Category: Baseball

  • Giants Rally Past Carp in Extra Innings, Close Gap on Hanshin to 3.5 Games With Franchise-First 10-Pitcher Bullpen Game

    On September 6, the Giants came from behind to beat the Carp in the 11th inning thanks to timely hits from Takuya Kai and Hayato Sakamoto, taking a series win over Hiroshima for the first time in two years and cutting the gap to first-place Hanshin to 3.5 games. The game also marked the first time in the club’s 11,573-game history that it used 10 pitchers in relief, sparking talk about how often the bullpen arms have been working on back-to-back days. On the thread, the debate over the starting shortstop job pitted error totals against UZR for Yuta Izumiguchi, Kaito Muramatsu, and Hideki Nagaoka, with the two metrics telling very different stories. The same day brought a stack of other news too — Masahiro Tanaka’s demotion to the farm, and Seino Transportation’s first Intercity Baseball Tournament title in 12 years.

    1AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:08
    Previous thread
    Giants Acting-Manager Thread 126
    3AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:09
    [Giants] First series win over Carp in 2 years, cut Hanshin's lead to 3.5 games! Kai's 2nd homer, off Okamoto in the 11th; Sakamoto's insurance-run knock part of a 5-run outburst; Norimoto picks up his 3rd win; Masuda's 4th HR & Oshiro's 9th
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/7865ade664ff0c2d395ad696c5b39718d9d06599
    5AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:11
    [Giants] Farm team's game vs. the Dragons rained out — currently 25 games over .500, 2 games behind first-place DeNA
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/626f14d163c317db33b3b9b8e8e406a60aa1f075
    6AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:11
    [Giants] First 10-pitcher bullpen game in the club's 11,573-game history — five relievers pitch on back-to-back days in historic outing, with a third straight day possible as Giants eye a sweep of the Carp at Mazda Stadium
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/da5f75525029e3b1fcde6f976cf10c915013283e

    On the 6th, the Giants are going for a three-game sweep of the Carp at Mazda Stadium. Relievers Hotta, Morita, Nakagawa, Ei Tanaka, and Martinez are all working their second straight day. It'll depend on how each pitcher is feeling, but with the team chasing first-place Hanshin by just 3.5 games and every game a must-win, sending some of them out for a third day in a row is very much on the table.
    13AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:12
    Kojima's 4th at-bat: an infield single, so he's 4-for-4
    16AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:21
    Bottom of the 4th
    NTT West 0-2 Seino Transportation
    22AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:38
    [Giants] Yuta Izumiguchi just 6 plate appearances from qualifying for the batting title two years running — hit a clutch game-tying single the day before, his value at shortstop keeps propping the team up
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/3b2d2674612a7b2435f2f0dea93380bf2cea2b46
    23AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:39
    Top of the 5th over
    NTT West 0-4 Seino Transportation
    25AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:42
    Is Izumiguchi taking Best Nine and the Gold Glove at short again this year?
    There's really only Muramatsu and Nagaoka in the conversation besides him
    26AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:48
    Izumiguchi: 109 G, .247, 6 HR, 34 RBI, OPS .675, 10 errors
    Muramatsu: 109 G, .262, 5 HR, 38 RBI, OPS .724, 15 errors
    Nagaoka: 107 G, .255, 8 HR, 35 RBI, OPS .686, 9 errors
    27AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:51
    Go develop a shortstop like Kazuo already (a nod to Kazuo Matsui, the star Giants/Seibu shortstop of the '90s-2000s)
    28AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:53
    Kojima's 5th at-bat: grounded out to the pitcher, so no cycle
    30AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:56
    UZR
    1.9 — Izumiguchi
    1.5 — Muramatsu
    -10.5 — Nagaoka
    31AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:57
    Wait, Lotte's Rukeshi was carrying a no-hitter through 7 innings?
    33AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:00
    If you actually watch Nagaoka play, his range is clearly the worst of the three by a mile, but if you only look at the error count, he looks like the best of the bunch
    35AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:05
    [Giants] Team's win leader Onda Inoue back at practice after 6 days out sick — 'I'm just focused on how to win the one game right in front of me'
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/d616b13ce051cad5d42dfd36c214c15959bbeea4
    36AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:09
    Active roster moves for September 6, 2026

    Central League
    Added to active roster
    Yokohama DeNA BayStars — Pitcher #12 Yu Takeda
    Removed from active roster
    Yomiuri Giants — Pitcher #11 Masahiro Tanaka
    Hiroshima Toyo Carp — Pitcher #53 Shun Okamoto
    Tokyo Yakult Swallows — Pitcher #70 Yu Hirosawa
    *Players cannot be reactivated before September 16.

    Pacific League
    Added to active roster
    Chiba Lotte Marines — Pitcher #48 J. Rukeshi
    Removed from active roster
    None
    38AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:14
    [Giants] Masahiro Tanaka demoted again — winless in 2 starts since his last call-up, exited the previous night's game after 3 innings with 1 earned run
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/1c0c2b6671ee6fd060d2fa0fe114b4a64342d7e6
    40AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:19
    NTT West Hardball Baseball Club
    Ryota Wakiya (infielder) — joined the Yomiuri Giants as a 5th-round pick in the 2005 college/industrial-league draft
    Takuzo Oshiro (catcher) — joined the Yomiuri Giants as a 3rd-round pick in the 2017 draft
    Yuta Izumiguchi (infielder) — joined the Yomiuri Giants as a 4th-round pick in the 2023 draft

    Seino Transportation Hardball Baseball Club
    Taiga Funasako (pitcher) — joined the Yomiuri Giants as a 5th-round pick in the 2022 draft
    41AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:21
    [Carp] Shun Okamoto demoted… gave up 4 runs in the 11th the night before, his 3rd outing allowing runs in his last 5 — the right-hander leads the team with 7 wins and made his first All-Star team this year
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/7e462a06c72938749495b7133770e9a6018b42e6
    42AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:25
    Okamoto was doing great as a starter, though…
    Instead of letting him rest when he got tired, they threw him into relief, ran him into the ground, and now he's demoted
    44AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:29
    Re: #42
    That's exactly where the Giants do things differently
    45AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:29
    Re: #42
    'Hard-Luck' Arai (fans' nickname for the manager, playing on the word for 'tough/bitter'): 'We're a poor club short on arms, can't be helped'
    51AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:43
    Re: #42
    Arai: 'I'm tearing it all down'
    46AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:30
    Even without Whitley, Mata and Howard can cover for him
    That kind of depth is what matters
    47AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:35
    Thought it felt cool today, but turns out it's a scorcher in Hiroshima, still over 30°C
    48AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:36
    Weather at Mazda Stadium looks fine
    Koshien's looking iffy though
    49AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:39
    Top of the 8th over
    NTT West 2-4 Seino Transportation
    53AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:46
    Sato-Teru, lol (nickname for Hanshin's Teruaki Sato)

    [All Smiles] Teruaki Sato beaming after getting an award, before the 9/5/2026 game
    https://youtu.be/bHH-SRx7c20?si=AY8G-2TSIfI3dH8m
    54AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:47
    About as exciting as an Orix-Dragons game
    56AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:51
    Top of the 9th
    Tsujimoto, who's suited up for Japan's national industrial-league team before, hits a home run
    NTT West 3-4 Seino Transportation
    63AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:58
    Game over
    NTT West 3-4 Seino Transportation
    64AnonymousSep 6, 2026 16:59
    Ogaki City's Seino Transportation wins it all for the 2nd time, first since 12 years ago
    65AnonymousSep 6, 2026 17:00
    [Intercity Baseball] Seino Transportation crowned national champions for the first time in 12 years — manager Naoharu Saeki's first title since 2014, when he was the team's ace pitcher; edges out NTT West in the final
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/26be46b6eb0e4436e04dd6ad4ba0865a3b4daaea
    68AnonymousSep 6, 2026 17:03
    Does the Intercity tournament actually get the host cities hyped up?
    70AnonymousSep 6, 2026 17:04
    [Dragons] Manager Kazuki Inoue: 'We're also clearing our schedule the fastest' — plays up the upside of the rainout, says Yuya Yanagi will start against the Giants in the next series
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/68ba5c32a078d3933eaea6de43a28b69c9e1309c

    Yanagi, originally slated to start, will instead pitch in the Giants' three-game series at Tokyo Dome starting on the 8th. With veterans like Wakui and Ono also in the rotation, the manager hinted at a shakeup, weighing each pitcher's rest between outings: 'There's also the question of where's best to slot those guys in. We're keeping an eye on how the schedule shapes up too.'
    72AnonymousSep 6, 2026 17:05
    Wonder if Seino Transportation will run a shipping discount to celebrate the title

    Background and Talking Points

    One detail worth flagging is the roster rule buried in the story: once Masahiro Tanaka came off the active roster, he can’t be reactivated until September 16 — a league-wide NPB rule meant to stop teams from shuffling players in and out too freely, and one casual fans often don’t know about. In the shortstop competition, Nagaoka looks like the safest pair of hands going by error count alone, but once you weight in range via UZR, Izumiguchi and Muramatsu both come out ahead — proof, as the thread found, that no single stat settles who’s actually better. Behind the 10-pitcher-relief story is also a contrast in bullpen philosophy: Hiroshima’s new manager, Takahiro Arai, is said to be deliberately holding back on how often he uses his relievers, while the Giants have kept sending the same arms out day after day. The Intercity tournament, meanwhile, is a national championship for corporate/industrial-league teams, and it doubles as a scouting pipeline into the pros — champions Seino Transportation count Taiga Funasako, now pitching for the Giants, among their alumni.

