesn’t specify the age or circumstances of Abe’s daughter, so readers are better off treating this as a story about Shiraku’s comments versus the noticeably cooler reaction to them, rather than as confirmed fact.

    *This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Geino/Sports News+) thread “Tatekawa Shiraku relieved at reports of former manager Shinnosuke Abe’s return to the team: “I hope they bring him back as manager,” “In the end they took baseball away from the father she loves so much…” [Ailuropoda melanoleuca★].”

  • Shohei Ohtani Hitting .150 in the Postseason, Could Be Benched Next Game — 5ch: ‘He Can’t Even Make Contact’

    As the Dodgers keep piling up postseason losses, U.S. media outlets have reported en masse that Shohei Ohtani could be left out of the starting lineup for the next game. His postseason batting average sits at a dismal .150 with zero RBIs this year, and fans are also debating how to square that slump with the seven years still remaining on his contract. In the 5ch live-reaction thread, opinions clashed between those who think he should rest on the bench for a while, those speculating he might be nursing an injury, and those defending him by pointing to his two-way heroics in last year’s NLCS — leaving the thread split on whether to keep playing him or give him a break.

    Two Hours After the Dodgers’ Loss… Breaking Ohtani ‘News’ Hits — U.S. Media Reports en Masse as Decision Time Looms

    Full-Count

    Ohtani is batting .150 with 0 RBIs this postseason

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    15AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:30
    Ohtani always goes full throttle on everything.

    A guy that big running that hard like that is bound to wreck his knees eventually.

    He should quit stealing bases.
    46AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:39
    Re: #15
    It's a soft, non-contact sport and running hard still gets you hurt?
    What kind of wimpy sport is this lol
    16AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:30
    Even if they bench him, just leaving him on the bench won't help — he's a reverse mood-maker, after all (he drags the team's energy down instead of lifting it).
    20AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:31
    ??: 'I took an arrow to the knee…' (riffing on the famous Skyrim meme line)
    22AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:32
    If he keeps playing like this with no extra-base hits, he's basically guaranteed to get scapegoated for the loss anyway, so slipping away quietly now might actually be the smart move.
    30AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:34
    Even if he keeps slapping singles from here, he'll just get scapegoated for it — better to sit the rest of the season out and rest up.
    33AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:34
    It's not that his batted balls aren't carrying —
    he's not even making contact with the bat.
    35AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:36
    Can't help it if he can't hit, right? Just a slump, isn't it?
    36AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:36
    People who aren't actually watching the games probably think 'he's due for a homer any minute now' lol, but if you're actually watching, it's nothing but despair. Today he even flung his bat to cover up getting caught looking on a strike. He's been putting on that same sorry display every single game lately.
    48AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:39
    Let him contribute to the win by banging a drum on the bench. (a jab referencing Japanese cheer-squad drummers)
    53AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:40
    Re: #48
    He could do that from the stands just as well, honestly.
    58AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:41
    Benching Ohtani is fine by me, but then to be fair they'd also have to bench Smith, whose postseason stats are even worse than Ohtani's. Feduccia would upgrade the defense anyway.
    62AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:42
    Re: #58
    Huh? There's no way a guy grinding it out at catcher — the toughest position on the field — is contributing less than Over-tani. (a mocking nickname for Ohtani, punning on 'done/finished')
    63AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:42
    Why does he turn into Scrub-tani every postseason and World Series??? (another mocking pun on Ohtani's name meaning 'scrub/weakling')
    77AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:45
    Re: #63
    Last year in the NLCS he single-handedly racked up 10 strikeouts and 3 home runs, though.
    87AnonymousOct 13, 2026 15:46
    Re: #63
    Last year, fresh off rehab and still going two-way, he hit 8 home runs with 14 RBIs and went 2-0 as a pitcher with 28 strikeouts.

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    Ohtani has been under a long-term contract with the Dodgers since 2024, so the decision over whether to keep playing him or rest him carries weight beyond pure performance — it’s tangled up with his contractual standing too. The thread’s split largely came down to a clash between those speculating his slump stems from an injury and those invoking a tough-it-out mentality to demand he be benched; since the latter camp’s comments included body-shaming remarks and baseless speculation about his personal life, those were left out of this piece. Meanwhile, defenders pointed to his two-way production in last year’s postseason (his home run and strikeout totals) and argued it’s premature to judge him on one rough stretch. Neither Ohtani nor the team has issued any official statement on whether he’s actually injured or what the front office is thinking, so it’s worth noting that the thread’s speculation remains just that — speculation.

    *This article was compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisokuho+) thread “Two Hours After the Dodgers’ Loss… Breaking Ohtani News of a Possible Benching Next Game — U.S. Media Reports en Masse as Decision Time Looms.”

