Was the Mongol Invasion of Japan Actually ‘Unemployment Relief’? 5ch: ‘Guess They Just Dumped the Troops in the Ocean’

From our other sites

The story

Haruaki Deguchi, professor emeritus at Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University, has introduced a theory — excerpted from his book “Kubilai, My Constant Companion” — that Kublai Khan’s invasions of Japan (the Mongol invasions, or Genko) were partly driven by “unemployment relief.” The idea: keeping a massive army idle risked sparking rebellion, so troops from conquered territories had to be sent off on foreign campaigns. On 5ch, skeptical voices pushed back with “isn’t this projecting modern values onto the past?”, while the discussion spiraled outward into comparisons with Hideyoshi’s invasions of Korea, Kamakura-era samurai turning into wokou pirates, sarcastic jabs tying it to Japan’s “lost generation,” and even the actual course of the Mongol invasions and the real role played by Goryeo troops.

Haruaki Deguchi (Professor Emeritus, Ritsumeikan Asia Pacific University (APU))

The vast Mongol Empire army that struck Japan during the Kamakura period — why would it go to the trouble of crossing the sea to attack Japan in the first place? As it turns out, hidden behind that decision was a surprising issue involving “unemployment” and “employment.” This article is excerpted and adapted from “Kubilai, My Constant Companion: Embodiment of 13th-Century Globalization.”

■ “Preventing unemployment” was the ultimate anti-rebellion measure

Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

What people said

3AnonymousNov 21, 2026 23:40
Guess it was unemployment relief — they just tossed the troops into the sea
205AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:46
Re: #3
Japan's headed down the same road — go to war with China to legally thin out the 'lost generation' that's draining pensions and welfare (namapo, slang for welfare benefits)
17AnonymousNov 21, 2026 23:50
Meanwhile, the vassals who'd pushed into Central Asia ended up breaking away from the Mongols and founding their own states
38AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:08
Re: #17
Calling them 'vassals' is a stretch — they were family members
18AnonymousNov 21, 2026 23:50
Every time I see one of these 'the pyramids were unemployment relief' theories I get exhausted. There's no way the Mongols or ancient Egyptians had a concept of 'unemployment.' Stop projecting the mindset of modern Japanese people who can't feel okay unless they're working year-round. What historians need is basic common sense.
24AnonymousNov 21, 2026 23:55
Re: #18
They did have the concept of famine, though
90AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:04
Re: #18
When commoners have too much idle time, it threatens the regime.

Japan did this too — confiscating iron and such under the pretext of building the Great Buddha
22AnonymousNov 21, 2026 23:54
Modern Japanese actually work less than most of the G7. Compare daily working hours with Italy and it's no contest. Though in Japan's case, hours have been deliberately cut to justify bringing in immigrants — that's why per-capita GDP looks low. Per-hour productivity is actually 3rd from the top. It's a rigged narrative pushing the 'low productivity' line.
27AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:00
Re: #1
Hideyoshi's invasion of Korea was probably something similar
91AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:05
Re: #27
There's a theory it was actually his lord Nobunaga's idea originally.

Though if Nobu had still been alive, he probably wouldn't have gone through with invading Korea anyway
28AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:00
The Kamakura shogunate ended up flooded with unemployed people because of the Mongol invasions too
106AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:25
Re: #28
Kamakura samurai who got no reward and couldn't make a living turned into wokou pirates
109AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:29
Re: #106
The wokou pirates actually started out trying to rescue family members who'd been abducted during the Mongol invasions
112AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:32
Re: #106
First I've heard of that — give me details
39AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:08
Re: #1
Chinese people probably don't want to recognize dynasties that weren't ethnically Han
43AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:10
Re: #39
By that logic, there were barely any purely Han dynasties to begin with
44AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:11
Japanese did the same thing too — sending samurai off to the Korean peninsula to be wiped out after civil wars ended: the Bunroku-Keicho campaigns around 1600, and after the Boshin War in 1850.
After that, they switched to civil rule
53AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:17
Re: #44
Funny how they never managed to wear down the most dangerous ones — the Tokugawa
54AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:18
Re: #43
No point explaining something that complicated to him — at his level, if they used kanji, they're Han Chinese
56AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:19
Re: #54
Well, 'Sinicization' is something that repeats throughout Chinese history — foreign peoples somehow always end up turning into Chinese-style empires before they know it
65AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:25
So if you want a job, hunting Japanese people is the way to go.
Stress relief, money, and international contribution all in one!
Come to Japan! Rally, heroes!
70AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:28
Well, of course — the Mongols, who'd never even seen a ship let alone ridden one, had no way of coming up with the idea of attacking across the sea on their own.

It started when the conquered Goryeo kingdom, trying to blunt Mongol momentum, suggested invading Japan — and the Mongols basically said 'okay, you do it then.'

The first Mongol invasion force was mostly Goryeo troops with zero motivation. They withdrew citing a storm, and that's the origin of the 'kamikaze' (divine wind) legend
92AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:07
Re: #70
No, the Goryeo troops were brutal — plenty motivated.
In the first invasion, Mongols were only at the commander level; it was effectively a Goryeo army.
Though there was resistance to the Mongols within the Korean peninsula too
78AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:49
When you think about it that way, Vietnam — connected by land [to the Mongol empire] — was seriously tough
80AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:50
Re: #78
Jungle is an even better wall than the ocean
81AnonymousNov 22, 2026 00:54
Re: #78
They probably understood the terrain advantage well. Kind of gives me a Shimazu clan vibe
93AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:08
When I went to Korea, a pamphlet there claimed that during the Mongol invasions, they deliberately built ships that would sink easily in order to help Japan.
I was baffled — like, no, the ones who drowned were your own ancestors
119AnonymousNov 22, 2026 01:46
Apparently this wasn't so much Japan being strong — it's more that the Mongol side's ships rocked so badly that both men and horses got terribly seasick and couldn't fight properly.
I mean, logically, a country fighting for hegemony on a continent shouldn't be weaker than one having minor skirmishes on an island
125AnonymousNov 22, 2026 02:01
Re: #119
Then don't come in the first place…
131AnonymousNov 22, 2026 02:27
Re: #119
They got picked apart by Japanese longbows outranging them, couldn't hold their beachhead, had no choice but to retreat to the ships, and then got wiped out by the storm.
With sloppy strategic planning, no tactical advantage, and just assuming numbers alone would carry the day, losing was a given.

It's really just a scaled-up version of the Ōei Invasion (1419), Joseon Korea's assault on Tsushima
174AnonymousNov 22, 2026 06:24
Japan got off safe because the Southern Song and Goryeo put up a brutal fight resisting the Mongols.
Honestly, the West barely survived because of that too
198AnonymousNov 22, 2026 07:33
Re: #174
The Southern Song, sure — but while Goryeo did resist, it wasn't really to the extent that it saved Japan

Background and Key Points of This Discussion

The “unemployment relief” theory introduced by Haruaki Deguchi holds that, as the Mongol Empire’s army swelled through repeated conquests, it had to be kept from sitting idle and turning into a seed of rebellion — so it was funneled into foreign campaigns instead. The Mongol invasions of Japan came in two waves, the Battle of Bun’ei in 1274 and the Battle of Kōan in 1281; some point out that most of the troops actually sent were conscripts from conquered territories like Goryeo, with Mongol soldiers themselves largely limited to the commander ranks. On the thread, opinion split between skepticism — that applying the modern concept of “unemployment” to antiquity and the medieval period is premature — and acceptance via comparison with Hideyoshi’s invasion of Korea and Edo-period governance, framed as “rulers channeling excess military force outward is something that repeats throughout history.” On the kamikaze legend too, some emphasized low morale and the tactical disadvantage against Japanese longbows over the storm itself, sharing a view distinct from a simple “divine providence” reading of history.

※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (News速報+) thread “[History] The ‘Mongol Empire That Shook the World’ — Was Kublai Khan’s Invasion of Japan Actually Unemployment Relief? The Surprising Aim Hidden Behind the Mounted Emperor’s ‘Genko’.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *