Category: Baseball

  • SoftBank Chairman Sadaharu Oh Mourns Lifelong Rival Isao Harimoto: ‘Go to Heaven with Your Head Held High’

    In a thread on 5ch’s Geinou/Sports Breaking News+ board, comments spread after SoftBank chairman Sadaharu Oh (86) — born the same year as Isao Harimoto and a fellow rookie from the same draft class — offered a tribute following Harimoto’s death on September 9, saying he hoped Harimoto could “go to heaven with his head held high.” Oh and Harimoto were lifelong friends who, after Harimoto’s 1976 transfer to the Yomiuri Giants, formed the famous “OH Cannon” batting duo and helped power the Giants to their first championship under manager Shigeo Nagashima. On the thread, some users found the phrase “with his head held high” an odd choice of words for a tribute, while others reminisced about Harimoto’s playing days and shared updates on Chairman Oh’s current health.

    Thu, 9/10, 2:36 PM

    SoftBank chairman Sadaharu Oh (86) mourned the sudden loss of his old friend Isao Harimoto, who passed away on September 9, in comments made on the 10th.

    Both were born in 1940 and turned pro the same year, in 1959. In 1976, Harimoto transferred from the Nippon-Ham Fighters to the Yomiuri Giants, where he and Oh formed the famed “OH Cannon” batting duo, hitting .355 with 22 home runs and 93 RBIs that season. He contributed to manager Shigeo Nagashima’s first championship that same year. The following season, in 1977, he posted a .348 average with 24 home runs and 82 RBIs, driving the team to another league title.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:01
    No way he's going to heaven lol
    80AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:19
    Re: #3
    There's no heaven or hell. You just become nothing.
    7AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:03
    Can you really get into heaven by sneaking in with your head down??
    10AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:07
    Something about that phrasing rubs me the wrong way.
    52AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:04
    Re: #10
    'With your head held high' sounds like something you'd say to encourage someone who's been badmouthed by people, doesn't it?
    12AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:08
    Surprising that with such a dominant all-time hit record, he only led the league in hits 3 times.
    Lower than I'd have guessed.
    13AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:08
    I wonder if Harimoto even believed in heaven?
    If he didn't, then please don't send him somewhere he'd have hated.
    17AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:11
    Honestly, I never expected Oh himself to live this long.
    Glad to see he's doing well.
    26AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:19
    Re: #17
    When he came back as manager after having his entire stomach removed for cancer, you'd often see him looking unwell, probably from food getting stuck in his esophagus.

    There was even an away game at Chiba Marine Stadium where his face suddenly turned ashen mid-game and he retreated to the back of the dugout and never came back — the head coach had to step in as acting manager.

    He ended up resigning as manager that same offseason and moved into a front-office role.

    Looking back on that, it's amazing how well he's doing now.
    19AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:12
    The way he phrased it makes it sound like Harimoto had something to feel guilty about.
    21AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:13
    Guess the general public doesn't picture him as someone who could 'hold his head high.'
    23AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:15
    > Sadly he's been called to heaven, but I hope he can go there with his head held high (Re: #1)
    Wait, was Harimoto even Christian?
    27AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:20
    Both Oh and Harimoto faced a lot of discrimination back in their day and share that common hardship, so I think there's a real bond between them.
    28AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:20
    How do we even know he's going to heaven?
    Not after mocking people the way he did.
    29AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:20
    Chairman Oh's still walking around fine on his own and sharp as ever — he even shows up to the draft meetings. Guy looks like he'll live to 100.
    31AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:21
    Guess it's pretty easy to get into heaven.
    67AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:36
    Re: #31
    As the saying goes, 'even a wicked man attains salvation — never mind a good one' (a sarcastic twist on the famous Buddhist teaching about salvation)
    32AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:22
    'With your head held high' feels a little off lol.
    Not really a phrase you'd normally use about someone who's passed away.
    40AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:37
    Re: #32
    During the 'Monaoka' scandal, Oh reportedly said something off-topic like 'What about the ¥9,800 hotel?' — he has a habit of dropping slightly odd comments sometimes.
    33AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:24
    Wish Harry (Harimoto's nickname) could've retired as a Giant — why did the Giants ever let him go?
    34AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:24
    > I hope he can go to heaven with his head held high

    Did he do something lol
    35AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:26
    I figured he only joined the Giants once he was already a veteran past his prime, but that batting average is insane!
    36AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:28
    That's the kind of thing you'd say about someone who caused a scandal.
    42AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:44
    Good timing for Oh moving over to Daiei — now he's chairman of a perennial championship franchise.
    77AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:09
    Re: #42
    Apparently it took some courage to leave the Yomiuri Group.
    Glad the Son family (Masayoshi Son, SoftBank's founder) has taken good care of him.
    59AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:25
    This was a slip of the tongue from Oh, right?
    'With his head held high'??? …Makes no sense.
    84AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:25
    Re: #59
    Isn't it just meant like 'with pride for the incredible records he left behind'?
    Oh's word choices are sometimes a bit '?' but it's nothing to worry about.
    More importantly, can someone post that photo of Harimoto leaping for joy behind Oh right after he hit his 756th home run?
    76AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:03
    https://imgur.com/a/9LzKZKl

    That reminded me of this incident —
    this was also a case where a Carp fan charged at Oh and Harimoto stepped in to protect him.
    Oh was probably grateful for that too.
    79AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:18
    Re: #76
    What a wild era that was lol

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    Isao Harimoto holds the all-time NPB record with 3,085 career hits. After transferring from the Nippon-Ham Fighters to the Yomiuri Giants in 1976, he and Chairman Oh formed the famous “OH Cannon” duo and helped power the team to league championships. The phrase that sparked discussion here — “I hope he can go to heaven with his head held high” — split the thread between users who felt it sounded like it implied Harimoto had something to be ashamed of, and those who read it more charitably as a tribute to his record-breaking career. Harimoto’s post-retirement years were also marked by controversies, including a reported dispute with a taxi driver, and some of that past coverage seems to have colored how people read into Oh’s choice of words this time. Meanwhile, longtime fans also expressed renewed surprise and respect that Chairman Oh remains active as team chairman despite having battled stomach cancer in the past.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports Breaking News+) thread “SoftBank Chairman Sadaharu Oh: ‘I Hope He Can Go to Heaven with His Head Held High’ — Mourning Lifelong Friend and Classmate Isao Harimoto.”

  • Who’s the Best Defensive Shortstop in NPB History? 5ch Says Makoto Kosaka Tops the Defensive Rankings

    The question “Who’s the best defensive shortstop in NPB history?” sparked a lively debate on the Nandemo Jikkyo board (a general live-discussion board on 5ch). Someone posted aggregated shortstop defensive stats spanning 1950 to 2020, showing Makoto Kosaka atop the all-time defensive runs rankings, while others pointed out that Yasumitsu Toyoda comes out on top once multiple metrics are combined. Among active players, opinions split over whether Saitama Seibu’s Sosuke Genda or Shuhei Takizawa is better, and names like Hayato Sakamoto and Kazuo Matsui also came up, turning the thread into a debate spanning legendary greats and current stars alike.

    1AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:17
    Is it gonna be Takashi Toritani?
    15AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:21
    Takizawa's better than Kosaka
    20AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:23
    Re: #15
    No way.
    Even now he's only slightly better than current Genda.
    If that's the case, peak Genda would still be better.
    17AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:22
    If we're talking current players, isn't Takizawa the most amazing?
    19AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:23
    Re: #17
    Doubt it — probably nobody does.
    25AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:27
    Re: #17
    Genda's still better even now though
    23AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:26
    Career Shortstop Defensive Stats [1950-2020]
    Defensive runs per 1000 innings shown alongside. "Est. Inn" = estimated defensive innings.
    Rank Player Runs /1000 Est.Inn Years Active Basic Fielding Stats Fielding% Est.RF
    1st Makoto Kosaka 221.7 22.9 9677 innings 13 yrs 1997-2010 1901 PO 3756 A *93 E .984 5.26
    2nd Kenji Koike 174.8 15.0 11621 innings 14 yrs 1961-1974 2527 PO 4107 A 230 E .966 5.14
    3rd Hayato Sakamoto 168.6 11.0 15257 innings 14 yrs 2007-2020 2687 PO 5419 A 173 E .979 4.78
    4th Yoshio Yoshida 151.6 10.4 14578 innings 17 yrs 1953-1969 2969 PO 5242 A 327 E .962 5.07
    5th Chusuke Kizuka 144.5 18.6 7760 innings 10 yrs
    40AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:32
    Re: #23
    Sakamoto ranks this high on defense alone?
    Guess that settles it — Sakamoto's the greatest shortstop ever then.
    I thought it'd be Matsui.
    54AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:36
    Re: #40
    Yeah, I thought it'd be Matsui too.
    59AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:38
    Re: #40
    For reference, Yasumitsu Toyoda is #1 overall on the combined shortstop metrics.
    30AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:28
    Re: #25
    He's not actually that good — he just racked up a ton of innings.
    36AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:31
    Re: #30
    Were you on a baseball team, by any chance?
    32AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:30
    Oh sorry, this is about shortstops.
    For second base, Kanya Tanaka is way ahead of everyone else, right?
    33AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:31
    Re: #32
    He's way behind Ogawa though
    34AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:31
    Re: #32
    Maybe Morimichi Takagi
    38AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:32
    Re: #32
    Isn't it Ryosuke Kikuchi?
    39AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:32
    Re: #36
    I played through college
    44AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:33
    Re: #39
    Well then, I can't really argue with that.
    43AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:32
    Wasn't Kosaka's arm weak though?
    46AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:34
    Re: #43
    How do I put it… I remember his throws being kind of shaky.
    48AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:34
    Re: #43
    His arm was strong — it was more his control that was off.
    61AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:38
    Among current players, Lotte's Tomosugi also gets by on defense alone.
    64AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:40
    Re: #61
    He's too frail — won't even last a full season.
    62AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:39
    Re: #59
    What metric are you using?
    71AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:42
    Re: #62
    WAR and RC Win
    70AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:42
    I think Orix's Sou has the strongest infield arm in NPB right now.
    74AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:43
    Re: #70
    Why are Sou's throws so clean?
    77AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:44
    Re: #70
    Guess that's why he's got an S-rank arm stat in Power Pros lol (the baseball video game's player-rating system)
    83AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:51
    If foreign players count, it's gotta be the Tigers' Arias.
    92AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:59
    Re: #83
    Wasn't he a first baseman?
    91AnonymousSep 10, 2026 17:58
    I hear Kosaka's name a lot, but what about Matsui?
    94AnonymousSep 10, 2026 18:00
    Re: #91
    On defense alone, he's a step below Kosaka.
    102AnonymousSep 10, 2026 18:05
    No joke, it's gotta be the Carp's Yano.
    103AnonymousSep 10, 2026 18:06
    Re: #102
    He was amazing for a stretch, but it didn't last long.

    Background and Key Points of the Discussion

    There are several metrics for quantifying defensive skill, and both the “defensive runs” figure and the Range Factor (RF) posted in the thread can shift rankings depending on how they’re calculated. Evaluations of the same player can flip depending on which metric is used — in the thread itself, opinions diverged over whether Yasumitsu Toyoda or Hayato Sakamoto deserved the “best overall” spot. Defensive stats are also heavily shaped by innings played, meaning players who held the same position for a long time tend to rack up bigger cumulative numbers, which makes it hard to crown the best defender on career totals alone. In recent years metrics like UZR and DRS, which account for batted-ball direction, have come into use, but no such data exists for players from earlier eras, so cross-era comparisons need to be read with that caveat in mind.

    ※This article is compiled as an excerpt/summary of the 5ch (Nandemo Jikkyo G) thread “Who’s the best defensive shortstop in NPB history.”

  • Shohei Ohtani Lands on the IL for First Time in 3 Years — Manager Roberts: ‘We’ll Use the 15 Days to Reset His Body’

    Dodgers pitcher/DH Shohei Ohtani was placed on the injured list (IL) on the 9th (10th Japan time) — his first IL stint since September 2023. After striking out in four straight at-bats against the Cardinals on September 2nd, he sat out four games before returning to the lineup on the 7th, but his form still hadn’t come back, prompting manager Dave Roberts to explain that they wanted to “use these 15 days to reset his body once.” On 5channel threads, speculation ran wild over the cause of his slump this season and how he’ll be used going forward, with the discussion spilling over into debate about the future of his two-way career.

    <Dodgers 14-1 Reds> ◇September 9 (10th Japan time) ◇Dodger Stadium

    Dodgers pitcher Shohei Ohtani (32) is headed to the injured list (IL) for the first time since September 2023. Manager Dave Roberts revealed the news after the game, saying, “We’re putting Shohei on the IL. We want to use the 15 days to reset his body once and get his form back up.”

    In the September 2nd game against the Cardinals (3rd Japan time), he struck out in four straight at-bats starting from his third plate appearance. He then sat out the next four games in a row. He returned to the starting lineup on the 7th, but with no improvement in his form, he was placed on the IL.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    15AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:51
    Re: #1
    Go start a soccer thread instead.
    198AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:18
    Re: #15
    Tell that to Tetsu Chiizu Karasu (a notorious 5ch copypasta persona associated with sports-thread spam).
    18AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:51
    Isn't it his knee that's busted? He's done for the season, no?
    23AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:51
    I wonder if he can even train during his IL stint.
    Unless they come up with some countermeasure for AI and other pitch-prediction/scouting tools, he'll be useless even when he's back.
    And if he's pitching, it'll just be relief duty — mop-up duty in blowout losses, no less.
    What a humiliation.
    152AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:11
    Re: #23
    Yeah, he can.
    Diaz already pulled a mysteriously-timed IL stint to free up a pitcher's roster spot for the adjustment.
    24AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:52
    The haters kept saying 'he's not going on the IL, so he must be faking it,' remember?
    29AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:53
    Re: #24
    Your Japanese is so shaky it's hilarious lololololol
    26AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:52
    You'd think the pros would have his diet dialed in — is Ohtani seriously out of shape?
    Or is he hurt and just can't train?
    48AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:56
    Since they dragged their feet on this decision, his return's probably gonna be delayed too.
    68AnonymousSep 10, 2026 15:59
    Re: #48
    He should've taken a page from Snell's book. (fellow Dodgers pitcher Blake Snell)
    72AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:00
    Guess the Dodgers' winning streak is unstoppable now that Ohtani's on the IL. (sarcasm)
    80AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:01
    Re: #72
    That's probably just because they're only facing bottom-feeder teams for the rest of the regular season.
    76AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:00
    Roki's coming back soon, so I'll be rooting for him instead. (pitching prospect Roki Sasaki)
    84AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:01
    Re: #76
    Wasn't he already playing in games?
    90AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:02
    This season's been a letdown with both Ohtani and Judge struggling — never really got exciting.
    96AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:03
    Re: #90
    Guess it's a changing of the guard now that Ohtani and Judge are both done for.
    111AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:05
    Did you get up early? Go grab me the usual badger ochazuke, would you? (apparent off-topic copypasta)
    113AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:06
    Re: #111
    Oh, so now you've followed me into this thread too.
    112AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:05
    Going on the IL at this point in the season, he probably won't make it back in time for the postseason.
    That's likely the call they've made.
    It's a shame, but I guess we just have to let him rest the rest of this season, take his time healing, and pin our hopes on next year.
    115AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:06
    Re: #112
    Pinch-hitter duty at best, I'd guess.
    127AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:07
    If Ohtani's done, Japanese baseball's popularity is going to sink even further into irrelevance — is that really fine?
    157AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:12
    Re: #127
    There's still Murakami. (Munetaka Murakami)
    130AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:08
    Should've done this way sooner.
    He was clearly hurt — what was the point of leaving him batting leadoff?
    166AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:13
    Re: #130
    Obviously he's the one who turned it down, lol.
    185AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:17
    Re: #130
    Go ask the man himself.
    136AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:08
    Knew it — nothing good ever comes out of playing the WBC.
    Probably gonna be the same story with the Olympics.
    146AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:10
    Re: #136
    This definitely had an impact.
    This was supposed to be his real comeback year for the two-way thing, so he should've started slow and built up toward Opening Day.
    142AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:09
    That decision took forever, lol
    160AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:12
    Re: #142
    From a business standpoint too, benching your marquee player — who could still at least hit — for 15 days is a painful call.
    I bet it wasn't easy for them to pull the trigger.
    195AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:18
    Wasn't Misiorowski supposed to be the one who breaks down?
    205AnonymousSep 10, 2026 16:20
    Re: #195
    It's probably just a matter of time before he breaks down too, though — total deGrom trajectory.