  • Yamamoto’s Shortest Outing of the Season Stuns Roberts: ‘Very Unusual’ — Dodgers Fall 0-2

    On October 12 local time (October 13 Japan time), the Dodgers fell 7-4 to the Brewers in Game 2 of the NL Championship Series, dropping to 0-2 in the series. Starter Yoshinobu Yamamoto was pulled after his shortest outing of the season, with manager Dave Roberts explaining it was “very unusual” and that “he wasn’t quite himself.” Yamamoto, who had gone 8-1 this postseason, took his second loss of the playoffs in this game. On 5ch, reactions split between criticism of the early pitching change and criticism of catcher Will Smith for not challenging close pitches.

    Manager Dave Roberts can’t hide his shock at Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s shortest outing of the season: “Very unusual,” “He wasn’t quite himself”… Dodgers suffer painful back-to-back losses to Brewers

    ◆MLB NL Championship Series Game 2: Brewers 7, Dodgers 4 (October 12, American Family Field, Milwaukee, Wisconsin)

    The NL West champion Dodgers dropped a seesaw battle on the road to the Brewers in Game 2 of the NL Championship Series on October 12 (October 13 Japan time), falling to 0-2 in the series. They now face a tough road toward becoming the first NL team in history to win three straight World Series titles.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here

    2AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:35
    You're the one who pulled him.
    5AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:37
    Re: #2
    LOL
    Anyone can see Roberts botched that pitching change
    3AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:36
    That so-called scapegoat they're calling 'Yamamoro' (a mocking riff on Yamamoto's name)
    7AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:38
    Re: #3
    The real culprits are Roberts, Smith, and that 'Boobicchi' guy
    4AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:36
    If they'd just let him keep pitching, he wouldn't have given up another run after that.
    9AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:38
    He just ran out of gas.
    Every single Japanese player on this team flamed out.
    12AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:41
    Whenever Roberts gets criticized, people jump in with 'the Dodgers don't actually give Roberts real authority' to defend him — but no, this one's squarely on Roberts.
    13AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:43
    What's even more baffling is pulling Roki — that was a long-relief situation if anything.
    15AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:48
    Ohtani was never someone you could count on in the clutch to begin with, but losing Yamamoto like that really hurts.
    16AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:48
    They had no tomorrow left, and they still kept Sasaki in reserve.
    17AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:48
    You're not exactly innocent either, letting that automatic-out machine rot on the bench.
    18AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:51
    Don't bring in the pitcher who was a complete mess with that wild pitch the other day!!—
    23AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:54
    Exactly the result you guys all called.

    The Dodgers are finished.
    24AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:54
    They say the 'Yamamoro' meltdown lost it, but up to that point they were leading 4-3 —
    meaning it was really just the usual bullpen regulars getting hit afterward.
    25AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:54
    Isn't it simply that they gave up on him way too soon?
    26AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:55
    Has everyone already forgotten Sasaki's perfect 3 innings from last year's postseason?
    27AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:55
    You didn't even have to pull him, but you did anyway.
    29AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:56
    A reliever comes in and plunks the leadoff batter — that's deflating.
    And sure enough, they give up the run.
    30AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:56
    He threw a clean strike and they wouldn't even let him challenge it — of course that's what happens.
    31AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:56
    Did foul-ball grinding tactics get the better of him?
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:57
    Yamamoto isn't a velocity guy, he lives on the edges of the zone —
    so the moment you have a catcher who won't use ABS challenges, you should've benched Smith on the spot.
    He's batting .000 without a single hit — why is he even still playing?
    33AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:57
    The biggest reason for today's loss is you, Roberts.
    35AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:57
    Yamamoto was already getting hit hard in that game, and then got hit with a refusal to challenge on top of it, which finished him off.
    36AnonymousOct 13, 2026 11:58
    Everyone got pessimistic on their own,
    declared it a lost game on their own,
    brought in some mystery pitcher they're calling 'Boobicchi,'
    and he just got hit like normal.
    41AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:01
    Pitch was in the zone but called a ball → Yamamoto wants an ABS challenge → Smith refuses → run scores.
    That happened twice in a row.
    Smith was never great defensively, but his bat was good enough to make him the starting catcher.
    But at .000 right now, he's at a level where he shouldn't even be in the lineup.
    47AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:07
    If the catcher's going to ignore ABS challenges, when else are you supposed to use them if not right there?
    48AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:09
    Re: #47
    And didn't they end up leaving 2 ABS challenges unused today anyway?
    Makes zero sense.