    *This article was compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Giants Acting-Manager Thread 127.”

  • Manager Roberts Analyzes Ohtani’s Condition — 5ch: “The Two-Way Duality of Good Shohei and Bad Shohei”

    After the game on the 5th (6th Japan time), Dodgers manager Dave Roberts offered his view that Shohei Ohtani’s “personality changes depending on whether he’s feeling good or bad physically.” On 5ch, the comment sparked mixed reactions — some joked about a “Good Ohtani” and “Bad Ohtani” two-way duality, others defended him with “that’s true of anyone,” while others pointed to his past behavior and took a harsher view, saying “his true colors are just showing.”

    <Dodgers vs. Nationals> ◇ 5th (6th Japan time) ◇ Dodger Stadium

    Dodgers manager Dave Roberts (54) gave his assessment that pitcher Shohei Ohtani (32) has recovered quite well from his current condition.

    [Photo] The “angry…” look on Ohtani’s face after being cautioned by manager Roberts

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Read the original article here

    4AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:54
    Well, you see a person's true self when things aren't going well, right?
    5AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:55
    If Ohtani weren't playing, the Dodgers' ratings on satellite TV would be an absolute disaster.
    13AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:58
    Re: #5
    Your Japanese is worse.
    6AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:55
    The two-way flow of Good Shohei and Bad Shohei
    7AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:55
    Like the old "when you've got your 551 / when you don't" bit? (a classic Japanese comedy routine about 551 Horai pork buns)
    8AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:55
    Every human's like that lol
    42AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:01
    Re: #8
    It's not "everyone" — that's exactly why the manager brought it up.
    111AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:12
    Re: #8
    Re: #19
    Iniesta was treated like a saint too, but he'd completely lose it whenever things weren't going well in the J.League.
    A person's true nature shows precisely when things aren't going well.
    9AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:55
    When he got criticized for getting caught stealing, he stubbornly kept stealing out of spite — once he stops performing well, I bet more "bad personality" stories will keep surfacing.
    10AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:56
    You're only noticing this now?
    11AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:56
    That's basically dissing him for being two-faced lol
    14AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:58
    Jeter once looked back on Matsui's Yankees days and said, "That guy never changed no matter the situation or condition."
    18AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:58
    His good personality was never really his selling point to begin with.
    44AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:02
    Re: #18
    Back when he was still in Japan talking about his "I'll show them" challenger spirit in interviews, he had this ambitious look on his face.
    His true personality is probably that of a competitive, elite-minded person — and that type exists everywhere.
    62AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:05
    Re: #18
    The media ran a whole campaign about him picking up trash and being considerate to opposing players, remember?
    198AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:26
    Re: #18
    He used to get treated like a bratty kid who teased his senpai.
    19AnonymousSep 6, 2026 14:58
    Re: #1
    Wait, isn't that true for literally everyone?
    41AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:01
    Ippei: "In Saint Seiya terms, he's like Gemini Saga after he became the Pope."
    Kurumada (the manga's creator): "…You've only just begun climbing."
    Ippei: "…up this endlessly long slope of debt repayment." (a joke riffing on Ippei Mizuhara, Ohtani's former interpreter, and his gambling debt repayment, framed as Saint Seiya manga dialogue)
    65AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:05
    Re: #41
    The same embezzlement won't work twice on a Saint 🙄

    Pegasus Illusion → 4.6 billion yen (a parody of Saint Seiya's iconic special-move names, referencing Ippei Mizuhara's roughly ¥4.6 billion embezzlement)
    49AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:03
    That's just how humans are.
    People make a fuss about it because they treat a mere athlete like some kind of saint.
    61AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:05
    Re: #49
    Because if you write even a slightly negative article, you get banned on the spot — and so does the outlet itself.
    84AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:08
    Re: #49
    There's the opposite pattern too.
    When someone whose life had been going well hits a rough patch,
    they start understanding other people's pain, become kinder,
    and learn to be considerate.
    Either way, humans are fundamentally selfish, self-centered creatures.
    67AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:06
    Something that's puzzled me for a while —
    there's no reason athletes have to be saints,
    yet I can never figure out why they get treated like one.
    The baseball guys at my school were nothing but troublemakers, in the bad sense.
    109AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:12
    Re: #67
    That goes for sports clubs in general, not just baseball.
    They're a bunch of guys with energy to burn
    who can't stand not being the center of attention —
    of course there's going to be some roughness and selfishness.
    81AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:08
    A dog's ability to sense things…
    Dekopin… (Dekopin is the name of Ohtani's dog)
    137AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:16
    Re: #81
    Wait, what —
    weren't things going well with his dog?
    90AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:09
    Roberts said he was doing batting practice the entire game.
    This guy's insane.
    105AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:12
    Re: #90
    Even telling him to rest is useless.
    114AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:12
    I mean, doesn't everyone's personality change when they're not feeling well?
    119AnonymousSep 6, 2026 15:13
    Re: #114
    I don't think my personality changes… am I just special?

    Background and Points of Debate

    Manager Roberts’ comment came amid Ohtani’s ongoing return to two-way (pitching and hitting) game action, and appears to mean that his focus and demeanor tend to shift when he’s not feeling well physically. The thread split over whether to read this as “a natural human reaction anyone would have” or as “a backlash against expecting athletes to be saints.” Ohtani’s public image has historically been built on wholesome anecdotes like picking up trash and showing consideration for opposing players, and as a counter-reaction to that, some posts linked this comment to the idea that “the mask has finally slipped.” However, some of these posts were based on unsourced hearsay or references to footage that couldn’t be verified, and it’s worth noting that the original article is simply about Roberts commenting on the degree of Ohtani’s physical recovery. Some also argued that the controversy over his emotional ups and downs says less about Ohtani’s personal character than about the media and public’s tendency to project an overly saintly image onto athletes — a perspective that can’t be gleaned from the original article alone, and is unique to the thread’s discussion.

    *This article is compiled as an excerpt/summary from the 5ch (Geisoku+) thread “Manager Roberts: “Shohei’s personality changes when he’s feeling good vs. bad” — analyzing Ohtani’s condition“.

  • Giants’ Starting Lineup Draws Cries of ‘Smells Like the Farm Team’ — But Praise for Ohshiro, Who Turned Down Free Agency to Stay

    With the Giants playing under an acting-manager setup, the team entered the final game of its series against Hiroshima, and when the starting lineup was announced on September 5, harsh comments like “this reeks of the farm team” poured in. On the other hand, some praised the decision to keep using Takumi Ohshiro, who chose to stay with the team instead of testing free agency, saying it was “good to see him get rewarded.” Opinions were split. News that Orix’s Kohei Higashi underwent right elbow surgery for the third year in a row also became a talking point, and the thread that day was dominated by discussion of team management and roster decisions.

    1AnonymousSep 4, 2026 22:54
    Previous thread
    Giants Acting Manager Thread 124 (fixed)
    8AnonymousSep 4, 2026 23:07
    Good to see Ohshiro get rewarded for not going through with free agency
    17AnonymousSep 4, 2026 23:16
    Re: #8
    Still, they really need to develop their own catchers
    28AnonymousSep 5, 2026 00:11
    Well, Matsui bailed, so it's on those two now anyway
    78AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:46
    Re: #28
    Matsui didn't bail — he wants to be a coach/manager for an MLB team
    That's the "rest of the dream" Matsui talked about
    32AnonymousSep 5, 2026 00:50
    Didn't we already conclude that managers who only went to high school aren't good?
    79AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:57
    Re: #32
    It's not just about education level — it's whether they were team captain in high school, college, or during their playing days as a pro, whether they've had coaching or farm-team manager experience, or whether they jumped straight to manager with no steps in between.

