From our other sites
The story
A passenger who brought a folding chair into the standing-ticket area of the Shinkansen Hayabusa and proudly posted about how comfortable it was on social media has drawn a wave of criticism. JR East has stated that “it’s not a problem as long as it doesn’t get in the way of other passengers, such as blocking the aisle,” and discussion on 5ch has spread to whether standing tickets should even exist, and whether all seats should be made reservation-only.
8/22 (Sat) 9:30 JST
Weekly Josei PRIME
On August 17, a post on Threads about disruptive behavior on the Shinkansen caused a stir.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
Standing bar: "We've got seats available!" (a jab at tachinomiya, bars where everyone stands anyway)
Exactly. Non-reserved seats are the whole point of having a Shinkansen in the first place. But now even the Tokaido-Sanyo Shinkansen has started copying JR East's bad habit during peak season.
If you're coming from Morioka, take the Yamabiko instead. If that's too slow, just book a reserved seat.
All-reserved seating is better precisely because it keeps out the clueless idiots who never plan ahead.
Isn't demanding it be free just because you're standing on the Shinkansen the real penny-pinching move here?
Mine's a backpack you can sit on. Google "backpack chair," lol.
Hikari (means "light" — speed of light)
Nozomi (means "wish" — joke: speed of quantum entanglement)
Wait, isn't Hayabusa ("falcon") slower than the speed of sound?
Well, it does have a track record of going farther than sound waves ever could — all the way to the asteroid Itokawa (a nod to the Hayabusa space probe).
>A folding chair should be fine, no? Just fold it up once you reach the station. It's not like it's some plush recliner — no need to get so worked up about it.
If you actually look at the poster's photo, it's not one of those tiny old-school folding stools that just prop up your butt. It's a Coleman chair with a backrest, armrests, and a drink holder — looks genuinely comfortable. And it's huge.
Just book a reserved seat. Are you broke? Then take the bus.
That "3 hours" thing only comes up when the train's fully booked.
Gonna tell Clara to stand up too? (a nod to the famous "Clara, you're standing!" scene from Heidi)
If you want to ride in a wheelchair that badly, I'll help you lose a leg. You're welcome.
That guy was zipping around on his hands like it was nothing.
Actually, Clara's been standing up just fine for quite a while now.
What even is a "standing ticket," lol
A ticket gives you the right to use that space, doesn't it?
If you're allowed to leave a bag there, a chair should be fine too.
I don't think they said it's banned — just don't get in the way.
"Please don't obstruct other passengers' movement," basically.
I've bought a standing ticket on the Hayabusa from Tokyo to Misawa myself — same price as a reserved seat. There are about 3 standing spots per car, and you're expected to stand near the boarding doors. Even if there's an open seat nearby, you can't sit in it. Basically it's a ticket for the doorway space. Next time I use it, I was planning to bring a Gadabout Chair — would that be rude?
Exactly, that's the point.
"So what if everyone did it" — that's a naive take.
Nothing would really happen, lol. Plenty of people already drag huge suitcases on board anyway.
https://www.jprime.jp/mwimgs/d/b/360/img_db32e792e11e55049b7eb5a01c0e88a8936416.jpg
At the Osaka Expo, I was shocked how many people were casually sitting on folding chairs just like this one while waiting in those massive lines. Probably regulars who knew the ropes.
https://thumbnail.image.rakuten.co.jp/@0_mall/e-monostore1/cabinet/2025-9-1/70953_1k2.jpg
At places like Maihama (Tokyo Disney) and Universal Studios Japan, people camp out overnight in line with these things all the time.
Background and Key Points
The Tohoku Shinkansen’s Hayabusa and Komachi services are entirely reserved-seat trains — unlike the Tokaido-Sanyo Shinkansen further south, which has long kept non-reserved (jiyūseki) cars where passengers without a reservation queue on the platform and, if the car fills, stand or sit on the floor. JR East has no such non-reserved car on these trains; instead, when all reserved seats sell out, it issues a “standing ticket” (立席特急券) at the same fare as a reserved seat, entitling the holder only to ride in the vestibule near the doors — not to sit in any empty seat, even one that happens to be free for that leg of the journey. This is the system the original poster was using when they set up a camp chair.
The thread’s actual fault line wasn’t really about chairs versus no chairs — it was whether the standing-ticket system itself is reasonable. One camp treated the chair as a harmless workaround for a badly designed product (full fare, no seat guaranteed); the other insisted the fix is simply to book ahead or pay for a seat, and saw the chair as queue-jumping the spirit of standing tickets.
What outside readers likely miss is that this isn’t casual commuter-train standing — it’s a premium bullet-train service charging full reserved-seat-equivalent price for standing room only, a legacy JR practice dating to the national rail era that has no real equivalent on most other high-speed rail systems. Also unaddressed in the thread: vestibule space near doors is regulated for emergency evacuation and luggage clearance, which is the actual likely basis for JR East’s “as long as it doesn’t block the aisle” line, not mere etiquette.
*This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (News Speed+) thread “[Railways] Backlash Erupts Over “Life Hack” Bragging About Bringing a Chair Onto the Shinkansen Hayabusa… The Rule JR East Revealed.”
Leave a Reply