    This isn't Formula 1 where a team sabotages its own Japanese driver — cut that stuff out.
    49AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:12
    Misiorowski was clearly nowhere near his usual form either — regular-season aces and key bats slumping is just a common thing in the postseason.
    53AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:15
    Re: #49
    Yamamoto was 8-1 this postseason.
    Today makes it loss number two.
    51AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:13
    Everyone keeps piling on Smith, but
    why didn't Yamamoto use the ABS challenge himself?
    Is that some uniquely Japanese timidness —
    deferring to the catcher's judgment?
    60AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:19
    Re: #51
    Because on the Dodgers, the catcher — Smith — has final say on that.
    62AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:27
    This slump of Ohtani's is reminding me of Tatsunori Hara in the 1989 Japan Series.
    If they drop Game 3 too, that sets up the flag for an Ohtani grand slam sparking four straight Dodgers wins.
    65AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:32
    Re: #62
    That time it was thanks to Kintetsu's Kato running his mouth.
    I'd love for someone on the Brewers to go say the Dodgers are even worse than the Pirates or the Rockies.
    67AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:34
    I think it would've gone completely differently if they'd challenged.
    In the end, both the questionable call in the 1st and the one in the 3rd would've been strikes on review (both came on 2-strike counts, so both would've been strikeouts).
    Facing a team that patiently worked pitches and ground it out trying to drag Yamamoto out early, with an umpire who kept making tight calls against him on borderline pitches — and then even Will Smith, who's supposed to be on his side, skipped every single challenge. You've got to feel for Yamamoto.
    68AnonymousOct 13, 2026 12:36
    Re: #67
    Couldn't agree more.

    Background and Key Points of This Topic

    The backdrop to this story is that the Dodgers are fighting through the playoffs chasing a third straight World Series title. The weight of what would be an unprecedented three-peat for an NL team makes the 0-2 hole they’re now in sting even more. Where opinion split on the thread was over where to pin the blame for the loss: criticism of manager Dave Roberts for the early pitching change, criticism of catcher Will Smith for not challenging close calls, and comments pointing to fatigue or an off night for Yamamoto himself all existed side by side. The “ABS” mentioned in the article is the challenge system that lets teams request an automated review of close ball-strike calls, introduced this postseason, and differing views on how that system should have been used are what split opinion between blaming the manager and blaming the catcher. The posts alone don’t capture the full picture — things like individual players’ fatigue levels over the course of the whole game — so it’s worth keeping in mind that this is just a slice of the reaction on 5ch.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “[MLB] Manager Roberts can’t hide his shock at Yoshinobu Yamamoto’s shortest outing of the season: “Very unusual,” “He wasn’t quite himself”.”

  • Dodgers’ Agonizing Back-to-Back Losses: Yamamoto KO’d in the 3rd, Ohtani Goes Hitless

    The Dodgers blew a late lead and fell 7-4 to the Brewers in Game 2 of the NL Championship Series, dropping to 0-2 in the series. Starter Yoshinobu Yamamoto was pulled early after just 3 innings (75 pitches), allowing 4 hits and 3 runs — his shortest outing of the season. Shohei Ohtani, batting cleanup as DH, went 0-for-4, while Roki Sasaki threw a scoreless, hitless inning in relief and hit a season-best 101 mph. On the forum, discussion centered on manager Dave Roberts’ bullpen management for not getting Sasaki in earlier for a longer outing, the team’s struggles against a Brewers roster with a payroll less than a third of the Dodgers’, and speculation that Ohtani might heat up again from Game 4 onward just like he did last year.

    ◆MLB NL Championship Series Game 2: Brewers 7, Dodgers 4 (Oct. 12, American Family Field, Milwaukee, Wisconsin)

    On October 12 (October 13 in Japan), the NL West champion Dodgers dropped a back-and-forth road battle against the Brewers in Game 2 of the NLCS, falling to 0-2 in the series.

    Starter Yoshinobu Yamamoto (28) was pulled partway through the 3rd inning after throwing 75 pitches, allowing 4 hits and 3 runs — his shortest outing this season. He had won five straight postseason starts dating back to last year, but the streak came to an end here. Shohei Ohtani (32), starting at cleanup as DH, couldn’t produce a solid hit, going 0-for-4. Roki Sasaki (24) came on as the third pitcher in the 4th inning with the team down by one run, threw a scoreless, hitless inning, and hit a season-best 101.0 mph.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    13AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:09
    They gotta bench Ohtani, right?
    This is a short series, man.
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:11
    Re: #13
    They don't actually want to win.
    Ohtani's basically a handicap at this point.
    29AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:10
    I only caught glimpses, but were all the borderline pitches getting called balls?
    Feels like the usual pattern when Yamamoto falls apart.
    71AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:13
    Re: #29
    Sharp read — the home plate ump was squeezing him, and Smith never called for an ABS challenge.
    43AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    Re: #1
    Why do soccer reporters never start threads about soccer matches,
    but always start baseball ones?
    100AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:16
    Re: #43
    Yeah, and they never start threads bashing soccer either.
    45AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    Glad the 'Ohtani overload' coverage has died down a bit.
    70AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:13
    Re: #45
    Nah, even today, every time 'Ohtani-san' made an out,
    the daytime TV shows kept cutting in with breaking news alerts.
    106AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:16
    Re: #45
    I feel like coverage dropped even during the first half when he was playing great this year.
    The talk shows were covering Rikuryu instead of Ohtani.
    47AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    They scored 4 runs off like 3 hits or something?
    104AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:16
    Re: #47
    The Brewers' young pitchers looked rattled too, throwing wild pitches all over the place.
    That's how the runs leaked out — runners advancing and scoring on sac flies to add up to those 4 runs.
    49AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    This is just how it goes when Ohtani doesn't hit.
    Yeah, back-to-back titles really were thanks to Ohtani.
    160AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:21
    Re: #49
    Ohtani barely hit in Games 1-3 of the NLCS last year either.
    Then he exploded in Game 4 and hit 3 home runs in the World Series, so he'll probably wake up starting Game 4 again this year.
    50AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    Well, that's it.
    After Murakami, now Ohtani and Yamamoto have fallen too.
    It's over.
    143AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:19
    Re: #50
    I wonder if NHK will even broadcast the World Series if there's no Japanese player in it.
    53AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:12
    What happened to Ohtani-san?
    86AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:14
    Re: #53
    It's his knee.
    Today he was walking slowly, favoring his leg.
    55AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:13
    The team was honestly doing better when Ohtani wasn't in the lineup — he comes back and this is what happens.
    73AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:14
    Re: #55
    The Dodgers are just weak against strong teams.
    72AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:14
    [MLB] 2026 Opening Day Team Payroll Rankings
    #2 Dodgers — $316,596,048
    #19 Brewers — $124,145,696
    144AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:19
    Re: #72
    LUXURY TAX PAYROLL
    #1 Dodgers — $433M
    #19 Brewers — $154M

    Almost 3x the difference. Actually, the Dodgers' luxury tax bill alone this year is $183M — that's enough to cover the Brewers' entire payroll and still have change left over.
    94AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:15
    Yamamoto getting ignored by his catcher on ABS challenges — is that a bench order? (ABS = the Automated Ball-Strike challenge system)
    136AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:19
    Re: #94
    Pitchers can call for ABS too, but the rule requires it to be done immediately (probably to prevent sign-stealing).

    A lot of the time, by the point the pitcher confirms the catcher isn't going to challenge and taps his own head, it's already too late.
    130AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:18
    The turning point was Smith not calling for an ABS challenge.
    163AnonymousOct 13, 2026 10:21
    Re: #130
    Even after Yamamoto left, the Dodgers only had the lead thanks to the other team's mistakes.

    Either way, there's no winning with the Dodgers' lineup managing just 3 hits.

    Background and Key Talking Points

    The NLCS is a best-of-seven series, and with the Dodgers chasing back-to-back titles, dropping two straight to a Brewers team with a far smaller payroll has put them in a must-win situation. Thread opinion was split over the bullpen management: some argued Sasaki should have been brought in earlier for a longer outing, while others felt the manager still doesn’t fully trust him yet. There was also technical discussion of the ABS (Automated Ball-Strike challenge system) — since a pitcher needs the catcher to immediately tap his helmet to challenge a call, delays in confirming whether the catcher will challenge often mean it’s already too late, which came up as context for the string of close calls. As for Ohtani, while many voiced frustration over his slump this season, there’s also strong hope he’ll repeat last year’s pattern of struggling early in the series before homering heavily from Game 4 onward. Sasaki’s season-best 101 mph fastball was seen as one bright spot.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5channel (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] Dodgers suffer painful back-to-back comeback losses, Yamamoto Yoshinobu KO’d after shortest outing of the season in the 3rd, Ohtani Shohei hitless… 110 plate appearances without a homer.”

  • Shohei Ohtani strikes out on 3 pitches in first at-bat — 5ch: ‘His eyesight must be going’

    In Game 2 of the NL Championship Series between the Dodgers and Brewers (October 12, 2026, Milwaukee), Shohei Ohtani struck out swinging after being thrown three straight fastballs in his first at-bat. Despite being held hitless early, the Dodgers took the lead behind strong pitching from Yoshinobu Yamamoto and others, putting them in control of the game. On 5ch, Ohtani’s slump drew a wave of reactions, split between those pointing to declining bat speed and failing dynamic vision, and those calling it just a temporary rough patch. His recent batting line — “106 plate appearances without a home run, a .188 average, a .504 OPS” — was also cited, fueling concern that the slump was dragging on.

    Sponichi

    [ October 13, 2026, 06:15 ]

    NL Championship Series Game 2, Dodgers vs. Brewers (October 12, 2026, Milwaukee)

    Source: sponichi.co.jp / Original article here

    5AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:31
    Embarrassing, Mr. Swing-and-Miss (a nickname for his whiffs). Hit a homer once in a while, would you?
    6AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:31
    Strikeout on three pitches
    Can't even get the bat on the ball
    He's a total sitting duck ("kamo" — slang for an easy mark)
    14AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:35
    Re: #6
    It's not that his form broke down from injury or that he hasn't healed up — it's "his eyesight failing."
    He's done.
    8AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:32
    So it's a must-win today, and in the end it all comes down to relying on Yamamoto again, huh?
    15AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:35
    Re: #8
    The other team's pitcher is just better, honestly.
    9AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:32
    Still, NHK's broadcast money keeps him in the lineup (Japanese TV rights depend on his star power).
    17AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:36
    "If it doesn't connect, it's nothing" (the famous Gundam line) — except it's actually happening for real now.
    18AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:36
    Turns out without AI analysis to help him, this is all he's got.
    For a DH, this performance would get you cut in any normal case.
    19AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:37
    Here's his stat line through yesterday, just leaving this here

    798 Anonymous ("much obliged") 2026/10/12 (Mon) 13:52:26.12 ID:jQPvH8sQ0
    Ohtani
    106 PA, no home runs
    103 PA, 1 RBI

    Batting average .188 (16-3), 0 HR, 0 RBI, OPS .504
    21AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:38
    That legendary power everyone talked about—
    what happened to it?

    Sure, it's huge when it connects,
    but the bat just cuts through air.
    28AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:41
    He never hits when Yamamoto's the starter, that's for sure.
    29AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:42
    Ohtani's bad, but Smith's even worse.
    He's the catcher so they have no choice but to start him,
    but things look pretty rough all around.
    30AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:42
    If he's hitting homers in batting practice, the injury must be fine by now.
    So this is a genuine slump.
    32AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:42
    Not even grazing a fastball in the low 150s km/h (93-94 mph) suggests the problem is something other than a physical injury.
    35AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:43
    Can't even rely on AI anymore, can't manage his own conditioning either —
    is there really no upside left for him?

    And the Dodgers are stuck paying a guy like this a fortune going forward.
    The local fans are bound to turn on him.
    37AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:44
    What's actually causing him to not hit at all?
    Struggling this badly seems like it has to be more than one thing.
    60AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:49
    Re: #37
    His dynamic vision has declined, so he's started being late on four-seamers.
    And when he speeds up his timing to compensate, he gets fooled and lunges at off-speed pitches instead.
    41AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:45
    Ohtani's the only one who can't even get the bat on the ball like this.
    43AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:45
    Why's a guy who can't hit this badly still in the starting lineup?
    45AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:46
    Next season, just focus on pitching.
    46AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:46
    He's starting to feel like just an average guy now.
    The brilliance he had through last year has completely vanished.
    Once someone who used to shine loses that shine, they rarely start shining again.
    Things had just been going too well for him until now.
    47AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:46
    Looking at the pitch sequencing,
    they clearly see him as a safe bet now (like a harmless tile in mahjong),
    he's being completely looked down on.
    48AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:47
    If it comes down to Ohtani with a chance to deliver, pinch-hitting is the only option. If they can't do that, it's elimination.
    49AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:47
    That first at-bat was brutal to watch.
    Are they really going to let him bat every time?
    51AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:47
    @
    Didn't even offer at it — that used to be a home run pitch too. Has Ohtani really declined?

    @
    Guess Ohtani's eyesight really has started going out of nowhere, huh.

    @
    Ohtani might genuinely be declining. I'd even say he can't see the ball properly. It's crazy that he's still batting cleanup, but given how much he's getting paid, the team's probably just going down with their star.

    @
    Ohtani's decline is definitely his eyes. He's not seeing the ball at all.

    [Game 2] Shohei Ohtani strikes out on 3 pitches in first at-bat, swings through fastballs — Dodgers take the lead after being held hitless, backed by Yamamoto [Seii Taishogun★ (poster handle)]
    https://hayabusa9.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/mnewsplus/1791840477/
    52AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:47
    Everyone else is battling at the plate, and he can't even manage to foul one off?
    81AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:54
    Ohtani being out of form can't be helped, so they should just rest him.
    122AnonymousOct 13, 2026 07:00
    Re: #81
    If it's declining dynamic vision, no amount of rest will fix it.
    Who'd have thought his eyes would give out at 32.

    Ichiro took insanely good care of his eyes, which is how he lasted until 40, but I figured Ohtani's would at least hold up until around 35.
    100AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:58
    So his actual bat speed has dropped, huh.
    No wonder he can't make contact then.
    109AnonymousOct 13, 2026 06:59
    Re: #100
    He's whiffing on fastballs because his bat speed has dropped, probably.

    Background and key points of this discussion

    Shohei Ohtani has been stuck in a batting slump throughout this postseason, and the stat line cited in the thread — “106 plate appearances without a home run, a .188 average, a .504 OPS” — shows a situation well beyond a temporary rough patch. Opinions in the thread split over the cause, with some pointing to declining dynamic vision or age-related decline, and others attributing it to technical issues like reduced bat speed or mistimed timing on his load. It’s worth noting that none of this is a medical diagnosis — it’s all speculation by fans based on what they’re seeing at the plate. Some posts went as far as tying the slump to his motivation or his future contract situation, but that too is speculation drawn from the game results, not a fact about his actual intentions or the team’s plans.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Game 2] Shohei Ohtani strikes out on 3 pitches in first at-bat, swings through fastballs — Dodgers take the lead after being held hitless, backed by Yamamoto.”

  • Nippon-Ham Tops Seibu 4-1, Advances in Climax Series — 5ch Reacts: ‘Seibu Just Lost on Their Own’

    In Game 3 of the Pacific League Climax Series First Stage on October 12, Nippon-Ham defeated Seibu 4-1, clinching a Final Stage berth with a 2-1 series record. Seibu, who finished second in the regular season, were eliminated after dropping two straight games. On the thread, discussion centered on reactions to Nippon-Ham winning a game that anti-fans had written off as a “throwaway,” how the win-advantage system works in favor of SoftBank in the Final Stage, and Seibu’s long history of struggling in the Climax Series.