    Take Kazuhiko Ushijima, for example: he consistently insisted that if he became a pitching coach, he'd need full authority over pitcher usage and pull timing — with not even the manager allowed to interfere — and he never budged on that condition with anyone. As a result, coaching offers kept falling through one after another. In the end, the only job he ever actually got was manager of the BayStars.
    81AnonymousSep 5, 2026 10:15
    Re: #32
    Manager Fujikawa's stock has been rising thanks to Kudo and Kinoshita breaking out and Motoyama bouncing back…
    42AnonymousSep 5, 2026 06:16
    So the young guys have to clean up after Ma-kun (Masahiro Tanaka) again?
    53AnonymousSep 5, 2026 08:04
    Re: #42
    Last time it was because 'Lord Hashi' (a player mockingly deified for issuing an intentional walk) gave an intentional walk — it'll be fine this time
    54AnonymousSep 5, 2026 08:15
    ▽ Games scheduled for Sat 9/5
    Tigers–BayStars (Koshien) 18:00
    Carp–Giants (Mazda Stadium) 18:00
    ▽ Announced starters for Sat 9/5
    (Tigers–BayStars) Shoki Murakami (R) vs. Takato Ogata (R)
    (Carp–Giants) Shogo Tamamura (L) vs. Masahiro Tanaka (R)
    60AnonymousSep 5, 2026 08:58
    Re: #54
    Since Tamamura's a lefty, they'll probably shamelessly pull the Ishizuka-to-Sakamoto swap again
    59AnonymousSep 5, 2026 08:47


    83AnonymousSep 5, 2026 11:19
    85AnonymousSep 5, 2026 11:29
    [Orix] Kohei Higashi goes under the knife on his right elbow for the third year running — announces Tommy John surgery using an artificial ligament
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/06f5ace5f6a781828dbc42a7fd5f4158e4142d87

    Orix announced that pitcher Kohei Higashi (26) underwent ligament repair surgery with an internal brace for a torn ligament in his right elbow on the 4th at a hospital in Saga Prefecture. He's expected to be hospitalized for about a week before starting rehab.
    88AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:01
    Re: #85
    Oh right, Higashi's still around — totally forgot about him
    89AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:03
    Praying the Giants (referred to here with the mocking kanji swap '虚塵,' literally "hollow dust") lose today 🙏
    90AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:12
    Re: #89
    Starting to get scared of how many games are left against Hiroshima…
    91AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:13
    Shohei Ohtani (32): "My knee hurts, but so does my neck"
    https://kizuna.5ch.io/test/read.cgi/morningcoffee/1788563666/
    92AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:19
    Re: #91
    Sato-Teru will be carrying the load starting next year, so rest easy
    98AnonymousSep 5, 2026 13:31
    107AnonymousSep 5, 2026 13:59
    18 years ago it was:
    Suzuki
    Kimutaku
    Gattsu
    Rami
    Seung-yeop
    Tani
    Abe
    Sakamoto

    With PND coming off the bench
    Of course a lineup like that was gonna win lol
    Out of today's starters, only Urata and Ohshiro would even make the bench back then lol
    109AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:10
    Re: #107
    The pinch hitter was actually Daido
    110AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:18
    Replay review requested over whether he touched the base
    112AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:34
    Re: #110
    Koseki: "I touched it"
    123AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:59
    Gifu-chan / Gifu Broadcasting Radio
    Saturday, September 5, 13:55–17:00
    Live broadcast of the 97th Intercity Baseball Tournament
    Semifinal: Seino Transportation (Ogaki City) vs. Aejec (Oyama City)
    — from Tokyo Dome
    Commentary: Shigeru Komori (Managing Director, JABA Gifu Prefecture Baseball Federation)
    Play-by-play: Tomohiro Ueno
    *Broadcast will run past the scheduled end time until the game finishes
    124AnonymousSep 5, 2026 15:04
    Re: #123
    Thx — oh, it's the semifinal, huh
    135AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:09
    ◆ Infield/outfield practice positions

    1B: Tima, Riku Masuda
    2B: Urata
    3B: Sakamoto, Ishizuka
    SS: Izumiguchi, Yuasa
    LF: Maru, Matsumoto, Hagio
    CF: Dai Suzuki
    RF: Sasaki, Nakayama

    Apparently Darbeck was out for warmups, but then talked with the trainer afterward, and the coaching staff got kind of flustered… or so I hear
    Since Tamamura's a lefty, it'll probably be Sakamoto at 3B again with Tima or Riku at 1B
    Come on, don't tell me both guys who drove in runs yesterday are sitting this one out
    136AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:12
    Even with Ishii out and the bullpen a weak spot, they're still in first place
    How come Kinoshita and Kudo just show up and the weakness disappears just like that? Our team is riddled with weaknesses and we're struggling
    151AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:46
    Re: #136
    Maybe our team needs to rethink its draft strategy…
    154AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:55
    Re: #136
    If anything it's turned into a strength for them, so to beat them you need to at least be tied heading into the late innings
    Score at full throttle from the first inning, and ride the starter as far as he can go
    A game like the one against the Swallows the other day is the worst-case scenario
    171AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:18
    Mazda Stadium
    Starting Lineups
    [Giants] [Carp]
    4 Urata 8 Sho Nakamura
    6 Izumiguchi 3 Kei Sato
    3 Riku Masuda 7 Fabian
    2 Ohshiro 5 Sakakura
    5 Ishizuka 4 Kikuchi
    7 Matsumoto 9 Sasaki
    8 Dai Suzuki 2 Mochizumi
    9 Sasaki 6 Katsuta
    1 Masahiro Tanaka 1 Tamamura
    *Darbeck out of the lineup due to not feeling well
    188AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:28
    Re: #171
    Lol this one reeks of the farm team too
    And Hochi Shimbun's out here saying it's just like 18 years ago — lmao
    207AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:37
    213AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:40
    837AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:51
    OPS by opposing team

    Maki
    vs. Giants: OPS .693
    vs. Tigers: OPS 1.176

    Encarnacion
    vs. Giants: OPS .581
    vs. Tigers: OPS 1.014

    Miyazaki
    vs. Giants: OPS .500
    vs. Tigers: OPS 1.002
    840AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:52
    Re: #837
    Our team's Kanagawa branch is doing pretty well
    842AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:52
    Re: #837
    Doing good, aren't they

    Background and Key Points

    Takumi Ohshiro appears to have chosen to stay with the team even though he was eligible for free agency, and whether the club can develop a long-term starting catcher has repeatedly come up as an ongoing issue for the organization. Kohei Higashi’s right elbow surgery, which became a talking point that day, is his third in as many years, once again highlighting how difficult it is to manage and develop pitchers who keep getting injured. In the thread, harsh assessments of the lineup and in-game management appeared alongside comments pointing out individual players’ strong records against certain opponents — a reminder that the lineup card alone doesn’t tell you whether the strategy behind it is sound. Note that some posts touching on managerial personnel decisions and club alumni could not be verified, so they have not been included in this article.

    *This article is an excerpt and summary of the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Giants Acting Manager Thread 125.”

  • ‘No Talent’ — Giants’ Ishizuka Silences Critics with a Timely Hit Right After Brutal Blast

    This roundup gathers reactions from the 5ch thread “Giants Acting Manager 126,” which was live-commentating the road game against Hiroshima on September 5. Early on, attention centered on how long pitcher Daichi Ishii could stretch his scoreless-innings streak, but it finally snapped late in the game. On offense, Yusei Ishizuka — just harshly criticized as having “no sense at all” — answered immediately with a timely hit, silencing the very posters who’d trashed him. On defense, Yuta Izumiguchi’s error stood out, and the thread swung between highs and lows the whole game.

    1AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:22
    Previous thread
    Giants Acting Manager 125
    2AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:22
    2025-2026
    Departures
    Released: 26 Imamura, 28 Takahashi, 36 Baba, 54 Otosaka, 95 Toda
    Unconditional release: 29 Griffin, 33 Keller, 39 Furup, 42 Hernandez, 50 Okoe
    Active Player Draft (out): 68 Kikuchi
    FA compensation (out): 48 Tanaka Chi
    Trade (out): 59 Wakabayashi
    Posting (out): 25 Okamoto
    Retired: 7 Chono, 30 Kondo, 43 Shigenobu

    Demoted to development roster: 69 Sasahara, 90 Ishida Mitsuru, 94 Kita, 98 Suzuki, 99 Kyomoto

    Arrivals
    Draft picks (regular): 21 Takemaru, 30 Tawa, 33 Kohama, 36 Yamashiro, 39 Minagawa, 99 Fujii
    FA signings: 9 Matsumoto, 43 Norimoto
    Active Player Draft (in): 54 Matsuura
    Trade (in): none
    Other: 26 Whitley, 28 Howard, 29 Dalbec, 42 Mata, 56 Kitaura, 98 Ogasawara

    Promoted to first-team roster: 25 Shiroki, 48 Luciano, 50 Tima, 59 Suzuki, 68 Utsunomiya, 69 Hirayama, 94 Chinen, 95 Sasahara

