Toru Hotaru: ‘We Even Teased Tennen Shizai’ — On the Influence of Matsumoto Hitoshi’s 2-Million-Copy Bestseller ‘Testament’

From our other sites

The story

Toru Hotaru, former member of the comedy duo Amagari Kesshitai, appeared on TV Asahi’s “Mimi no Ana Kappojite Kike!” (“Open Your Ears and Listen!”) and spoke about the influence of Matsumoto Hitoshi’s book “Testament,” which became a bestseller with over 2 million copies sold. On the thread, users debated whether the “teasing” aimed at Tennen Shizai and Ninety-Nine back then was actually an attempt to crush them, along with the shifting relationship between Matsumoto, Hamada, and their junior comedians.

Matsumoto Hitoshi’s “Testament” Had Insane Influence… Toru Hotaru: “I Think They Even Teased Tennen Shizai for Dancing” — The Book Sold Over 2 Million Copies

TV Asahi’s “Mimi no Ana Kappojite Kike!” aired on the 24th, with Toro Salmon’s Kubota Kazunobu and Westland’s Iguchi Hiroyuki serving as MCs.

On this episode, Toru Hotaru of the former duo Amagari Kesshitai appeared as a guest.

Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here

What people said

2AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:53
The Yamanba skits on 'Hitori Gocchu' after that were unbelievably boring.
4AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:54
They made them dress in hip-hop-style outfits, right?
Hosshan too.
5AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:54
Isn't Mattsun (Matsumoto) retiring already?
37AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:16
Re: #5
That's not something you can easily say…
44AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:25
Re: #5
As for 'isn't he retiring' — these days he's turned into the terrifying Baumkuchen Man (a mocking nickname referencing the sexual-misconduct allegations against him)!

Any woman who eats it ends up getting hauled off in the location van!

Somebody, please stop this Baumkuchen Man terrorizing all of Japan!