    Nippon-Ham  0 1 0  1 1 0  1 0 0|4

    Seibu.    0 0 0  0 1 0  0 0 0|1

    [Battery]

    Source: nikkansports.com / Original article here

    5AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:20
    Upsets brewing in both the Central and Pacific Leagues? (´・ω・`)
    196AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:42
    Re: #5
    Both the Giants and Seibu finished 2nd place and now this… (´・ω・`)
    7AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:20
    Is Shinjo secretly a brilliant manager or something?
    23AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:21
    Re: #7
    Seibu just lost on their own, that's all.
    139AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:35
    Re: #7
    Anti-fans nationwide must be grinding their teeth right now. There was even a hater today saying it was a "throwaway game" just because Yamagata was starting, lol
    19AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:21
    So a Japan Series between two third-place teams could actually happen?
    Is that really how this is supposed to work?
    30AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:22
    Re: #19
    Can't really blame a team for making the Japan Series even if they end up with 5 losses along the way.
    25AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:21
    If it's Seibu, SoftBank gets a 2-win advantage, right?
    In that case it's better for everyone if Nippon-Ham goes through instead.
    49AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:23
    Re: #25
    Even if Ham goes through, the advantage is still 2 wins.
    155AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:37
    Re: #25
    It's there because Ham lost to Bank so many times during the season.
    182AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:41
    Re: #25
    Seibu finished 2nd place, what are you even talking about.
    29AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:22
    Any real baseball fan knows the pennant race is the true standings, and the CS and Japan Series are just exhibitions.
    Go ahead and let two third-place teams fight over the "Japan Championship" (lol).
    45AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:23
    Re: #29
    You don't have to come in here making excuses just because your team lost, lol
    57AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:24
    The most hated team in Japan, SoftBank, against the second most hated, Nippon-Ham —
    sounds like it's going to be a hype-filled grudge match.
    65AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:25
    Re: #57
    I'm a Seibu fan, and honestly I don't even hate them.
    69AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:25
    SoftBank only needs 2 wins, while Nippon-Ham needs 4?
    There's no way SoftBank doesn't walk through this.
    75AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:26
    Re: #69
    Whoever hits 5 wins first takes it — looks like SoftBank starts with a 2-win advantage baked in.
    85AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:28
    Re: #69
    SoftBank needs 3 wins, Nippon-Ham needs 5.
    146AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:36
    Re: #69
    Probably for revenue reasons — they built this convoluted rule so the advantage doesn't cut down on the number of games played.
    76AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:26
    Seibu is unusually bad at the Climax Series.
    Has Seibu ever actually won a CS?
    98AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:29
    Re: #76
    Sounds like the last time they won a CS was 15 years ago.
    135AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:34
    Re: #76
    This was back in the old playoff era, but 2004 was incredible.
    The Hawks ran away with the regular season, but Seibu, who finished 2nd, pulled off a stunning Japan Series berth in the decisive final playoff game by starting Ishii Taka — a guy who'd won only 1 game all year.
    Then in the Japan Series they started Ishii Taka again, and he went 2-0 with no runs allowed over two starts to win MVP.
    Imagine taking a guy who was basically useless all season and turning him into the short-series MVP.
    2008 was strong too — there was that legendary play where Kataoka scored a run on pure baserunning speed even though the team got no-hit.
    They started falling off after barely losing the pennant race to SoftBank in 2010.
    Since then, under manager Tsuji, they've managed to win the pennant two years running and then get eliminated two years running, and there's zero sign of any upset magic left in this team.
    79AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:27
    Well, at least they got three home games at the end and pulled in a few hundred million yen — that's something.
    But watching from the outside, this roster really doesn't look like championship material.
    86AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:28
    Re: #79
    Third place gets nothing, after all — they even have to cover their own travel and hotel costs.
    80AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:27
    Still, it'd be rough if Nippon-Ham turned around and lost to DeNA too.
    95AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:29
    Re: #80
    Though to be fair, SoftBank's only really popular in Fukuoka anyway. Nippon-Ham has more nationally recognized star players.
    83AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:27
    Since there's an advantage, does that mean if SoftBank wins twice in a row, the Final Stage is already over in just 2 games?
    152AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:37
    Re: #83
    No, it doesn't work that way. The advantage is 2, so they still need 3 wins.
    90AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:28
    Ham held ace Ito back for Game 3, while Seibu threw Takeuchi out there for it.
    Feels like the edge goes to Ham for knowing how to manage a short series.
    109AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:30
    Re: #90
    Yesterday was do-or-die for Ham — lose and they're out — so starting ace Ito in Game 2 was absolutely the right call.
    107AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:30
    Seibu ("Cat") Home First Stage record:
    2004 vs 公 W-L-W → Won
    2006 vs Hawks(鷹) W-L-L → Eliminated
    2010 vs Marines(鴎) L-L → Eliminated
    2012 vs Hawks(鷹) L-W-L → Eliminated
    2013 vs Marines(鴎) L-W-L → Eliminated
    2017 vs Eagles(鷲) W-L-L → Eliminated
    2026 vs 公 W-L-L → Eliminated
    113AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:31
    Re: #107
    Whoa, data like this actually exists. That's pretty interesting.
    180AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:41
    Re: #107
    Wasn't 2004 the year a typhoon forced a Japan Series game to be canceled at Seibu Stadium even though it's a dome…?
    115AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:32
    You'd probably need to hand Nippon-Ham something like a 3-win advantage just to get this close to 50/50.
    When the outcome is this predictable under the rules, it doesn't really work as an exciting event.
    130AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:34
    Re: #115
    Giving out a win-advantage in a best-of series — NPB is the only league in the world doing something like that in the postseason.
    122AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:32
    Re: #109
    Nah, forget about Ham for a second — Seibu needed to manage their rotation so Sumida could start one of those three games.
    170AnonymousOct 12, 2026 17:39
    Re: #122
    When there's a title on the line, they pitch him all the way to the final game. Kitayama wasn't being saved for the CS so much as thrown out there to lock up the wins title.