    2025 first-team registrations: 69
    2026 first-team registrations: 70

    Vacant uniform numbers
    7 18 55 83
    3AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:22
    Mazda Stadium
    Starting Lineups
    [Giants] [Hiroshima]
    4 Urata 8 Nakamura Sho
    6 Izumiguchi 3 Sato Kei
    3 Masuda Riku 7 Fabian
    2 Oshiro 5 Sakakura
    5 Ishizuka 4 Kikuchi
    7 Matsumoto 9 Sasaki
    8 Suzuki Dai 2 Mochimaru
    9 Sasaki 6 Katsuta
    1 Tanaka Masahiro 1 Tamamura
    *Dalbec out of the lineup, not feeling well
    5AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:30
    This is bad, this is REALLY bad
    6AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:31
    Here comes the 'gets hit by the same batter twice' jinx
    8AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:31
    Hang in there, Tamo
    10AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:31
    Wouldn't be shocked if he gave up a run any moment now
    11AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:32
    Word is Murata's the one calling the pitching changes
    12AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:33
    Fabian's hitting .300 — but only against us ('our team,' the usual fan slang for the Giants)
    13AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:33
    Just like Nakamura, there's always some guy who's ice cold all season except against the Giants, then suddenly turns into a monster
    16AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:34
    Hey Izumiguchi, quit messing around out there
    19AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:34
    Keeps getting bailed out by Riku's glove at first
    28AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:35
    Infield, outfield, whatever — what is going on with the Giants' defense today
    29AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:35
    Kawasoi, quit coaching Urata all the time and go work with Izumiguchi already
    32AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:36
    If Fabian had actually run that one out properly, that would've been bad for us
    33AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:36
    Ishii Daichi still doesn't have his control today — might actually be hittable
    34AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:36
    Izumiguchi just doesn't have enough faith. In the end, he's the one who'll save our team
    39AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:39
    [Nippon-Ham] Accident for Tatsuki Mizuno — hit by pitch on the left leg, grimaces in pain, forced out of the game
    https://news.yahoo.co.jp/articles/19c53829d344f538d37a7e7268aedf7946d4601e
    40AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:39
    Ishii still looks shaky out there today — any other time he'd be shutting us down easy
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:40
    He's about as fast as Urata or Oshiro now (i.e. not fast at all)
    51AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:41
    Is Fabian actually good or bad? Can't tell anymore
    52AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:41
    It's come around to our two best hitters with runners in scoring position — come on!
    57AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:42
    Somebody end Ishii's scoreless streak already
    59AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:43
    Wish he'd just throw pitches like that one. Yeah, Ishizuka's got zero sense, no doubt about it
    73AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:44
    Re: #59
    Where's your apology?
    74AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:44
    Re: #59
    Lol, acting like some kind of expert
    83AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:45
    Did Re: #59 lose it and keel over? lol
    61AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:43
    ISHIZUKA WITH THE TIMELY HIIIIIT AAAAAAH
    70AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:43
    That's Ishi-chan (affectionate nickname for Ishizuka) fighting off two strikes and slapping one to the right side
    75AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:44
    Wait, we were only tied?? Felt like we were straight-up winning lol
    77AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:44
    Getting closer and closer to Meikyukai (NPB's 'Golden Players Club' for career-milestone legends)
    79AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:45
    Ishii's done, folks, lolololololol
    81AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:45
    Oshiro-Ishizuka as the new cleanup combo — not bad at all!
    86AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:45
    Oshiro's finally dropped that habit of leaning back while running
    95AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:47
    This home plate ump's strike zone is running high across the board today
    99AnonymousSep 5, 2026 20:48
    That pitch that got away from him is going to be dangerous against lefties

    Background and talking points

    The “acting manager” in the thread’s title is the nickname reflecting that the Giants are currently playing under an interim manager rather than a fully appointed one, and it’s carried straight through this ongoing series of live-commentary thread titles. As the roster news at the top of the thread (post 2) shows, this season is seeing a major roster overhaul spanning the draft, free agency, and released players, and the thread’s mood reflects just how closely fans are following the front office moves. “Our team” is standard internet slang Giants fans use for their own club, with no deeper meaning intended. Pitcher Daichi Ishii’s “scoreless streak” refers to the number of consecutive scoreless innings he’s built up appearance after appearance, and it’s a frequent talking point in live threads as a gauge of a reliever’s consistency. The exchange around Ishizuka — getting harshly criticized only to deliver a timely hit moments later — is a classic case of an anonymous-board post getting instantly undercut by results, and is better read as part of the thread’s live energy than as any real verdict on the player. Likewise, the error attributed to Izumiguchi on defense was a one-off moment in a game-deciding situation, and should be viewed separately from any judgment on his season as a whole.

    *This article is compiled and summarized from excerpts of the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Giants Acting Manager 126.”

  • Ohtani Sits Out Second Straight Game, Bolts Stadium Right After Final Out — 5ch Debates Whether He Should Even Be on the Bench

    Dodgers pitcher Shohei Ohtani sat out for a second consecutive game against the Nationals on September 4 (September 5 JST). He appeared on the bench in the late innings, joined the team’s celebration huddle after the win, then immediately bolted back behind the bench and hurried out of the stadium the moment the game ended. In 5ch’s live-thread discussion, opinions were split over why he refuses to go on the injured list (IL) despite carrying an injury, and how to judge him dutifully showing up on the bench even while sidelined. Some posters sarcastically noted “the lineup’s been dead ever since Ohtani stopped playing,” while others voiced concern about the state of his neck, biceps, and knee.

    Dodgers pitcher Shohei Ohtani sat out the Nationals game at home on the 4th (5th JST), marking his second straight day of rest. He headed straight home right after the game — a “lightning-fast exit” for the second day in a row.

    After appearing on the bench late in the game and joining the victory huddle, he suddenly took off running behind the bench, making a “lightning-fast” getaway.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:35
    This guy really is an attention-seeker, huh
    5AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:35
    LMAO, now he's not even bothering to show up on the bench anymore
    11AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:36
    Guess he doesn't care what his teammates think of him.
    Mentally strong in a way, I suppose.
    46AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:46
    Re: #11
    It's right there in his elementary school yearbook essay —
    'Types of people Ohtani dislikes':

    'people who kill the vibe' ←…wait, huh?
    13AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:36
    If he's just going to run home right after, he might as well not have shown up at all —
    he's not even playing anyway.
    48AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:47
    Re: #13
    Nah, there's still cheering the team on —
    being part of the team's unity is basically an obligation.
    Not showing up on the bench at all would've been really bad.
    15AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:37
    Why is he so stubbornly refusing to go on the IL?
    Think about the team for once.
    29AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:40
    Re: #15
    Maybe there's a pay-cut clause in his contract?
    30AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:41
    Re: #15
    It's because he's not thinking about it at all.
    19AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:38
    He probably thinks this kind of thing is funny.
    26AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:39
    Re: #19
    Didn't need to go and run either, honestly —
    it's just cringe on every level.
    36AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:43
    Not just Ohtani — you never really hear about Japanese MLB players hanging out with teammates off the field, outside of lip-service comments.
    42AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:44
    Re: #36
    Matsui used to go hang out at his teammates' houses all the time back in his Yankees days.
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:45
    He's useless at hitting, pitching, and fielding right now, but since he won't go on the IL, the team's basically stuck playing with one less roster spot.
    65AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:54
    Re: #44
    Seriously just in the way, lol.
    53AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:48
    Staying great over a long career is a huge part of what makes a player truly great.
    It's starting to look doubtful Ohtani can pull that off, though he might still manage it if he focused on pitching alone.
    67AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:55
    Re: #53
    The 'flash in the pan' type (lit. 'peak gust of wind') tends to get remembered later wrapped in romance — but also for poor self-management and reckless spending.
    54AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:49
    Re: #48
    He wasn't even cheering until the 7th inning though…
    63AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:53
    Re: #54
    That's exactly why it's so bad.
    In Japan, a pitcher who isn't starting doesn't need to be on the bench, but in the majors, not pitching doesn't mean you're off the team —
    you're still expected to travel with the club and cheer them on.

    Since they come from 'hunter' stock (a common internet trope contrasting Western individualism with Japan's 'farmer' culture), their tradition of team unity runs way stricter than Japanese people tend to assume.
    58AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:50
    Does he even feel any embarrassment?
    Getting paid something like 100 billion yen and still being called useless.
    62AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:52
    Re: #58
    Oh right, he's still only in year 3 with the Dodgers.
    If he retires early, he might end up worse off than a death-row inmate (hyperbole about how brutal the fallout from his contract terms would be).
    66AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:55
    Once Japanese fans lose interest and he stops being profitable, he's going to get absolutely torn apart by the locals.
    72AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:57
    Re: #66
    I bet the gambling scandal gets dragged back up too.
    79AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:03
    But tomorrow's news will probably spin it as him gritting through the pain to show up on the bench for the team.
    93AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:11
    Re: #79
    The media's already struggling to keep covering for him, so the coverage itself is shrinking — they'll probably just gloss over it.
    This is exactly how he fades into the background.
    80AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:03
    The Dodgers' lineup suddenly got hot the second Ohtani sat out, lmao.
    83AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:04
    Re: #80
    Even a sloppy Dodgers team wouldn't have everyone chasing the first pitch into a second-base grounder over and over.
    86AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:06
    Re: #80
    Six hits yesterday, five today — how is that 'hot'?
    That's all thanks to Smith, you idiot.
    82AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:04
    Where's the injury exactly?
    92AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:11
    Re: #82
    Neck, biceps, and knee.
    94AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:14
    Even LA crowds do 'Freddie' chants, but they only do 'Ohtani' chants when he's about to win MVP.
    He's not even that well-liked to begin with.
    97AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:19
    Re: #94
    Sounds like the Djokovic thing then — mechanical, not heartfelt.
    100AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:20
    https://youtube.com/shorts/idrk3MqD4gk?si=KJLPST2MaFEPJEcL

    Found actual footage of it lol
    102AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:21
    Re: #100
    Lmao, they're spinning this into some heartwarming story.
    109AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:23
    Re: #100
    He's definitely the odd one out on this team.
    111AnonymousSep 5, 2026 19:25
    Re: #100
    Is this really a heartwarming story though?
    Could also read as him getting kind of mocked lol

    Background and key points of this discussion

    In MLB, players generally travel with the team and sit on the bench even for games they’re not playing in, unless placed on the injured list (IL) — unlike Japanese baseball, where a pitcher who isn’t starting is typically treated as fully off duty. What split opinion in the thread was how to judge Ohtani showing up on the bench in line with this custom: some saw it as “fulfilling his obligation,” while others countered that “showing his face and bolting right after is obligation in name only.” Some posters speculated a pay-cut clause in his contract might explain his reluctance to go on the IL, but this is speculation — not something officially announced by the team or Ohtani himself. Comments naming his neck, biceps, and knee as the injured areas should also be treated with caution, since none of these have been officially confirmed as the injury sites.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nanademo Jikkyo G) thread “[Sad News] Shohei Ohtani shows up on the bench in the 8th, then the moment the game ends, suddenly takes off running for home wwwwwwwwwwww.”

  • SoftBank Blanks Seibu 2-0 as Otsu Fires 7 Scoreless Innings — Seibu Slides to Third Straight Loss

    In Pacific League play on September 5, SoftBank beat Seibu 2-0 for their third straight win, holding Seibu to just 4 hits in a shutout loss that stretched Seibu’s losing streak to three games. Starter Otsu worked 7 scoreless innings, and Kurihara chipped in 2 hits and 2 RBI. SoftBank now leads second-place Seibu by 7 games with their magic number down to 14, edging closer to a long-awaited third straight Pacific League pennant. A first-inning replay review over whether a runner had reached second base also became a talking point, with posters split on a play that was tough to call from video alone.

    Seibu.     0 0 0  0 0 0  0 0 0|0

    SoftBank  1 0 0  0 0 1  0 0 X|2

    [Battery]

    Source: nikkansports.com / Original article here

    5AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:53
    Ham-kasu (derogatory nickname for Fighters fans)
    Korokoro (flip-flopper)
    Ponko (dated ethnic slur)
    Treasure
    96 wins
    Big idiot
    Copycat
    Hokkaido native
    Dentsu
    Geezer
    Scrub
    One-year (contract)
    lol (lit. "grass")
    Non-tender
    Dodgers

    Arashi's catchphrase
    11AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:54
    Maaya Uchida extends her "Goddess of Victory" legend (the voice actress is seen as a lucky charm whenever she attends games)

    But wait, Kamichatani's starting tomorrow —
    was he really out there coaching Uchida on her ceremonial first-pitch form before today's game…?
    15AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:55
    Hakata Hanamaru: "A lot of people nationwide dislike the Hawks, so I don't talk about them on national broadcasts"

    A line from a Downtown bar-hopping segment a few years back

    If you've ever left Fukuoka, you'll know this is true
    16AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:55
    7 games up on second-place Seibu with a magic number of 14
    That long-awaited third straight Pacific League pennant is coming into view
    26AnonymousSep 5, 2026 16:59
    So that makes 7 straight wins with "Nee-taso" around then (fan nickname, inside joke — if you know, you know).
    28AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:03
    Otsu: "I pitched today thinking, come on infield, don't make an error on me"
    29AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:03
    At this rate, SoftBank might actually be more scared of the Fighters making the Climax Series
    They don't seem to have much of an inferiority complex against the Fighters lately
    33AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:07
    Re: #29
    There's a 3-game series in Fukuoka next week, so it probably comes down to that
    38AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:14
    Re: #29
    Honestly, I'd rather Seibu stayed in second
    42AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:16
    Re: #29
    It's like they let them win just to get cocky before the big stumble at the end
    63AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:51
    What was that thing in the first inning?
    What was Genda even appealing about?
    64AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:52
    Re: #63
    He was appealing that Shuto never touched second base
    65AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:53
    There just wasn't proof — he probably didn't touch it
    Otherwise they wouldn't bother with a replay request
    68AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:55
    Re: #65
    Genda was staring right at it, so maybe so
    73AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:07
    Re: #65
    From the replay footage, it looks like he touched it
    90AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:49
    Re: #65
    You don't need to "step on" the base
    Just "touching" it is enough

    It's not about whether he stepped on it,
    it's about whether he made contact —
    even with a toe or the side of the foot, contact is all it takes
    66AnonymousSep 5, 2026 17:54
    So if the Fighters lose today or tomorrow, and SoftBank wins tomorrow, the magic number drops by 3 at once?
    70AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:01
    Re: #66
    Rare, but not unheard of
    I think the Hanshin Tigers dropped theirs by 3 last year
    In the Pacific League, when records are tied, the magic number is decided by head-to-head results between the teams in question
    If the number of draws is equal,
    once a team takes the head-to-head lead, the magic number can drop by as much as 3 at once if the conditions line up
    77AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:21
    Re: #73
    It was a close call
    That's why the review took so long
    82AnonymousSep 5, 2026 18:31
    Re: #77
    It really wasn't that long

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    The Pacific League magic number is a rough measure of how many more wins are needed to clinch the pennant, and depending on other teams’ results, it can drop by more than one in a single game. The thread got into the rule that when winning percentages are tied, head-to-head results between the teams involved decide the tiebreaker — with posters recalling a past case where the number dropped by 3 in one game once the right conditions lined up. The other point of debate was the first-inning replay review, centered on whether the runner at second base had actually reached the bag. Under baseball’s rules, a runner is safe as long as they “touch” the base rather than fully “step on” it — contact from a toe or any part of the body is enough. That standard can be hard to judge from video alone, and it’s a detail that’s surprisingly not well known.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geisoku Sokuho+) thread “[Baseball] Pacific League H 2-0 L [9/5] — Hawks win again, Otsu 7 scoreless innings, Kurihara 2 hits 2 RBI, Seibu shut out on 4 hits for 3rd straight loss”.

  • Comparing 30 Years of Giants Lineups, 5ch Says ‘1999 Was the Golden Year’

    A poster who says they’ve been watching Yomiuri Giants baseball since 1996 started a thread on 5ch’s Nandemo Jikkyo G board listing out the team’s starting lineup year by year. The 1999 lineup — featuring Toshihisa Nishi, Takayuki Shimizu, Hideki Matsui, Kazuhiro Kiyohara, and Yoshinobu Takahashi — and the 2002 lineup, which paired Matsui with Kiyohara, drew the most “this is the best” votes, while commenters said the lineup lost its “special feeling” starting around 2013, when Shuichi Murata, Jose Lopez, and John Bowker were in the mix. Comparing those glory years to the current 2026 lineup, posters also disagreed over whether Hayato Sakamoto counts as a star and why the Giants can no longer land big-name free agents.

