From our other sites
The story
The Game Awards (TGA) nominees have been announced, sparking a flurry of reactions on 5ch’s “Hardware/Industry” (Geha) board. The Game of the Year (GOTY) category features six titles: Grand Theft Auto VI, The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time (remake), Resident Evil Requiem, 007 First Light, Control Resonant, and Phantom Blade Zero. Opinions were split over the scarcity of the big-name US titles that usually dominate, the fact that the unreleased GTA6 scored the most nominations of any title, and the inclusion of Ocarina of Time — now on its second remake.
Let’s all watch it together
Source: youtube.com / Original article here
What people said
007
Control Resonant
GTA6
Phantom Blade 0
Resident Evil Requiem
Ocarina of Time
007 First Light → IO Interactive (Denmark)
Control Resonant → Remedy Entertainment (Finland)
GTA6 → Rockstar North (UK)
Phantom Blade Zero → S-GAME (China)
Resident Evil Requiem → Capcom (Japan)
The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time → Nintendo (Japan)
A rare year with no American-made game in the mix
・Grand Theft Auto 6
・The Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time
・Resident Evil Requiem
・007 First Light
・Control Resonant
・Phantom Blade Zero
Especially Control Resonant — it only has a Metascore of 83.
What a rigged-ass awards show.
Well, I guess that tracks.
They did slot Marathon and Saros into the individual categories
An awards show full of favors.
Fine, since it won't actually win anyway, but going forward I wish they'd just exclude garbage remakes from nominations entirely
It's simply dead weight.
Resident Evil and Final Fantasy remakes have been nominated before, so there's no way the Ocarina remake — rated even higher than those — wouldn't get a nomination.
It's pretty decent.
For what it's worth, the original was nominated back in 2019 too.
It was basically a tech demo for real-time ray tracing.
The protagonist uses psychic powers to make their way through a facility that feels like the SCP Foundation.
The DLC also ties into the Alan Wake story.
This is so staged it's funny lol
To be fair, this award is decided by a mix of votes from major review outlets and the public, so
it's entirely possible outlets that got early review access voted it in.
And on top of that, it's a pre-release game that still got the most nominations of anyone.
Resonance ← ooh!
Wan Zi Qian Hong ← feels like it's just fodder next to Resonance…
Trails 2nd ← fodder… lol
Trails 2nd actually got picked?
That's a huge win considering how niche it is.
・2XKO
・Marvel Tokon: Fighting Souls
・Avatar Legends
・Invincible VS
・My Hero Academia: All's Justice
The fighting game category is a mess lol
Seriously, they're putting My Hero Academia and Tokon in there…
Forget good or bad — this category seems like you get in just by actually releasing.
Putting Poko Aka FE (note: nickname for a Fire Emblem title) in with Ocarina would've caused an uproar, and Big Walk and Mina being good makes sense since they're indies, but why is FH in there?
Same as with FH5 — racing games basically never get a GOTY nomination even when they're well reviewed.
Well, they've got to beat last year's "whatever Expedition 33" record for most wins, don't they? ❤
If you're gonna put that kind of game in, it should've been Onimusha.
It's honestly really high quality though.
The level of polish is insane.
And of course it didn't end up winning either.
In terms of how little the remake actually reworked things and overall quality, RE4 Remake and Ocarina are about on the same level,
so Ocarina losing is a given too.
It'll probably pick up one win though, in either art direction or music.
In 2023 there was Tears of the Kingdom and BG3 in the running, so losing was just down to the competition —
it wasn't because it was a remake.
They passed over six widely-reviewed games scoring 90 and 89 to include games in the mid-80s,
so of course it feels like a letdown.
Three Houses actually won in the Strategy category back in the day.
Feels like there's some behind-the-scenes politics going on.
so I get why people felt a remake winning GOTY didn't sit right.
But everyone's kind of woken up from that by now, so I wouldn't find it strange even if a remake won this time.
Re: #95
If it comes down to choosing Resident Evil or Onimusha for the slot, I guess it'd end up being Resident Evil.
Background and Key Points of This Topic
The Game Awards (TGA), running since 2014, is one of the world’s largest gaming award shows, hosted by Geoff Keighley. The GOTY category is decided through a combination of votes from roughly 100 major media outlets and review sites plus a public vote. The thread’s hot topic — GTA6 pulling in the most nominations — is likely the result of outlets that had access to pre-release review builds factoring it into their votes even though the game hasn’t launched yet; there’s no solid basis for calling it “staged.” A remake making the GOTY list has precedent in 2023’s Resident Evil 4 Remake, which lost that year but still points to shifting standards. The thread also raised the lack of Sony first-party titles, but looking at the individual categories, some Sony titles did get nominated — so it’s worth noting the absence isn’t total.
※This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hardware/Industry, “Geha”) thread “[TGA] The Game Awards nominees announced starting 2 AM!.”

Leave a Reply