    Background and Key Points of the Discussion

    NPB’s Climax Series uses a distinctive system that grants the first-place regular-season team a built-in 2-win advantage in the series standings. Handicapping the win count in a best-of series like this is rare even among postseason formats in professional sports worldwide, and posters on the thread pointed out that “NPB is the only one doing this.” Seibu’s performance has been in decline ever since they narrowly lost the pennant race to SoftBank in 2010, and commenters cited old data showing the team’s last CS win dates back to the playoff era in 2004. Opinions split between fans who treat the regular-season standings as the “true” rankings and those who weight the results of the short postseason series more heavily — a divide that fueled much of the back-and-forth on the thread.

    *This article is compiled by excerpting and summarizing the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “[Baseball] Pacific League CS Game 3: L 1-4 F [10/12] — Nippon-Ham advances to CS Final Stage with 2-1 record, 2nd-place Seibu eliminated after back-to-back losses“.

  • Giants’ Sakamoto and Tanaka to Keep Playing Into Their 21st Pro Seasons — 5ch: ‘All the Big Names Are Gone Now’

    Yomiuri Giants infielder Hayato Sakamoto and pitcher Masahiro Tanaka (both 37) will continue their playing careers into their 21st professional season next year, team sources confirmed on October 11. Sakamoto struggled to a .175 average as a starter this season but showed clutch instincts as a pinch hitter, batting .333 with 9 RBIs, while Tanaka went 4-4 with a 3.42 ERA and turned in a strong outing on September 19 against the Chunichi Dragons, allowing just one run over seven innings. The announcement sparked debate on the 5ch sports-news board Geisoku Sokuho+, with some users arguing the pair “can still contribute” and others saying they “should make way for younger players.” The thread also touched on the Giants’ thin bench of marquee names and Sakamoto’s standing at No. 9 on the all-time NPB hits list.

    Yomiuri Giants infielder Hayato Sakamoto (37) and pitcher Masahiro Tanaka (37) will continue their playing careers into their 21st professional season next year, team sources confirmed on the 11th.

    Sakamoto finished the season with a .175 average, 5 home runs, and 19 RBIs, but his clutch hitting held up as a pinch hitter, where he batted .333 with 1 home run and 9 RBIs. The team also praised his strong work ethic, calling him a role model for the rest of the roster. In that day’s game against DeNA, trailing 1-4 in the eighth, he came in to pinch-hit and flied out to left. “I just couldn’t come through for the team in the end,” he said. “I was disappointing, so I’m going to think things over carefully and go from there.” After wrestling with the decision for much of the season, he ultimately chose to aim for a comeback next year.

    Tanaka, who reached 200 combined wins between Japan and the majors last season, went 4-4 with a 3.42 ERA this year. He flashed his old form on September 19 against Chunichi at Tokyo Dome, picking up the win with seven innings of one-run ball in the thick of the pennant race. The duo — teammates since elementary school and now the oldest players on the roster — will keep anchoring the Giants next season.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    4AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:38
    Enough already. That's an ugly way to hang on.
    5AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:39
    (∪^ω^)Woof woof!
    ( * )
    6AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:39
    These two are about the only pro baseball players I can even name anymore
    20AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:44
    Re: #6
    Seriously, this.
    The famous names are completely gone now.
    81AnonymousOct 12, 2026 16:00
    Re: #6
    The only Giants I even know are Sakamoto, Tanaka, and Togo.
    For the Tigers it's just manager Fujikawa.
    12AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:40
    I've been working since before you kids were even playing Koshien.
    Keep grinding, don't get soft on me.
    13AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:41
    Bet they won't even take a pay cut like players on other teams would.
    17AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:43
    Huh? I thought Tanaka-ma was going to retire.
    18AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:43
    Guess the Giants are locked in for another losing season next year too lol
    21AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:44
    They can't really draw a crowd anymore, can they (´・ω・`)
    23AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:44
    Still, with these two on it, merch will probably sell just fine.
    30AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:45
    As long as they don't start Sakamoto on opening day and just keep him around as a morale booster and pinch-hit ace, I'm fine with this.
    41AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:48
    The 'Handkerchief Prince' generation (Yuki Saito's old nickname)


    How many years has it been since Handkerchief disappeared?
    43AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:48
    Maybe they should just start a separate league for the 35-to-50 crowd.
    Then they could be the "up-and-coming young players" there.
    44AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:49
    Both of them are a huge bad investment at this point.
    Dark ages, man lol
    46AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:49
    NPB All-Time Career Hits Ranking, Top 10
    #1 Isao Harimoto — 3,085
    #2 Katsuya Nomura — 2,901
    #3 Sadaharu Oh — 2,786
    #4 Hiromitsu Kadota — 2,566
    #5 Sachio Kinugasa — 2,543
    #5 Yutaka Fukumoto — 2,543
    #7 Tomoaki Kanemoto — 2,539
    #8 Kazuyoshi Tatsunami — 2,480
    #9 Hayato Sakamoto — 2,474 ★
    #10 Shigeo Nagashima — 2,471
    ★ = active player
    49AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:50
    Re: #46
    These days, anyone good enough to crack this list just heads to MLB instead.
    The top of the chart might never get updated again.
    57AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:52
    Re: #46
    People were hoping he might even pass Harimoto.
    Guess catching Kanemoto is looking tough now too.
    47AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:49
    Sakamoto's done plenty for the Giants, so I'm fine with it,
    but Tanaka's done a lot for Japanese baseball as a whole — holding onto him like this really shows the Giants acting like they own the league.
    52AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:51
    Wait, Tanaka-ma switched to the Giants at some point?
    Had no idea.
    53AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:51
    Sakamoto, seriously, just get married already.
    Get Tanaka to hook you up with an idol or something.
    55AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:52
    Combined NPB + MLB Wins — Japanese Players with MLB Experience
    #1 Yu Darvish ★ 208 (NPB 93 + MLB 115)
    #2 Masahiro Tanaka ★ 204 (NPB 126 + MLB 78)
    #3 Hiroki Kuroda 203 (NPB 124 + MLB 79)
    #4 Hideo Nomo 201 (NPB 78 + MLB 123)
    #5 Kazuhisa Ishii 182 (NPB 143 + MLB 39)
    #6 Masumi Kuwata 173 (NPB 173 + MLB 0)
    #7 Daisuke Matsuzaka 170 (NPB 114 + MLB 56)
    #7 Hisashi Iwakuma 170 (NPB 107 + MLB 63)
    #9 Kenta Maeda ★ 169 (NPB 101 + MLB 68)
    #10 Tsuyoshi Wada 165 (NPB 160 + MLB 5)
    ★ = still active in Japan or MLB
    59AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:53
    Re: #55
    Guess 'Daimajin' (the 'Great Demon God,' closer Kazuhiro Sasaki's old nickname) wasn't such a big deal after all
    87AnonymousOct 12, 2026 16:01
    Re: #59
    Racking up wins is kind of a badge of shame for a closer, you know (it usually means he blew the lead first).
    63AnonymousOct 12, 2026 15:54
    Tanaka was genuinely valuable since the rotation kept collapsing around him.
    Sakamoto, if it's around 50 million yen, I guess that's fine.
    85AnonymousOct 12, 2026 16:01
    Who'd have thought Kenta Maeda would be the last one standing from this generation.
    90AnonymousOct 12, 2026 16:02
    Re: #85
    Did it take Maeda a while to adjust to the NPB ball?
    He really turned it on down the stretch.

    Background and Key Points of the Debate

    Sakamoto and Tanaka are the same age and, as the article notes, have been teammates since elementary school. Sakamoto struggled to a .175 average as a starter this season but kept his clutch reputation intact with a .333 mark as a pinch hitter, while Tanaka went 4-4 but showed he still has something left, including a complete-game win over Chunichi in September — these are the main grounds cited for their continuing to play. The thread split between posters who felt the pair are “still needed as contributors” and those who argued they “can’t hold up anymore and are blocking chances for younger players,” with the latter camp also grumbling about their high salaries and the fact that, unlike players on other teams, they aren’t taking pay cuts. The thread also contained a fair amount of crude personal insults, which have been excluded from this writeup. Two points worth clarifying for context, since the original article doesn’t spell them out: Tanaka isn’t a Giants lifer — he came over from the Rakuten Eagles (as comment 52 shows, some posters weren’t even aware of the move) — and Sakamoto’s career hit total already ranks 9th all-time in NPB history at 2,474 hits.

    *This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Baseball] Giants’ Sakamoto and Tanaka to Continue Playing Into Their 21st Pro Season.”