    Background and Key Points of the Discussion

    In Major League Baseball, a trip to the injured list (IL) requires a minimum 15-day stint, letting a team pull an injured player off the active roster and bring in a replacement. As manager Roberts explained, Ohtani has been struggling lately — striking out in four straight at-bats on September 2nd, missing four games, and returning on the 7th only to still be off his game — so this looks less like a specific injury and more like an attempt to reset his form. On the threads, reactions ranged widely: criticism over why the team didn’t decide to rest him sooner, speculation that his participation in this year’s WBC may have played a role, and even arguments that he should give up on the two-way experiment and focus solely on hitting. There were also baseless posts insinuating drug use, which have been excluded from this article. One point worth clarifying, since it’s easy to misread: going on the IL doesn’t automatically mean his season is over — rather, it’s being framed as a tune-up at this late stage of the regular season, ahead of the postseason.

    ※This article is compiled as an excerpt and summary of the 5channel (Geinou/Sports Express+) thread ‘[Baseball] Shohei Ohtani placed on the injured list for the first time in 3 years, since September 2023 — Manager Roberts: ‘We’ll use the 15 days to reset his body once’‘.

  • Shohei Ohtani Could Land on the IL — Right Arm Trouble Flares Up Again During Swing

    Dodgers pitcher/DH Shohei Ohtani was left out of the starting lineup for the sixth time in seven games, raising the possibility that he could be placed on the injured list (IL). According to manager Dave Roberts, Ohtani felt discomfort in his right arm during swing practice on September 7, and the issue has lingered without fully healing. Because Ohtani is registered as a two-way player, an IL stint for him would require a longer 15-day absence than usual, leaving the club torn on how to proceed. On 5ch, opinions split between those urging him to rest and those questioning why Ohtani is so stubbornly refusing to go on the IL.

    Dodgers pitcher Shohei Ohtani (32) was left off the starting lineup for a second straight game — his sixth absence from the lineup in seven games.

    At his pre-game press conference, manager Dave Roberts revealed that Ohtani’s right arm isn’t in good shape. “During his swing on Monday [the 7th, local time], he felt discomfort. I heard about it last night. It turns out it hadn’t fully healed. We’re resting him today and will consult with the medical staff on how to proceed.”

    Asked whether that could include placing Ohtani on the injured list, Roberts said, “It’s a possibility. Since it would mean 15 days, we’d like to avoid it if we can, but doing what’s best for him is also what’s best for the team.”

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:33
    Getting injured just from swinging is insane.
    How fragile is this guy?
    6AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:33
    Apparently Ohtani's been doing full-power swing practice behind the bench during the game, by the way
    40AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:46
    Re: #6
    The media's probably gonna find some way to spin this into a heartwarming story too
    7AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:34
    This is starting to sound like something out of an old-timer's farewell tour
    11AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:34
    They just keep saying 'right arm, right arm' without ever naming the actual injury — this one's probably legit bad
    12AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:35
    They should've just put him on the IL right away instead of him trying to look tough about it
    13AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:35
    He won't rest even when told to rest, so there's really nothing the Dodgers can do about it
    14AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:35
    Told to rest, then goes and does an angry full-power swing session behind the bench
    15AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:36
    Can't be helped
    Guess we go get Satteru (nickname for Hanshin Tigers slugger Teruaki Sato) to fill the gap
    16AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:36
    Why is Ohtani so stubbornly refusing to go on the IL?
    He's way too desperate to play.
    He's not even hitting when he does play, so what is he even trying to prove, seriously
    24AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:39
    Re: #16
    Obviously it's for his own stats
    For the MVP
    61AnonymousSep 10, 2026 10:00
    Re: #16
    Normally the IL is 10 days, but for a two-way player it's 15 days
    That's why the team is hesitant to put him on it
    77AnonymousSep 10, 2026 10:18
    Re: #16
    If he goes on the IL, he's guaranteed to lose the home run race to Murakami or Okamoto
    Meaning he'd hand over the title of best hitter in Japan
    He hates that
    Having a player who can't play still take up a roster spot hurts the team
    But since his own numbers matter more to him than the team winning, he's refusing the IL
    17AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:36
    A horse that finishes the race unhurt is a great horse — take a page from Ichiro's book
    22AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:38
    Even if Roberts consults the medical staff, doesn't it not matter since Ohtani won't listen to anyone anyway? 🤔
    23AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:38
    A DH-only guy is an absolute nightmare to manage in situations like this
    25AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:39
    Didn't Dr. Yada ever teach him that?
    26AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:40
    Insisting on playing for a team that's basically running away with the division says it all, doesn't it
    If he were on a team locked in a tight pennant race, wanting to play could be about contributing to the team and all that, but…
    31AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:43
    Is there seriously nobody who can rein this guy in?
    42AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:48
    Honestly he should just step away from baseball for a while, sit out the postseason too, and come back fresh next year
    At this rate he's just going to be seen as a liability who won't stop trying to play…
    43AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:48
    Oh, so it was just an injury after all
    So as long as he's not hurt, he really is the strongest player in the world — phew, glad to hear it
    44AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:48
    Seriously, what is this guy even trying to do
    If he'd just quietly gone on the IL last month, he could've finished with respectable-looking stats
    46AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:50
    Injured from a swing lol
    Do some exercise that actually matches what your body can handle lol
    50AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:53
    His season's pretty much done, and that's fine
    He'll just win MVP again next year
    Yoshinobu Yamamoto will carry the Dodgers to a three-peat
    55AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:55
    Can't the team or manager just force him to rest in a case like this?
    If Ohtani throws a fit about wanting to play, are they obligated to let him?
    56AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:55
    Re: #55
    Ohtani's side has a clause in his contract letting him refuse
    81AnonymousSep 10, 2026 10:28
    Re: #55
    If they make him rest, he just goes and trains hard behind the bench during the game
    basically proving that resting him doesn't accomplish anything
    58AnonymousSep 10, 2026 09:57
    He's a stoic space case, so somebody needs to be the one to put a stop to this
    105AnonymousSep 10, 2026 10:57
    I think the damage from that 50-50 season is still catching up with him
    107AnonymousSep 10, 2026 11:00
    Re: #105
    50-50 isn't really that impressive a record anyway
    Anyone can steal bases, people just don't usually bother going for it
    So it's basically just 50 home runs
    106AnonymousSep 10, 2026 11:00
    He probably doesn't get any dopamine from anything besides baseball
    He's gonna be an empty shell once he retires

    Background and key points of this discussion

    The injured list (IL) normally requires a minimum 10-day stint, but a rule mandates at least 15 days for players registered as two-way (pitcher and position player), and that’s cited as one reason the club is finding this decision difficult. Ohtani reportedly has a contract clause preventing the team from placing him on the IL without his consent, and some replies in the thread touched on why the club can’t simply rest him unilaterally. With the postseason approaching, opinions were split between playing through the injury and taking a longer break to be ready, and the debate widened alongside criticism of his recent hitting slump. Note that replies implying Ohtani himself was somehow at fault in the Ippei Mizuhara illegal gambling case were excluded from this article, as those claims are not established fact.