The Ice Cream Man from that American movie has become real life!
6AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:55
These days, Matsumoto's probably had his income completely overtaken by the Tennen Shizai guys.
11AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:56
Re: #6
I bet streaming pays more these days than TV, where fees are shrinking.
25AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:04
Re: #6
Over a decade ago, Degawa said Ninety-Nine's annual income was 200 million yen.
26AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:05
Re: #6
I think Okamura's the top earner, but his only regular gigs are Gurunai, Chiko-chan, two Kansai local shows, and a radio slot,
so even at a high rate, it's probably not as much money as people assume.
7AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:55
People who quit smoking have weak willpower.
I'm never quitting, no matter what.
8AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:55
Re: #1
Teasing him about the Adidas tracksuit was no joke.
10AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:56
They didn't mention that afterward, Shinsuke went on to produce comedians in Kansai, right? Was that Westland?
12AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:56
The Japan Movie Specialty Channel was airing 'Osaka Story' with Ikewaki Chizuru, Sawada Kenji, and Tanaka Yuko,
and there's a scene with Miyagawa Daisuke in it — he's got long hair like Kimutaku (Kimura Takuya) had back then, and it looked so out of place.
14AnonymousAug 26, 2026 22:59
Even back then, Matsumoto's cocky swagger was cringeworthy.
76AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:52
Re: #14
And Junior, who was the poster child for being one of Matsumoto's yes-men,
also hated the Tennen Shizai crew, Ninety-Nine included — and later, after Miyasako left Yoshimoto, he was blatantly kicking a man while he was down.
18AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:01
Just shows how small-minded Matsumoto is.
67AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:33
Re: #18
It's less 'teasing' and more like he was actually trying to crush them.
21AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:02
On the behind-the-scenes footage that came as a separate video with the 'Kishiwada Shonen Gurentai' DVD,
there's a bit where Ninety-Nine chartered a helicopter just to get from Kishiwada to an event in Nara.
22AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:03
2 million copies, that's huge.
I did read it standing in the bookstore though.
23AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:03
Seeing the threads lined up like this hits different.
24AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:03
Hotaru: 'That guy's finished now.'
27AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:05
Underestimate [Beat] Takeshi and you'll never become him.
39AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:19
Re: #27
Takeshi's the one who got overtaken by Downtown and Tunnels in comedy long ago.
He hasn't produced anything in comedy since the Heisei era began.
I respect him as a film director, but as a comedian he's a thing of the past.
43AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:23
He'd already made it big with 'Gotcha,' and at 30, was dissing up-and-coming comedians eight years younger than him
— and not even playing it for laughs.
83AnonymousAug 27, 2026 01:19
Re: #43
What he was doing wasn't any different from Yasushi.
51AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:35
Apparently he called Ninety-Nine 'Downtown's goldfish poop,' but
the real goldfish poop is someone like Kimura Yuichi.
52AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:37
And yet he coldly cut Miyasako loose, despite Miyasako being the one who helped him reach where he is today.
55AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:43
Re: #52
Miyasako only got popular thanks to Yoshimoto in the first place, but he mistook it for his own doing,
went off the rails solo, and left Hotaru behind.
56AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:44
I wonder what he thought about Hamada singing songs, getting all the screaming fangirls, and starring in dramas.
58AnonymousAug 26, 2026 23:50
Re: #56
I think that was the era they got along worst.
74AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:49
Re: #56
Downtown themselves sang and had girls screaming over them back in their Osaka days,
even though they used to trash comedians who dyed their hair or bulked up…
62AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:04
All that karma came back around on him in his later years lol
68AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:35
Re: #62
'Old men are total perverts, y'know?!'
(Lizard Old Man, Episode 1 — a Matsumoto sketch character)
66AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:25
It's not just Ninety-Nine — I get the sense Moriwaki and Nakayama Hide got the same crushing treatment too.
Moriwaki's own personality probably played a part in his case,
but it's a wonder Nakayama Hide never got crushed.
82AnonymousAug 27, 2026 01:05
Re: #66
Hide-chan's talent agency has a lot of pull.
72AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:45
Matsumoto's a small man built on a pile of lies.
78AnonymousAug 27, 2026 00:55
Re: #72
Up until that whole Fuji TV incident, he was shielded by his partner Hamada and Chairman Osaki,
but once those two started keeping their distance, the gilding completely peeled off Matsumoto.

Background and Key Points

Matsumoto Hitoshi’s “Testament” (遺書) came out in 1994, when he and Hamada Masatoshi’s duo Downtown were consolidating their grip over Japanese TV comedy through Yoshimoto Kogyo, the Osaka-based agency that also produced Ninety-Nine (Okamura and Yabe) and the trio Tennen Shizai, both junior acts under the same “senpai-kohai” (senior-junior) hierarchy that structures Japanese comedy troupes. Selling over two million copies was extraordinary for a comedian’s essay collection, and it cemented Matsumoto as a cultural arbiter whose on-air “ijiri” — the teasing/needling routine central to Japanese variety comedy — could make or break a junior act’s image.

The thread doesn’t agree on how to read that teasing. Some posters treat it as ordinary senpai ribbing (the Adidas tracksuit jokes, the hip-hop styling), while others insist it was calculated to suppress rising kohai, especially once Ninety-Nine’s earnings reportedly began rivaling or exceeding Downtown’s own.

What’s missing for outside readers is the context behind the asides about Miyasako Hiroyuki and Matsumoto’s declining protection: Miyasako left Yoshimoto in 2019 amid the agency’s “yami eigyo” (underground/unlicensed event) scandal, and posters allude to Matsumoto cutting ties without explaining that background. Likewise, the “Fuji TV incident” references Matsumoto’s 2024 sexual-misconduct allegations, which triggered his indefinite hiatus and the erosion of the protection he’d enjoyed from Hamada and former Yoshimoto chairman Osaki — the unstated frame behind the thread’s schadenfreude.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Entertainment] Toru Hotaru: ‘I Think They Even Teased Tennen Shizai for Dancing’ — Matsumoto Hitoshi’s ‘Testament’ Had Insane Influence.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *