From our other sites
The story
A CNN article from May 2026 covering the century-old mystery of why the carnivorous dinosaur Tyrannosaurus had such tiny forelimbs set off a lively discussion on 5ch’s Science News+ board. The article cites research suggesting that “the sturdier a dinosaur’s skull, the more its forelimbs tend to shrink” — the idea being that once an animal specialized in killing prey with its jaws and teeth, its arms simply became less important. In the thread, posters pointed out that the same article had already been posted six months earlier, raised objections about confusing correlation with causation, and floated alternative theories — such as the arms being needed to brace the body in an ambush stance — all mixed in with jokes, but touching on real scientific points along the way.
2026.11.13 Fri posted at 19:57 JST
(CNN) — Why are the arms of the carnivorous dinosaur Tyrannosaurus rex so small? A study published this past May may finally have solved that mystery.
This oddest of features on the mightiest of dinosaurs has long been fodder for jokes, and the reason behind it has been debated for over a century.
Source: cnn.co.jp / Read the original article here
What people said
Triceratops looks like it'd have a pretty thick skull too,
but it's got perfectly normal arms.
Well yeah, it's got four legs.
Even a total amateur could figure that out lol
If a dinosaur with that massive a skull also had sturdy, bulky forearms,
it couldn't walk on two legs.
And it'd run slower too.
If you've got huge jaws and sharp teeth, you don't really need front legs
to pin down prey. Even a grade-schooler could follow that logic.
Go look up Allosaurus.
Allosaurus: King of the Jurassic
Tyrannosaurus: King of the Cretaceous
and it's a bird in its next life, so that kind of tracks.
it uses its arms as a kid, but once it grows up its head gets too big and the arms become useless?
Emu: wings shrunk to practically nothing
If you can handle daily chores with just your mouth, having half-useless arms just gets you hurt in a fight.
Crocodiles don't seem to use their forelimbs for much besides moving around either (though females need them for digging nests)
2026/05/26 (Tue) 22:35:22.37 ID:xXUxS+On
Why are the arms of the carnivorous dinosaur Tyrannosaurus so tiny? Has the age-old mystery finally been solved?
(CNN) Why are the arms of the carnivorous dinosaur Tyrannosaurus rex (T-rex) so small?
https://egg.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/scienceplus/1779802522/-100
just like Bodhidharma (the legendary monk said to have lost the use of his limbs from years of meditation).
Weak people just don't get it, see!
Go get yourself mauled to death by a T-rex.
this little guy could totally turn into a Tyrannosaurus given the right conditions.
https://img06.shop-pro.jp/PA01137/526/product/181982556_o1.jpg
When prey got close, they'd crouch and wait like a sprinter in the blocks at the 100-meter dash —
kind of like the tachi-ai stance at the start of a sumo match.
During that waiting crouch, the arms were incredibly important —
those small arms were what barely held the body back from lunging forward too soon, and the moment the prey came close, it would let go and dash.
So then it doesn't need legs either,
and it doesn't need a big body either,
so… does it just turn into a snake?
Background and Key Points of This Discussion
The article behind this discussion was originally published by CNN in May 2026, and as post #19 pointed out, the very same thread had already run on 5ch once before, six months earlier — making this effectively a repost of old news. The explanation offered for the shrinking arms is a correlation — “theropods with sturdier skulls tend to have smaller forelimbs” — framed as a kind of biomechanical trade-off (once the jaws and teeth became the sole weapon, the arms had less work to do). But as post #24 notes, this is still just a statistical correlation; it doesn’t actually spell out the causal mechanism behind why the pattern holds. Elsewhere in the thread, post #31 raises a different functional theory not covered in the article — that the arms braced the body to keep it from lunging forward too early during an ambush. In reality, the role of T-rex’s forelimbs (whether as a hunting aid, for gripping during mating, or as support when getting up) remains a genuinely open question in paleontology. Plenty of folk theories drawing comparisons to living animals like birds and crocodiles circulate too, but none of them amount to an academically settled conclusion.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Science News+) thread “Why are the arms of the carnivorous dinosaur Tyrannosaurus so tiny? Has the age-old mystery finally been solved?“.
Leave a Reply