    1AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:02
    My beloved Giants — their starting lineup these days is a genuinely pitiful sight.
    I'm going to post the lineup year by year starting from 1996, when I first became old enough to watch baseball.
    7AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:05
    1999
    1 (2B) Toshihisa Nishi
    2 (LF) Takayuki Shimizu
    3 (CF) Hideki Matsui
    4 (1B) Kazuhiro Kiyohara
    5 (RF) Yoshinobu Takahashi
    6 (3B) Daisuke Motoki
    7 (SS) Tomohiro Nioka
    8 (C) Shin-ichi Murata
    9 (P) Koji Uehara
    45AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:18
    Re: #7
    Yeah, 1999 really is the one
    14AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:07
    2002
    1 (LF) Takayuki Shimizu
    2 (SS) Tomohiro Nioka
    3 (RF) Yoshinobu Takahashi
    4 (CF) Hideki Matsui
    5 (1B) Kazuhiro Kiyohara
    6 (3B) Satoshi Eto
    7 (2B) Toshihisa Nishi
    8 (C) Shinnosuke Abe
    9 (P) Koji Uehara

    By the way, this is my favorite Giants team ever
    81AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:34
    Re: #14
    Yeah, this is the best one, hands down, after watching for 30 years
    Sad to think it's already 24 years ago though
    83AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:37
    Re: #14
    The Daiei Hawks had a stacked lineup back then too, but the Giants were still stronger
    39AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:15
    2013
    1 (CF) Hisayoshi Chono
    2 (RF) Yoshiyuki Kamei
    3 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    4 (C) Shinnosuke Abe
    5 (3B) Shuichi Murata
    6 (1B) Jose Lopez
    7 (LF) John Bowker
    8 (2B) Takayuki Terauchi
    9 (P) Tomoyuki Sugano
    43AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:17
    Re: #39
    This is around where it stopped feeling special
    49AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:20
    Re: #39
    Wait, Bowker was already 13 years ago?…
    68AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:30
    I didn't think this at the time, but after watching for 30 years…
    Re: #39
    Things really started going downhill once Abe was forced into the cleanup spot in 2013
    41AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:16
    2014
    1 (RF) Hisayoshi Chono
    2 (CF) Itaru Hashimoto
    3 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    4 (C) Shinnosuke Abe
    5 (LF) Anderson
    6 (3B) Shuichi Murata
    7 (1B) Jose Lopez
    8 (2B) Haruhisa Kataoka
    9 (P) Tomoyuki Sugano
    46AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:19
    Re: #41
    I liked Lesley (Anderson)
    Wonder if he could've done more if he weren't such a "Spelunker" type (Japanese baseball slang for an injury-prone player, from the old video game)
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:18
    2016
    1 (CF) Hisayoshi Chono
    2 (RF) Yoshiyuki Kamei
    3 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    4 (1B) Shinnosuke Abe
    5 (3B) Shuichi Murata
    6 (LF) Garrett
    7 (2B) Cruz
    8 (C) Seiji Kobayashi
    9 (P) Tomoyuki Sugano

    Start of the Yoshinobu Takahashi managerial era
    Brings back that feeling from back then of "he could still do it as a pinch hitter…"
    59AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:25
    Re: #44
    The previous year, the best pinch hitter on the team was Yoshinobu himself, with maybe Donki (nickname) or someone a distant second
    And on top of that, Ibata was gone too
    47AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:19
    2017
    1 (CF) Dai-Kang Yang
    2 (2B) Magee
    3 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    4 (1B) Shinnosuke Abe
    5 (3B) Shuichi Murata
    6 (LF) Yoshiyuki Kamei
    7 (RF) Hisayoshi Chono
    8 (C) Seiji Kobayashi
    9 (P) Tomoyuki Sugano
    82AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:37
    Re: #47
    Re: #57
    Looking at it point by point, this stretch isn't actually bad even after the decline had started
    55AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:23
    2021
    1 (LF) Seiya Matsubara
    2 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    3 (CF) Yoshihiro Maru
    4 (3B) Kazuma Okamoto
    5 (1B) Wheeler
    6 (RF) Takayuki Kajitani
    7 (C) Takumi Oshiro
    8 (2B) Naoki Yoshikawa
    9 (P) Yuki Takahashi
    58AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:25
    Re: #55
    That's pretty rough
    57AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:24
    2022
    1 (2B) Naoki Yoshikawa
    2 (SS) Hayato Sakamoto
    3 (CF) Yoshihiro Maru
    4 (3B) Kazuma Okamoto
    5 (1B) Sho Nakata
    6 (RF) Polanco
    7 (LF) Walker
    8 (C) Takumi Oshiro
    9 (P) Shosei Togo
    63AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:27
    2026
    1 (LF) Cabbage
    2 (CF) Tsuyoshi Matsumoto
    3 (SS) Yuta Izumiguchi
    4 (1B) Dalbec
    5 (C) Yukinori Kishida
    6 (RF) Raito Nakayama
    7 (3B) Hayato Sakamoto
    8 (2B) Shunsuke Urata
    9 (P) Kazuyuki Takemaru

    No matter how many times I look at it, this year really is the worst
    66AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:29
    Re: #63
    Still impressive they stayed in first-place contention with the "star-studded" Hanshin Tigers until September with this lineup
    65AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:28
    Why couldn't Sakamoto become a star?
    70AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:30
    Re: #65
    He's obviously a superstar
    74AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:31
    Re: #70
    I barely ever see him in commercials though
    78AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:32
    Re: #70
    If you haven't gone to the majors, you're not a "star"
    Not in this day and age, anyway
    67AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:29
    Will the Giants ever produce another core player?
    If they don't get another Sakamoto- or Okamoto-caliber talent, the team is finished
    73AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:31
    Re: #67
    Well, over a span of decades, every team eventually produces a monster talent
    75AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:31
    Is finishing 2nd really that impressive?
    Even a Hanshin team that was all foreigners except Toriya, or one leaning on MLB returnees and imports, managed that before
    79AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:33
    Re: #75
    Please, lay off the Chunichi Dragons
    77AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:32
    Re: #73
    Is there anyone who looks like they could become that guy?
    Guys like Asano or Ishizuka don't seem capable of it, right?
    80AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:33
    Re: #77
    That includes players who aren't even born yet, you know
    We're talking about a span of decades here
    91AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:49
    It's funny how everyone overlooks that the Giants never ran out of homegrown, high-school-draft franchise players
    Though I guess poaching stars from other teams makes a bigger impression
    93AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:50
    Re: #91
    If Asano or Ishizuka actually develop properly, they'll get their due credit
    Though it's probably not happening
    97AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:54
    Foreign players are a lot tougher to land than they used to be, too
    Someone like Dalbec doesn't hold a candle to Ramirez
    100AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:56
    Re: #97
    They actually have a pretty good hit rate scouting their own imports
    Not many NPB teams can match the Giants when it comes to homegrown-scouted foreign players
    101AnonymousSep 5, 2026 14:56
    Maru was the last big free-agent signing, wasn't he
    Poaching a player of that caliber again seems impossible now
    Everyone just heads to the majors instead
    106AnonymousSep 5, 2026 15:01
    Re: #101
    When it comes to money, SoftBank is on another level now
    108AnonymousSep 5, 2026 15:03
    Re: #101
    Even if they miss out on someone like Kondo, they still land guys like Moritomo and Yamakawa — it's not that the Giants have declined, it's just that their old-time pull doesn't reach as far anymore and they keep getting beaten to the punch
    110AnonymousSep 5, 2026 15:05
    Re: #74
    Come to think of it, did Hideki Matsui — a bona fide superstar — even appear in commercials?
    112AnonymousSep 5, 2026 15:07
    Re: #110
    Yeah, he was in tons of them

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    The Giants earned their reputation as a “star-studded team” largely thanks to the roster from the late 1990s through the early 2000s, when free agency let them sign top players away from other clubs — Kazuhiro Kiyohara from the Seibu Lions, Satoshi Eto from the Hiroshima Carp — while also fielding homegrown franchise names like Hideki Matsui and Yoshinobu Takahashi. The turning point the thread identifies is around 2013, which coincides with the aging of that core, a growing trend of Japanese stars heading straight to MLB, and the rise of deep-pocketed rivals like SoftBank in the bidding war for top free agents. Opinions split over whether Hayato Sakamoto counts as a “star”: some point to his lack of media and commercial appearances, while others argue his on-field record alone makes him a clear superstar — a subjective debate that the facts cited in the thread (his commercial history, the fact he never went to MLB) don’t really settle either way. It’s also worth noting that some posters attribute the fading “pull” behind the Giants’ big free-agent signings not to the Giants’ own decline, but to rival clubs getting stronger — so this isn’t simply a one-sided knock on the team.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “When Did the Giants Stop Being a Star-Studded Team?.”

  • Munetaka Murakami’s Strikeout Rate Nears 40% ‘Danger Zone’… U.S. Media Calls His Numbers ‘Dismal’

    White Sox infielder Munetaka Murakami (26) can’t seem to shake his slump. In the game against the Astros on the 3rd (4th in Japan time), he went 0-for-4 with three strikeouts, dropping his batting average to .213. He hasn’t homered since his 29th on August 18. U.S. outlet the Chicago Sun-Times reported that his strikeout rate since August 1 has hit 38.4%, calling it a “danger zone.” On 5channel, opinions split between those defending him as “above average” thanks to his high OPS, and those alarmed by his sinking average and rising strikeout rate.

    [MLB] Munetaka Murakami’s strikeout rate is alarming… nearing a 40% “danger zone,” U.S. media calls it “a dismal performance”

    White Sox infielder Munetaka Murakami’s (26) sky-high strikeout rate is drawing attention. With the team chasing a division title, he still can’t climb out of his slump — going 0-for-4 with three strikeouts on the road against the Astros on the 3rd (4th Japan time). He hasn’t homered since his 29th on August 18 (19th Japan time), and his batting average has sunk to .213.

    What’s most concerning is the strikeout rate: U.S. outlet the Chicago Sun-Times reported that “Murakami’s strikeout rate since August 1 stands at 38.4%,” calling it a “danger zone.”

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:22
    Everyone knew this would happen before the team even signed him.
    4AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:23
    Looks like we've got another washed-up case (owakon) right here.
    6AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:23
    Baseball (yakyuu) is collapsing fast, lol

    Nothing but bad news for baseball fanboys (yakibuta) all year — nonstop frustration.
    8AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:24
    That's exactly why no team but the White Sox even wanted him…
    15AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:26
    Baseball is completely done, lmao, finally down to zero stars lol lol

    Soccer's got Zion, basketball's got Hachimura — total victory.
    51AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:40
    Re: #15
    The soccer players are riding the bench in Europe.
    16AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:26
    Batting average .211 (.171 with runners in scoring position)
    20AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:27
    A .213 average is no joke — that's cut-from-the-team territory even if you hit 50 homers.
    24AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:28
    Pulling a muscle after running 20 meters? That's just what happens when you're out of shape.
    29AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:29
    Are Japanese position players cratering right along with Ohtani's decline? Man, they flipped on him fast over there.
    31AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:29
    Baseball is garbage (yakyuunko), totally washed up

    NHK shouldn't be paying MLB for broadcast rights.
    33AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:30
    Strikeouts don't matter as long as OPS is high. Not striking out is pointless if you're just gonna be like Yoshida.
    37AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:34
    Re: #33
    His OPS in August was .683. September's barely started and it's already .349. "Doesn't matter as long as it's high" — nobody with normal sense could say that looking at this disaster, lol.
    34AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:30
    Baseball's such a small world globally, and he still can't cut it?

    MLB 2025 Opening Day roster by country:
    1st: Dominican Republic (100), 2nd: Venezuela (63), 3rd: Cuba (26), 4th: Puerto Rico (16), 5th: Canada (13), 6th: Japan (12), 7th: Mexico (11), 8th: Curaçao (4), 9th: Panama (4), 10th: South Korea (3)
    35AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:31
    Fine, trade the strikeouts for more grounders to second — doesn't help much either way, since you'd get some productive outs but also double plays.
    38AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:35
    So he just hadn't been scouted properly until now? His average is just too awful.
    40AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:35
    Pitchers already figured him out ages ago — the shine's completely worn off.
    41AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:36
    Really goes to show how amazing Ohtani is, putting up results year after year.
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:36
    People say three years in the league makes you legit, but who's really done that besides Ohtani, Yamamoto, and Seiya? Considering how everyone's aiming for the majors these days, isn't the quality and quantity way too thin?
    55AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:42
    And to think, back in Japan they used to call this guy a god.
    57AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:43
    Re: #55
    Only a handful of Yakult fans ever called him that.
    66AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:48
    Even at the WBC he barely got a hit at the end and struck out constantly. That Triple Crown year was just a one-off hot streak (kakuhen).
    68AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:50
    Re: #66
    Even that year, he cooled off after hitting his 56th homer.
    76AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:53
    Re: #66
    Sure, call the Triple Crown year a hot streak (kakuhen), but he was still top-tier in NPB the other years too, so it's not like he's a one-year wonder. And 29 home runs in his MLB rookie season is plenty impressive on its own.
    69AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:51
    Teams with real World Series hopes can't really afford to roster him, huh.
    70AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:53
    Wait, isn't America supposed to not care about strikeouts as long as you hit home runs? …Huh?
    78AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:54
    Re: #70
    No way that's true. His average is low, and his RBI total is low too.
    84AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:56
    Re: #70
    That's just some sabermetrics nerds going "who cares about a low average or a high strikeout rate!!!"

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    Munetaka Murakami won NPB’s youngest-ever Triple Crown with the Yakult Swallows in 2022, and moved to the White Sox — the only team that pursued him — via the posting system in the 2025 offseason. The thread’s split opinion centers on how to judge his high strikeout rate: some point to his OPS, which factors in on-base and slugging percentage, and argue his numbers are still above average, while others take a harsher view given his batting average has plunged since August and his strikeout rate has worsened to 38.4%. The gap between his hot streaks and cold streaks seems to be what’s driving the disagreement. His 29 home runs as a rookie are genuinely solid on their own, and how people weigh his current slump against his past track record is a key factor shaping reactions — something worth keeping in mind, since the article alone doesn’t fully convey it.

    *This article is compiled and summarized from the 5channel (Geinou/Sports Express+) thread “[MLB] Munetaka Murakami’s Strikeout Rate Is Alarming… Nearing a 40% ‘Danger Zone,’ U.S. Media Calls It a ‘Dismal’ Performance.”

  • Dark clouds over Ohtani’s bid for 4th straight MVP — 5ch: “Even in a slump, he’s a monster just for being a candidate”

    An article by U.S. media pointing to trouble ahead for Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani’s bid for a fourth consecutive MVP award became a hot topic on 5ch. Ohtani has been unable to pitch for roughly two months, and his hitting also slumped in August, while his biggest rival is closing in fast. If he pulls it off, it would be only the second such feat in history since Barry Bonds. The thread split between skeptics saying “maybe the two-way act has hit its limit” and defenders arguing “just being a candidate in an off year makes him a monster,” with the discussion spreading into rival comparisons and historical MVP records.

    Is Shohei Ohtani’s bid for a 4th straight MVP in trouble? The staggering gap with his rival that U.S. media points to

    Los Angeles Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani is chasing what would be only the second four-consecutive-year MVP run in MLB history, but that possibility is starting to look shaky. He hasn’t taken the mound in roughly two months, and while his hitting has also cooled off in August, his biggest rival is surging. The claim comes from reporter Zach Heiny of the U.S. outlet Dodgers Beat.

    Ohtani won MVP in 2023 with the Los Angeles Angels and in each of the following two years with the Dodgers; winning again this season would put him alongside Barry Bonds with four straight. He was widely seen as the frontrunner for most of the season, but the situation has shifted recently.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    8AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:14
    Am I the only one who thinks it's amazing he shows up in the MVP conversation every single year?
    For every other player, the list of contenders changes year to year.
    52AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:26
    Re: #8
    Just you.
    Everyone on Geisupo (the sports gossip board) hates Ohtani anyway.
    12AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:16
    NHK was so relentless with the Ohtani coverage that this amount of attention actually feels about right now.
    13AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:16
    The two-way player's premium reputation might be over after this year.
    14AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:16
    Running out of steam in September? That's not pro-level.
    15AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:17
    Shohei Ohtani's two-way act is finished.
    16AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:17
    If he wins MVP looking like this, it's a complete fix.
    17AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:17
    Realistically speaking, three years in a row alone is already an insane feat.
    19AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    Forget pitching, the guy's not even making the starting lineup at this point.
    20AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    I can never quite remember the full official name of the MVP award.
    21AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    Wait, he's in the middle of a 3-year streak?
    He needs to promote that more, because nobody knows.
    22AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    He's big for a Japanese guy, so it'll be rough once his body starts breaking down.
    24AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    Maybe he's got a shot if he hands out his signature luxury watches again.
    25AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    This year he's not even standout as a hitter, and he's missed way too much time as a pitcher.
    26AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:18
    He peaked in March for the WBC (World Baseball Classic), and then got knocked out early in the quarterfinals on top of it.
    32AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:20
    Re: #26
    PCA played all the way to the end of the tournament for Team USA, though.
    27AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:19
    Isn't this a case of "chase two rabbits, catch neither"?
    35AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:21
    Turning into a bad investment at 32 is bad news.
    Not living up to the contract money.
    62AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:34
    Re: #35
    He's clearly declining as a male athlete.
    That's exactly where Ohtani is right now.
    36AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:21
    Rui Hachimura, who's even bigger than Ohtani, hasn't had any major injuries despite basketball being way more physically demanding than baseball, yet Ohtani…
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:23
    >"Aiming to become only the second player in MLB history with 4 straight MVPs, but that chance is fading"