    ※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Nanでも実況G) thread “[Sad News] Shohei Ohtani Could Land on the IL — Right Arm Injured Again During Swing“.

  • Emoto Takenori: “Teams with Losing Records Shouldn’t Make the Playoffs” — 5ch Divided Over His Baseball Reform Proposals

    Pro baseball commentator Takenori Emoto has put forward proposals to Nippon Professional Baseball on Climax Series (CS) playoff eligibility, the merits of the OPS stat, and the number of schools allowed into the Koshien tournament — and 5ch had plenty to say about it. His three claims — “teams with losing records shouldn’t make the CS,” “OPS is unnecessary, batting average/RBIs/home runs are enough,” and “cut the number of Koshien schools” — each split opinion down the middle, with some users calling for scrapping the CS altogether and others arguing Koshien should actually expand. The result was a single article that touched off several arguments running in parallel.

    ⟨Takenori Emoto’s Proposals for the Baseball World⟩ “Teams with Losing Records Shouldn’t Make the CS,” “OPS Isn’t Needed,” “Cut the Number of Koshien Schools” — What He Really Means

    It’s not just the pennant race — sharp-tongued commentator Takenori Emoto doesn’t miss a thing happening around the baseball world! Climax Series rule changes, the summer Koshien tournament, a flood of home runs from Japanese major leaguers… he cuts through all of August’s baseball news. ⟨Part 2 of 2⟩

    “The level of baseball is dropping, both in the pros and among high schoolers,” argues Takenori Emoto

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    2AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:39
    Isn't a pennant race with just 6 teams kind of ridiculous? The J.League has 60 clubs competing nationwide.
    4AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:41
    Re: #1
    You just can't keep up and find it a hassle, lol
    8AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:42
    How kind of you all from the era when guys were smoking behind the dugout — back when the competitive level was so low — to share your opinions
    9AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:44
    They could bump up the number of Koshien schools a bit. Actually, I'd love to see a couple of Taiwanese representative schools in there.
    12AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:44
    The CS shouldn't exist in the first place — it's just a 6-team league.
    14AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:45
    OPS is necessary — it tells you when a guy's trash if it's low.
    16AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:46
    Lol, the 3rd-place Yokohama team still hasn't climbed out of the red. The CS shouldn't be held at all, honestly. If they want to put on a show, just make it an exhibition series that doesn't carry a Japan Series berth.
    17AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:46
    I was thinking Emo-yan (Emoto's nickname) has turned into an old fogey, but then again he's been saying stuff like this since he was young — going on about how the dugout's full of idiots and whatnot.
    67AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:53
    Re: #17
    People don't just change because they get older. They only change if they turn conservative to protect their position, or if dementia sets in.
    18AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:47
    Re: #1
    >"We're here to watch insanely fast pitches and the power of hitters smashing them back."

    Then go to a batting cage.
    19AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:48
    Re: #18
    Apparently if you go every day, you end up with 70-something grannies smashing back 160 km/h pitches.
    22AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:50
    Just like Miyamoto (former player turned commentator), seriously, what's going on in the heads of people saying "expand the bench roster"? Teams can't even scrape together 9 players and you want to expand the bench… Shimizu of the Giants said the same thing, but at least he later corrected himself, admitting it would just give the powerhouse teams an even bigger edge.
    37AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:05
    Re: #22
    He probably thinks schools that can't even field 9 players should just fold. He's the type who won't feel any sense of crisis until numbers shrink down to rugby-team levels.
    23AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:51
    They should just bring back the old first-half/second-half split season. NPB never reforms nearly enough — all they do is copy America bit by bit under the excuse of "internationalization."
    24AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:53
    Koshien should be cut to either 32 or 64 schools.
    25AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:54
    The Central League is adopting the DH now too, so things are different from back when Central and Pacific split into two leagues.
    https://column.sp.baseball.findfriends.jp/?pid=column_detail&id=097-20171126-11
    They should scrap interleague play, since it's almost always Pacific League teams that come out on top, and maybe bring back the single-league system that hasn't existed since 1949.
    26AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:55
    You got any way to pay off that debt (losing record)? Just declare bankruptcy.
    28AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:59
    Bottom line: what baseball needs is to expand to 16 teams. Then combine with Korea's 10 and Taiwan's 6 to build a 32-team league. MLB's heading to 32 teams too, so match it. And compete.
    29AnonymousSep 10, 2026 00:59
    >"The teams that made it to the final 8 were properly trained, none of them were soft. If only schools like that got picked to represent their region, we wouldn't even be having this dumb debate about switching to 7 innings for heat countermeasures."

    So true, right?
    If you let it all concentrate into a handful of powerhouses, baseball would be finished in an instant — it'd become no different from any other sport.
    The baseball world fundamentally has no sense of crisis.
    30AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:00
    Japan's probably the only place still worshipping a meaningless stat like batting average. On-base percentage matters more.
    31AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:01
    Emoto: "OPS isn't needed"
    "…psst psst…(*´・ω・)(・ω・`*)…psst psst…"
    "Saying OPS isn't needed nowadays… right?"
    "This is why old folks…"
    "♫ Come on, let's update ourselves ♫"
    32AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:01
    Re: #1
    >"Apparently older fans have stopped showing up at MLB ballparks lately, and it's because all this data keeps cluttering everything up. 'That's not what we came to see. We came to see insanely fast pitches and the power of hitters smashing them back,' he says."

    Makes no sense.
    Does data showing up somehow stop you from watching insanely fast pitches and hitters smashing them back?
    33AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:01
    Add 4 more teams and reorganize into 4 divisions — 2 leagues, East and West, 4 teams each. 1st place gets an automatic CS berth, and the top 4 teams by winning percentage among the rest fill the remaining spots — 8 teams fighting it out in the CS. That's the kind of reform I'd want to see.
    34AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:02
    [Summer Koshien champions over the past 10 years]

    Kinki: 5 times
    Kanto: 2 times
    Okinawa: 1 time
    Tohoku: 1 time
    Cancelled due to COVID: 1 time

    The winners are pretty much always the same regions. Tokai, Kyushu, and Shikoku, once powerhouses, have declined.
    35AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:02
    >"The appeal of baseball isn't staring at spreadsheets."

    Is this a dig at Nomura (Katsuya Nomura, the data-driven former manager)?
    I wonder what Nomura actually thought about OPS.
    Wasn't it not really mainstream in Japan while he was still alive?
    36AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:04
    If it's just for the show, why not hold a knockout-style Emperor's Cup (soccer-style tournament) before the Japan Series? With interleague play, the Emperor's Cup, and the Japan Series, you'd get a nice balanced "domestic treble," just like in soccer.
    42AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:19
    Put the bottom teams into a promotion/relegation system. There's zero tension right now.
    45AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:22
    Re: #42
    Won't happen — the individual clubs hold more power than NPB itself.
    48AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:26
    Stuff like:
    – slugging percentage shouldn't factor into on-base percentage
    – reaching on a dropped third strike shouldn't count toward on-base percentage
    – if the pitcher's just wild and the batters before and after also draw walks/HBPs, that batter's on-base percentage should be voided

    …a stat like that would actually mean something. But OPS is just simple addition, so it can go past 100%. A "rate" stat that can exceed 100% doesn't mean anything. An OPS of 1.00 would mean being on base or hitting a homer 100% of the time, lol. Nobody in the history of any category anywhere has ever done that.
    50AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:30
    Re: #48
    OPS just happens to work well as a stat when you simply add the two together. That's exactly why calling it a "percentage" doesn't fit.
    61AnonymousSep 10, 2026 01:40
    Re: #48
    It's OBP + SLG, so hitting a home run once every 2 at-bats also gives you an OPS of 1.00.
    72AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:13
    Re: #48
    By that math OPS comes out to 2.50. Since you're adding two separate metrics — OBP and SLG — the resulting number has nothing to do with percentages anymore. A number like 2.50 doesn't mean 250%.
    77AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:24
    Re: #72
    Then it's even more of a meaningless, flawed stat. "0.90 is great, 1.00 is even greater, bigger number = greater" isn't a "stat" at all. What's the actual difference in skill between a 0.90 guy and a 0.95 guy? Between 0.95 and 1.00? The numerical gap is the same 0.05 either way, but what's the real difference? Nobody can say, nobody knows.
    81AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:33
    Re: #77
    "Bigger number = greater" is clearly what a "stat" is, lol.
    83AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:37
    Re: #77
    Ever heard of a distribution?
    80AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:31
    I think it'd make more sense to base the advantage on games back rather than on a losing record — like, a 10-game lead gets you a 2-win handicap, a 1-game lead gets nothing.
    82AnonymousSep 10, 2026 02:35
    Re: #80
    Why specifically 10 games?

    Background and Key Points of This Debate

    The Climax Series (CS) is NPB’s postseason format, introduced in 2007, and the fact that a 3rd-place team with a losing record — a so-called “debt team” — can still qualify has long been a point of contention. OPS (on-base percentage plus slugging percentage) is a sabermetrics-style stat that has spread in recent years, and skepticism like Emoto’s remains deep-rooted in Japanese baseball, which has traditionally emphasized batting average, RBIs, and home runs. In the thread, criticism that “a stat is broken if simple addition can push it past 100%” was met with counterarguments that “it’s a number meant to be read via distribution, not as a percentage,” revealing some disagreement over how OPS is even calculated in the first place. On the question of how many schools should compete at Koshien, opinions split between those wanting to expand the field and those wanting to shrink it, given that some teams already struggle to field enough players amid Japan’s declining birthrate — making it a debate that didn’t reduce to a simple for-or-against split.

    *This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5ch (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] Takenori Emoto Makes Proposals to the Baseball World: “Teams with Losing Records Shouldn’t Make the CS,” “OPS Isn’t Needed — Batting Average, RBIs, and Home Runs Are Enough,” “Cut the Number of Koshien Schools”.”

  • Two-Way Doubts Grow Around Ohtani: US Media Says ‘His Physical Peak Has Passed’

    Following reports that pitcher Shohei Ohtani is dealing with concerns in multiple areas — his left knee, right upper arm, and neck — that are affecting both his pitching and hitting, the US outlet FanSided has raised doubts about whether his two-way career can continue. The Los Angeles Dodgers have been managing the situation with scheduled rest days, but the article takes a harsh view, stating that “his physical peak has passed.” On 5channel threads, opinions were split between optimists citing his track record of defying repeated “limit” theories, and those frustrated that neither his pitching nor hitting is at full strength, calling for him to focus on just one role.

    “Is it no longer possible?” Doubts emerge over Shohei Ohtani’s two-way future!? US media points out his “physical peak has passed”

    Los Angeles Dodgers’ Shohei Ohtani is dealing with concerns in multiple areas — his left knee, right upper arm, and neck — that are affecting not just his pitching but his hitting as well.

    While the team is managing the situation as best it can with scheduled rest days, the US outlet FanSided has taken a harsh view of his continuing as a two-way player.

    Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here

    3AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:47
    Ohtani's proven every one of those doubters wrong before, though.
    4AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:48
    Even if two-way doesn't work out, he's still valuable as a hitter alone.
    64AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:13
    Re: #4
    Ohtani's problem is that it's hard to give up either pitching or hitting.
    Even this year, his early-season pitching numbers were top class.
    It's hard to tell a starter at that level to quit.
    But he's also a top-tier power hitter.
    Not just on the Dodgers — the best in the league.
    6AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:49
    Say what you want about him being 'done' — he's still stealing bases needlessly.
    7AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:49
    He should just be a reliever.
    Just keep throwing 10 pitches a day.
    Never step into the batter's box again.
    8AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:49
    Isn't Ohtani the guy who bounces back like nothing ever happened?
    11AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:50
    He's done more than enough already. At this point I just want him to pick one and focus.
    13AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:52
    Re: #1
    Until pretty recently, every pitcher in pro baseball used to bat too.
    15AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:53
    Wouldn't it be fine for him to focus mainly on hitting and just relieve as a pitcher?
    16AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:53
    US media is seriously lame.
    Acting all high and mighty, idiots.
    18AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:53
    Just put him on the IL already. He's not hitting, not pitching, he's no use at all.
    Calling up a young guy would do more for the team's future.
    19AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:54
    Everyone already knows.
    Only the diehard fans are pretending not to notice.
    21AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:55
    Say all that, but you were all thrilled when he hit a home run right after pitching that same day.
    The team's already said he'll keep doing two-way next season too — it's something only Ohtani can pull off.
    I'm just here to enjoy it.
    22AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:56
    Who even cares if the team wins or loses.
    23AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:57
    This is exactly why pros don't normally let players go two-way.
    24AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:57
    Imagine getting paid to defend this guy — what a burden.
    25AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:58
    If they end up paying him a massive salary after he's no longer useful, it's really just a matter of paying upfront versus paying later — but I bet it still doesn't sit right with the team.
    27AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:58
    If he has to pick just one, it should be pitching.
    28AnonymousSep 9, 2026 18:58
    Swinging away from the first pitch and grounding out in two or three pitches.
    No intention at all of making the opposing pitcher work for it.
    36AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:02
    Ohtani-san's real form is actually 🧠📱 an AI, y'know 💦
    37AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:02
    Isn't the deal basically '¥10 billion because he's two-way, but only ¥5 billion if he goes one-way,' or something like that?
    38AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:03
    Ohtani's finished.
    He's not good enough as just a pitcher or just a DH, so they gave him the two-way gimmick to compensate.
    The team doesn't actually need him doing any of this, stealing bases included.
    It's all just aimed at generating TV coverage.
    Once he can't do that anymore, the old media will be in trouble.
    He's boring enough as it is.
    54AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:11
    What's Ohtani planning to do after he retires, I wonder.
    62AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:13
    Re: #54
    He's loaded, so he could just live off gambling like Mizuhara did. (referring to Ippei Mizuhara, Ohtani's former interpreter caught in a gambling scandal)
    65AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:14
    I think Ohtani's done, but it's kind of funny that he still has to work for seven more years.
    At this rate he won't be able to fulfill the contract.
    He'll end up losing out on that contract money — serves them right, baseball nerds. ("yakibuta," 5ch slang mocking obsessive baseball fans)
    96AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:25
    Re: #65
    Ohtani gets paid regardless of whether he does anything — that's just how the contract works.
    77AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:18
    The only guy who stays world-class even as he ages is Kazuyoshi Miura. (legendary Japanese footballer still playing professionally into his late 50s)
    82AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:20
    Re: #77
    Nah, even he's washed up now.
    Have you seen him play live recently?
    He probably couldn't even keep up with junior high schoolers.
    93AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:25
    Even back when he was doing two-way, honestly it was mostly neither-here-nor-there.
    101AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:27
    Re: #93
    In 2023 he won the home run title while still doing two-way.
    94AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:25
    8 wins as a pitcher and 30 home runs is plenty impressive though.
    98AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:26
    Re: #94
    Only if you just look at the numbers.
    104AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:27
    It came out that he was just farming weak opponents on both sides of the ball, and that looks really bad lol
    112AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:31
    Re: #104
    Way better than being the one getting farmed by scrubs.

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    Ohtani won the AL home run title and MVP in the same season back in 2023, putting up top-tier numbers as a two-way player. This season, though, he’s been in and out of action due to a combination of issues with his left knee, right upper arm, and neck. This “limit” theory comes from a single outlet, FanSided — neither the team nor Ohtani himself has said anything about giving up on the two-way role. His contract with the Dodgers was never conditioned on him staying two-way; the salary is guaranteed regardless of his pitching or hitting performance, so a slump doesn’t directly lead to the contract being voided. Where opinions on the thread diverged was over how much to trust his track record of repeatedly overturning “limit” theories in the past, and how the team itself views the burden of continuing both roles while carrying injury risk.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5channel (Geinou/Sports News+) thread “[MLB] Doubts Emerge Over Shohei Ohtani’s Two-Way Future!? “Is It No Longer Possible?” — US Media Points Out His “Physical Peak Has Passed…”“.

  • Central League: Tigers 1-3 Carp [9/9] — Carp Snap Losing Skid as Toko Fires 8 Scoreless, Kikuchi & Nakamura Deliver Back-to-Back RBI Hits; Tigers Fall to 3rd Straight Loss

    In Central League action on the 9th, the Hiroshima Carp snapped their losing streak with a 3-1 win over the Hanshin Tigers, as Hiroki Toko pitched eight scoreless innings and Ryosuke Kikuchi and Kento Nakamura delivered back-to-back RBI hits. Rei Takahashi pitched gutsily for the Tigers but got no run support, dropping Hanshin to their third straight loss and casting a shadow over the pennant race. On 5channel’s live-thread, fans debated from every angle — questioning manager Kyuji Fujikawa’s in-game decisions, puzzling over how the Tigers keep struggling overall despite dominating the Giants head-to-head, and voicing hope tied to the number of remaining games at Koshien.

    Hiroshima 0 0 0 0 0 0 3 0 0 |3

    Hanshin 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 1 |1

    [Battery]

    Source: nikkansports.com / Original article here

    2AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:30
    (∪^ω^) Woof woof!
    40AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:36
    Re: #2
    Hashigami: Arai, shake! Woof woof!
    Hashigami: Good boy! Now go bite the Tigers!
    Arai: Chomp chomp!
    20AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:32
    This isn't a death road trip, it's a death home stand.
    25AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:33
    Maybe it's better if they don't win the pennant this year.
    46AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:37
    Re: #25
    Fujikawa's already locked in to stay on as manager next season too, so missing the pennant changes nothing.
    27AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:33
    I'm a Giants fan, but…
    They get your hopes up that we're catching up, then crush us in the head-to-head games just to show the gap in class.
    It's like being tortured slowly to death by a snake.
    34AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:34
    Re: #1

    Pitchers of record
    Winning pitcher: Toko, Carp (7-4, 0 SV)
    Losing pitcher: Takahashi, Tigers (13-3, 0 SV)
    Save: Moriura, Carp (5-2, 20 SV)
    35AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:35
    Tomorrow it's Saiki vs. Kuribayashi again, so another loss looks likely.
    36AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:35
    If the only way you score is standing around waiting for a homer, you don't even need a manager calling the shots.
    37AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:35
    They're crushing the Giants head-to-head and somehow the gap is still only 2 games — what a mystery lol
    58AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:40
    Re: #37
    Maybe they're focusing too much on the Giants games.
    91AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:46
    Re: #37
    They're losing so much everywhere else that the gap never widens.

    Same as the last series — why does the Tigers side play every single game like it's do-or-die?
    42AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:36
    Apparently there's a first-place team that starts its ace at home against the last-place team and still loses pathetically.
    The Tigers are so weak it's hilarious lololol
    45AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:37
    ID:AaRUes3z0 (Re: #33)
    We won ♪ we won ♪ we won again ♪
    Beat the 'Stinkers' again ♪ (a mocking pun on 'Tigers')
    Hurry home on the JR Kobe Line ♪
    55AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:39
    Because MBS pulled some dumb stunt, the Tigers' pennant hopes might really be gone now…
    MBS isn't getting off easy for this!
    62AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:41
    Re: #55
    Udon (a TV personality) might lose his gigs in Kansai over this.
    But if he didn't even know 'V yanen!' (the Tigers' championship victory chant), that means Udon was just a bandwagon fan too.
    57AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:39
    If they win the pennant with this much of a talent gap, interim manager Hashigami's stock is going to skyrocket lol
    Fujikawa: doesn't matter what else happens, he's going all-in to beat the Giants no matter what.
    Hashigami: even if he writes off a tough Tigers matchup, he makes up for it elsewhere and then some.
    Looking at the whole season, the latter approach might be the smarter one.
    65AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:41
    Re: #1
    Empty stands again today too 💦
    84AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:45
    Re: #65
    That's the 'Tax League' for you (a mocking pun on セ・リーグ/Central League, jabbing at its low attendance) — empty stands even though it's only weekend games once a week.
    78AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:44
    Since the Tigers have 3 more games left to play, does that mean the real gap is effectively 3.5 games?
    Their win rate at Koshien apparently isn't great, but with a lot of the remaining games there, maybe there's a shot.
    95AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:47
    Re: #78
    If the Giants had already finished their whole schedule and the Tigers just had 3 games left, sure — but I can't picture the current Tigers winning all 3 of those games in the thick of a pennant race.
    96AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:47
    Get swept pathetically 3 straight by the Giants, but turn around and defy the Tigers.
    What is wrong with you, Hiroshima…
    I will never forgive you.
    You're Tokyo's lackeys. What a truly pathetic team.
    108AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:52
    Re: #96
    Fujikawa picked a fight with Arai (got in his face like a thug), so he snapped and turned into Yomiuri's lapdog.
    99AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:48
    Thought Toko might just phone it in, but he really battled out there.
    102AnonymousSep 9, 2026 21:49
    Re: #99
    Got beat by Toko, a hometown boy from Amagasaki (right near Koshien).

    Background and Talking Points

    The Hanshin Tigers remain in first place in the Central League, but after dropping this three-game series to the Carp, their lead over the second-place Giants still isn’t widening the way you’d expect. As commenters in the thread pointed out, the Tigers have a commanding record against the Giants head-to-head this season, but they keep dropping games against other opponents — the Carp in particular — which is dragging down their overall results. Opinions were split on manager Kyuji Fujikawa’s approach, with a persistent theory that he’s prioritizing Giants matchups above everything else and treating other series as expendable. It’s also worth noting the Tigers have more games left to play than the Giants, so the raw game-back number alone doesn’t fully capture how tight things really are. And since Fujikawa’s return as manager next season is already locked in regardless of how this year finishes, that’s useful context for reading the thread’s debate over his in-game decisions.

    * This article is compiled from excerpts and a summary of the 5channel (Sports News+) thread “[Baseball] Central League: Tigers 1-3 Carp [9/9] — Carp Snap Losing Skid as Toko Fires 8 Scoreless, Kikuchi & Nakamura Deliver Back-to-Back RBI Hits; Tigers Fall to 3rd Straight Loss.”

  • Giants Cling to 3-Run Lead Over Chunichi as Late-Inning Bullpen Calls Steal the Spotlight — 5ch: ‘Just Like Tanishige Said’

    This is the live-commentary thread for the Giants-Chunichi game at Tokyo Dome on the 9th. While Maru delivered results, Izumiguchi — who keeps getting called out for his low batting average with runners in scoring position — again failed to cash in on his chances. The Giants carried a 3-run lead into the late innings, and thread posters debated how to divide up the remaining bullpen arms, including whether to rest closers like Eight and Raidel for the next day’s game. After the final out, some reacted that commentator Motonobu Tanishige’s on-air read of the situation had come true.

    1AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:39
    Previous thread
    Acting Giants Manager 129
    2AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:40
    2025–2026
    Departures
    Released: 26 Imamura, 28 Takahashi, 36 Baba, 54 Otosaka, 95 Toda
    Free agent: 29 Griffin, 33 Keller, 39 Frulp, 42 Hernandez, 50 Okoe
    Active Player Draft (out): 68 Kikuchi
    Compensation pick: 48 Tanaka Chi
    Trade: 59 Wakabayashi
    Posting: 25 Okamoto
    Retired: 7 Nagano, 30 Kondo, 43 Shigenobu

    Moved to developmental roster: 69 Sasahara, 90 Ishida Mitsuru, 94 Kita, 98 Suzuki, 99 Kyomoto

    Arrivals
    Draft picks: 21 Takemaru, 30 Tawa, 33 Kohama, 36 Yamashiro, 39 Minagawa, 99 Fujii
    Free agent signing: 9 Matsumoto, 43 Norimoto
    Active Player Draft (in): 54 Matsuura
    Trade:
    Other: 26 Whitley, 28 Howard, 29 Dahlbeck, 42 Mata, 56 Kitaura, 98 Ogasawara

    Promoted to first-team roster: 25 Daiki, 48 Luciano, 50 Tima, 59 Suzuki, 68 Utsunomiya, 69 Hirayama, 94 Chinen, 95 Sasahara

    2025 first-team registrations: 69
    2026 first-team registrations: 70

    Vacant numbers
    7 18 55 83
    3AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:40
    Tokyo Dome
    Starting lineups
    【Giants】  【Chunichi】
    4 Urata     4 Fukunaga
    8 Cabbage  6 Muramatsu
    3 Dahlbeck  5 Takahashi S.
    2 Oshiro    3 Sano
    7 Maru     9 Kanbayashi
    6 Izumiguchi     7 Hosokawa
    9 Matsumoto     8 Okabayashi
    5 Ishizuka     2 Ishii
    1 Mata    1 Ohno
    5AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Yoshihiro's here!!
    7AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    HEEERE IT COOOOMES!!!!!!
    8AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Maru's on fire, lol
    9AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Clutch hitting: check, vs. lefties: check
    10AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Not the same Maru as yesterday
    11AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    How many more to go?
    Countdown's started
    13AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    🦫 Giants
    14AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Ohno's getting rocked
    15AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:51
    Way to go, old man!
    25AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:52
    Izumiguchi overswung and popped a foul fly out to third
    26AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:53
    He was late on it so he ducked out of the way, but that was close
    29AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:54
    Now all that's left is for the Tigers to lose 🙄
    32AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:55
    Are we about to get the 'save labyrinth' treatment again with Raidel closing against Chunichi? (fan slang for his nerve-wracking saves)
    33AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:56
    Well, let's just make sure he doesn't get taken deep for a 3-run shot like that one time
    37AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:57
    Damn it
    Chunichi (mocking nickname 'Chin') takes the lead
    Nooooo it's actually happeninggg lol
    39AnonymousSep 9, 2026 19:58
    No self-driven go-ahead knock for him this time lol ('jiengo' = when a pitcher drives in his own run)
    42AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:00
    September's the time to burn through all your pitchers
    We're winning anyway
    59AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:11
    Izumiguchi's really flexing that low RISP average again today
    66AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:13
    He's swinging a bit more freely now, but will the results follow?
    68AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:13
    /Lah lah lah lah lah\
      \ __________/
       |               |
       |       Lah lah lah lah lah>
    < Let's go, Kadowaki!    |
       |     : (ノ'A`)>:     |
      / ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄: ( ヘヘ:: ̄ ̄ ̄ ̄\
    /                    \
        \ Hey hey hey! /
    80AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:17
    INOUE TOMO IS HEEERE ━━━━(゚∀゚)━━━━!!
    82AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:18
    If Kadowaki doesn't get himself to third, he can't run the bases, come on
    95AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:21
    What happened to Cabbage down in the minors — he could never draw a walk to save his life before
    98AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:22
    Please let Rai-Maru's 2.50 be nothing but smoke and mirrors
    118AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:25
    We're burning through pitchers today, so if we get a big lead I want to save Eight and Raidel for tomorrow
    120AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:26
    Haruto plunked Omori and got pulled
    though it wasn't a beanball
    125AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:27
    Was wondering what inning Chunichi ('Chin') was even in — turns out it's only the top of the 7th lol
    126AnonymousSep 9, 2026 20:27
    Just like Tanishige said it would
    Should've just kept the 3-run lead and closed it out quick with Rai-Maru

    Background and Key Points of This Discussion

    This day’s Giants-Chunichi game at Tokyo Dome saw Maru deliver results early, while Izumiguchi — long criticized for his low batting average with runners in scoring position — continued to struggle in this game as well. With only a limited number of available pitchers in the late innings, the focus turned to whether go-to relievers like Eight and Raidel should be held back for the next day’s game, and opinions were split on whether the 9th inning should be treated as a save situation. After the game, some voices noted that TV commentator Motonobu Tanishige’s on-air prediction had ultimately proven correct. The original thread, titled ‘Acting Giants Manager,’ is the 130th installment of an ongoing series, and debates over pitcher usage have repeatedly come up in these live-commentary threads as the season winds down.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Acting Giants Manager 130.”

  • Shohei Ohtani Benched Day After Comeback, Restarts ‘Within What He Can Still Play Through’

    Shohei Ohtani wrapped up his first game back after a five-game absence on September 8, only to be unexpectedly left out of the starting lineup the very next day, the 9th. According to Sports Hochi, the concern centers on the condition of his left knee and right arm, and he reportedly plans to restart “within a range he can still play in.” On the 5ch Geinou/Sports Express+ thread, the sudden “accident” report drew mixed reactions — some worried about his health, others joking about his repeated absences, and some sharply noting that his bench players, like Edman and the pinch-hitters, have actually been performing better.

    Possible accident for Shohei Ohtani? Shocking benching the day after his return from a five-game absence — he’s determined to restart “within a range he can play in,” but concerns remain over his left knee and right arm

    Sports Hochi

    September 9, 2026, 7:00 AM

    Source: hochi.news / Original article here

    2AnonymousSep 9, 2026 07:58
    "Accident-harassment," lol (mocking how the media keeps slapping the word "accident" on every setback)
    3AnonymousSep 9, 2026 07:58
    How many different Hernandezes are there anyway (the Dodgers have more than one on the roster)
    4AnonymousSep 9, 2026 07:59
    So they've decided it's hopelessly bad, huh
    Did the injury get worse again?
    5AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:00
    Edman batting leadoff is working out better anyway
    6AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:00
    Kind of want the Dodgers to lose whenever Ohtani's not in the lineup
    7AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:00
    Japanese tourists who dropped big money on flights and tickets must be in tears
    8AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:00
    If he's going to get a whole news article every time he's out of the lineup, wouldn't it just be better to put him on the IL already
    9AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:00
    What 'accident'? Everyone already knows something's clearly wrong
    10AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:01
    Could it be that Ohtani's retirement isn't as far off as we think?
    35AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:08
    Re: #10
    Nah, isn't it better if he just rests the whole rest of this season and heals up properly?
    Judge's been out resting forever too, right?
    14AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:01
    Today's probably just a normal healthy scratch, I'd guess
    16AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:03
    We don't need you!
    17AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:04
    Even without playing, he's still raking in sponsorship money
    19AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:04
    Maybe if he rests for about a week and just sleeps the whole time, Ohtani's judgment will go back to normal
    20AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:04
    They were busy trash-talking soccer and the boomerang came right back at them, lol

    Baseball's decline into irrelevance is something else 🤣
    108AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:26
    Re: #20
    This you, perhaps?

    961: Anonymous (much obliged): 2026/09/09 (Wed) 00:21:12.10 ID:GNzoSbCf0
    The guy who was trashing Ohtani like crazy
    ended up posting in an IP-revealing thread,
    and it turned out he's a diehard fanboy of soccer's [Takefusa] Kubo
    116AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:28
    Re: #108
    Ah, I see
    Guess it's the backlash from Ohtani stans dissing on every player in every other sport
    130AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:31
    Re: #108
    That anti's always around, huh
    He's in this thread too
    28AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:06
    Just swinging a bat and suddenly it's 'fatigue' this, 'injury' that
    44AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:10
    Re: #28
    Full-time DH and still getting hurt, lol
    32AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:07
    Ohtani's a guy who needs a lot of sleep after all
    38AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:09
    Re: #32
    Marriage and kids are totally dragging him down
    41AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:09
    Re: #32
    Guess now that he's gotten older he probably can't sleep much more than a normal person anymore
    37AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:09
    8 wins, 30 home runs — that's plenty for this year already, right?
    80AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:18
    Re: #37
    Wish I could've seen 10 wins and 40 homers though
    51AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:11
    He's been treated like a saint this whole time, but turns out he's only human
    65AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:15
    Honestly it's probably time to retire the two-way thing, but he'll probably choose pitching over hitting…
    83AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:18
    Re: #65
    Pitching full-time with the occasional at-bat puts less strain on the body, but hitting full-time with the occasional start on the mound is tough
    82AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:18
    This looks like an IL trip coming — my guess: bench him through tomorrow, then IL after that
    98AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:23
    Re: #82
    He played yesterday, so if they put him on the IL now he'd barely get to play the rest of the season — so I don't think they will?
    88AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:19
    Re: #80
    Why do baseball bros (a mocking 5ch term for baseball otaku) always obsess over multiples of 10 for no reason, lol
    97AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:23
    Come to think of it, he wasn't there on the bench to greet Teoscar when he hit his homer yesterday either
    And Teoscar always tosses him sunflower seeds too
    128AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:30
    Re: #97
    Teoscar's a good one
    Even when he's not hitting himself, he still tosses the sunflower seeds like always
    102AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:25
    Performing like he used to is going to be tough now
    Wonder what they'll do about his contract, lol
    122AnonymousSep 9, 2026 08:29
    Re: #102
    If they trade him, it just means the Dodgers got to use him on the cheap

    Background and Talking Points

    Ohtani has faced repeated reports of fatigue and injury this season while continuing his two-way workload as both pitcher and hitter, and on the thread, the headline’s very use of the word “accident” became a target of jokes. This time it’s strictly a bench start (being left out of the lineup), which is technically different from being placed on the injured list, though the reporting itself doesn’t make that distinction clear. With the postseason approaching, losing their top slugger would be no small blow for the Dodgers, and the thread’s chatter about bench players like Edman and Teoscar stepping up reflects the team’s current depth situation. Meanwhile, the back half of the thread drifted off-topic into baseball-versus-soccer fan rivalries and speculation about Ohtani’s personal life, and as of the 9th there’s been no further update on his actual physical condition.

    *This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Geinou/Sports Express+) thread “Possible accident for Shohei Ohtani? Shocking benching the day after his return from a five-game absence, determined to restart “within a range he can play in”.”

  • Former Manager Shinnosuke Abe Returns to the Giants, Back on the Field 4 Months After Resigning — 5ch: ‘Didn’t They Start Winning Once He Left?’

    The Yomiuri Giants have announced that former manager Shinnosuke Abe will return to the team’s front line roughly four months after resigning. Abe stepped down as manager early in the season, and is now rejoining the club just as it has been picking up form in the late stages under interim skipper Shinji Hashigami. Reaction on 5ch was split: some posters were harsh, arguing “he clearly hasn’t reflected enough,” pointing out that his resignation came with a vow to quit drinking, while others welcomed the move as reinforcement for the Climax Series push, noting the team’s win rate against the Hanshin Tigers had dropped since Abe left.

    Former Manager Shinnosuke Abe Returns to the Giants, Back on the Field 4 Months After Resigning (published September 8, 2026) – Livedoor News

    Source: news.livedoor.com / Original article here

    4AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:03
    Coming back as manager right away would make it look like he hasn't reflected at all — start him off as 'Assistant Manager' Shinnosuke Abe.
    7AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:04
    Guess they can't do the champagne shower even if they win it all —
    alcohol's banned now.
    13AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:07
    He swore off booze, not off coming back to the team — nothing we can do, just accept it.
    16AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:08
    Next season's Yomiuri Giants manager: Shinnosuke Abe.
    This is really happening.
    17AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:08
    He went on in that interview all humbled about how he'd tarnished the Giants manager's job — so this shouldn't be happening.
    24AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:10
    Re: #17
    It's the other way around — his return was already decided, so they ran the remorse story to beg the public's forgiveness first.
    18AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:09
    Seriously, being part of the elite really does mean you're never guilty, huh ("jōkyū kokumin" — slang for untouchable elites).
    19AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:09
    Are you serious. Guess I'll go ask ChatGPT ("Chappy") what to do about this.
    20AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:09
    Can't have an outsider like Hashigami actually going and winning it all, now can they.
    21AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:09
    Guy's unemployed, that's rough —
    just hire him as a ball boy or equipment manager.
    23AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:10
    The last piece for the Giants to take back the title falls into place.
    25AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:10
    Felt like it was going to be Matsui though (fans had been expecting Hideki Matsui to get the nod).
    27AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:11
    Could he go hang out with guys like Sho Nakata — the free agent who decked someone — or Shun Yamaguchi, who assaulted people at a hospital?
    30AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:12
    My local Yomiuri Shimbun branch had *just* finally taken down the Abe Shinnosuke poster too.
    32AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:13
    The alcohol company sponsors aren't gonna love this.
    33AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:13
    Spare a thought for Hashigami — stuck cleaning up after this guy and getting an earful from Hirooka on top of it.
    41AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:22
    Didn't they start winning once Abe left?
    48AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:27
    They stopped beating the Tigers after Abe left, so bringing him back in time for the Climax Series actually makes sense.
    57AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:34
    Re: #48
    Since Hashigami took over it's 3-9 against the Tigers — makes you suspect it's because Hashigami's a Tigers alum.
    50AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:30
    The players actually look like they're enjoying themselves right now — this is gonna kill the mood again.
    51AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:31
    Giants morale collapses, Tigers take the pennant!!!
    52AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:32
    Just have ChatGPT set the lineup and call the plays.
    53AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:32
    There's nobody else anyway.
    56AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:34
    Re: #53
    Just bring Hara back then.
    54AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:33
    And they'd finally started winning too.
    58AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:35
    Compared to what Hiroshima's going through, this is nothing.
    61AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:37
    >It's already September, so even calling it a 'return,' it's probably more of an advisory role.
    >He likely won't be in uniform, so the impact on games should be limited.

    Alright, thread's over then.
    62AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:37
    This'll boost morale, I guess —
    though that's probably the whole point.
    66AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:42
    Everyone involved in this must feel so awkward…
    69AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:48
    Bet the Tigers fans are loving this.
    73AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:50
    Re: #69
    More like they're shaking in their boots — with Hashigami still in charge they could go after the Giants directly.
    71AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:49
    Great, pennant's a lock now.
    72AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:50
    Apologizing by email, lol — guess like father, like son, lol.
    74AnonymousSep 8, 2026 15:52
    What face is he even going to make while he starts the power harassment back up?
    95AnonymousSep 8, 2026 16:06
    ・Front office gets to fire manager Hashigami for 'failing to win the pennant'
    ・Abe comes back, the team stumbles, so they can finally let Abe go too
    ・Meanwhile Hashigami gets credit for holding the team together and lands a coaching or front-office job next year

    Nothing but upside here.
    99AnonymousSep 8, 2026 16:07
    Re: #95
    So who's actually managing the team then?
    107AnonymousSep 8, 2026 16:20
    Ha, good luck with that (lol)
    108AnonymousSep 8, 2026 16:24
    Re: #107
    Don't come crying later.

    Background and Talking Points

    Shinnosuke Abe took over as Giants manager in 2024 but resigned early this season, with coach Shinji Hashigami taking over the reins ever since. Reports at the time of his resignation said he showed contrition, including a vow to give up alcohol, and the thread’s jokes leaned heavily on that detail. As the quoted article notes, this “return” is believed to be more of an advisory role rather than Abe putting the uniform back on and calling the shots himself — though most of the thread’s reactions treated it simply as a “return to managing” without factoring that in, so the actual scope of his involvement will have to wait for an official announcement from the club. Posters also cited conflicting numbers for the team’s record under Hashigami, especially against the Tigers, so it’s best to check primary sources for the exact figures.

    *This article is compiled and summarized from the 5ch (Nanademo Jikkyo G) thread “Former Manager Shinnosuke Abe Returns to the Giants, Back on the Field 4 Months After Resigning.”