    This is the first time he's had such a clearly bad season.
    84AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:54
    Re: #44
    Ohtani having a bad season?
    There was that COVID year, remember.
    46AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:24
    When he can't finish #1 in home runs, they can just cook up some made-up stat like "home runs plus steals combined" to put him at #1 anyway.
    87AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:55
    Re: #46
    Last year too he was right on the edge of winning the home run title, but he didn't care and just rested up since the postseason was coming.
    49AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:24
    I figured this season's slump meant MVP talk wouldn't even come up…
    but turns out he's still a real candidate, lol. Ohtani really is a monster.
    71AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:40
    Re: #49
    He crashed hard in August.
    Up through August he was still in the running.
    But even though he's technically "in it" now, it's just like Lindor two years ago or Schwarber last year — not really a real contest anymore.
    56AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:28
    Guess when it comes to parenting he's just a normal guy after all.
    Behind that otherworldly two-way performance, having two babies at home — yeah, that'll wear you out.
    61AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:32
    Re: #56
    Guess he was really running a "three-way" act this whole time (pitcher, hitter, and dad).
    64AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:36
    Unlike some guy just racking up WAR by being a two-way player,
    PCA is doing it all with his bat alone.
    65AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:39
    Re: #64
    PCA gets credit for his center-field defense too, you know.
    66AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:39
    Re: #64
    He made another incredible defensive play again today.
    80AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:47
    Winning MVP four times alone is already more than enough.
    89AnonymousSep 5, 2026 13:02
    Re: #80
    That's exactly the thing —
    take the steroids out of the picture and he's number one all-time.
    82AnonymousSep 5, 2026 12:49
    But Ohtani is still the only member of the 50-50 club, so……

    Background and key points of this discussion

    The four-consecutive-year MVP streak Ohtani is chasing would match the run Barry Bonds achieved from 2001 to 2004 — an era when Bonds was piling up home runs but was also dogged by steroid-use allegations. The jabs about historical records that come up in the thread only land if you know that context. “PCA,” named as a rival, is never explained and may be confusing to first-time readers, but appears to refer to a player who’s also praised for his center-field defense. Ohtani also underwent elbow surgery in 2023, and since returning to pitching his rest between starts and pitch counts have been carefully managed, so this roughly two-month absence could be seen as an extension of that caution — though the thread doesn’t mention this. It’s also worth noting that the original article doesn’t spell out that MVP voting by the BBWAA weighs team performance alongside individual stats, a nuance that tends to get lost when the debate boils down to raw numbers.

    ※This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Geisupo Sokuho+) thread “[MLB] Is Shohei Ohtani’s bid for a 4th straight MVP in trouble? The staggering gap with his rival that U.S. media points to.”

  • Shohei Ohtani’s Pitching Comeback This Season All But Dead — 5ch: ‘If He Were My Favorite Player, This Wouldn’t Fly’

    With Dodgers star Shohei Ohtani held out of the starting lineup for a second straight game, manager Dave Roberts told reporters before the game that there’s no structural damage in Ohtani’s right upper arm, but that his return to pitching will be pushed back further than originally planned — making a pitching comeback this season effectively hopeless. On 5ch’s Nanademo Jikkyou G board, reactions split sharply: some worried he isn’t living up to his massive contract, others defended him by pointing out his batting numbers remain elite even as a DH-only player, and still others questioned whether the “two-way player” label even applies to him anymore.

    Dodgers manager Dave Roberts addressed pitcher Shohei Ohtani’s absence from the starting lineup for a second consecutive game before the match. He revealed there is no damage in Ohtani’s right upper arm, but said his pitching return would be delayed. A pitching comeback this season is now considered hopeless.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    6AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:21
    There's still 7 years and ¥70 billion left on this deal and he's already falling apart lol
    70AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:43
    Re: #6
    They already got their ¥100 billion worth ages ago
    The next 7 years are basically him volunteering
    7AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:21
    Well if all he has to focus on now is hitting, his batting should bounce back
    9AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:21
    Can't hit (well, he can), never played defense, can't run, can't pitch
    32 years old
    DH only
    7 years left on the contract

    Sorry but… did we just witness the birth of a death-row inmate?
    16AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:23
    Re: #9
    But 'Big Timee Shohei' still tosses a pitch every once in a while and gives us our dose of inspiration porn (Timee = a Japanese app for one-off, single-shift gig work — i.e., he 'gig-works' as a pitcher now)
    43AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:30
    Re: #9
    If this were a foreign player I actually rooted for, I'd be losing my mind right now
    18AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:24
    If pitching's off the table, his motivation's probably tanking hard
    Wouldn't be surprised if he just fades out from here
    27AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:26
    Re: #18
    Given his personality you can just tell he's sulking
    Like he's thinking, 'Coach, I want to pitch too, get showered with praise, and rake in tons of cash'
    19AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:24
    Re: #7
    He's been DH-only for almost 3 months now
    If anything his numbers keep getting worse
    21AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:25
    Re: #19
    Even with his numbers 'declining' he's still 3rd in OPS — that's monstrous
    Do you have any idea how insane 1st place is?
    Get 1st twice and you're basically a Hall of Famer
    28AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:26
    Re: #21
    Ugh…
    Once people start comparing him downward like this, it really starts to feel like he's washed up
    50AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    Re: #21
    Never heard of that weird rule
    What do you even think the Hall of Fame is
    22AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:25
    Normal players: hit and play defense
    Ohtani: hits, skips defense, pitches instead

    Why is this even called 'two-way' in the first place?
    By that logic every batting pitcher in the Central League is a two-way player
    31AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:27
    Re: #22
    That's an insult to Central League pitchers who go through a full season in the rotation
    30AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:27
    Forget two-way player, is he even reliable as a position player at this point?
    33AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:28
    Re: #30
    He's not a position player, he's a hitter
    34AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:28
    Re: #30
    A DH-only guy isn't a position player, he's a hitter
    44AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    Seriously, start practicing outfield defense already
    47AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    Re: #44
    His knees are shot, outfield's not happening
    48AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    Re: #44
    You think he could ever pull off a basket catch like Ichiro?
    45AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    Bet they'll wheel out the dog again as a cute prop to boost his likability
    52AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:32
    Re: #45
    Lol, I can picture it already
    46AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:31
    If you told him to pick just one, he'd probably drop hitting
    54AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:33
    Re: #46
    Pitching was his original dream anyway, and as a hitter he's pretty much already accomplished everything
    Given how off-the-charts his talent is though, people around him probably wish he'd just focus on hitting
    56AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:35
    Wasn't he injury-prone like this back in his early Angels days too?
    He just wasn't getting this much attention back then
    62AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:39
    Re: #56
    $700 million doesn't come for nothing
    57AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:35
    The guy wins 8 games as a starter AND hits 30 home runs on the side, and still gets ripped apart
    82AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:51
    Re: #57
    Lol, didn't you people say pitcher wins are a meaningless stat
    61AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:38
    And here's the stat line the scum of the earth are trashing him for
    63AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:39
    Re: #61
    For someone supposedly bad in the clutch, he's racking up plenty of RBIs
    65AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:41
    Re: #61
    That RBI total while batting leadoff is insane, no?
    64AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:40
    Even by his own standard, 2022 was his career year as a pitcher and he still didn't win MVP, so there's probably zero motivation left for pitching
    Even Skenes wasn't in the running last year — pitching just doesn't carry the value anymore
    67AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:42
    Re: #64
    Back in his AL days, even when he pitched he basically always lost out to Judge
    The only season Ohtani won MVP was the one where Judge got hurt and missed a long stretch
    72AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:45
    Re: #64
    However you look at it, he's clearly always wanted to pitch, pitch, pitch
    74AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:46
    Re: #70
    They're using that money to sign other big-name players, so it's not that simple
    84AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:53
    Re: #74
    That's a separate issue though
    87AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:57
    I keep thinking he should just be a full-time closer
    Guess Ohtani just doesn't want to do anything but start
    89AnonymousSep 5, 2026 09:59
    Re: #87
    A reliever with his caliber of talent being wasted on relief work? Not needed one bit
    99AnonymousSep 5, 2026 10:07
    Re: #87
    It's not that he doesn't want to, it's that he can't

    Background and Key Points of the Debate

    Ohtani’s contract with the Dodgers, signed in 2023, is a 10-year, $700 million deal (worth over ¥100 billion at the exchange rate at the time), most of which is deferred. The mismatched figures of “¥70 billion” and “¥100 billion” tossed around in the thread stem from the complexity of this deferred-money structure. The central debate was how to value Ohtani as a hitter now that a pitching comeback looks hopeless — some defended him by pointing to his top-tier OPS, others objected to the “two-way player” label itself, and others worried his motivation is slipping based on talk of lateness or attitude. Manager Roberts’ press conference stressed there is no structural damage to the upper arm, so this is easily misread as a serious injury when it’s really more a matter of usage and conditioning. Note that the claim he has been “showing up late” is unverified hearsay from the thread.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nanademo Jikkyou G) thread “[Bad News] Shohei Ohtani’s Two-Way Career Is Dead This Season WWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWWW“