From our other sites
The story
Multiple US media outlets report that Major League Baseball (MLB) has proposed introducing an international draft system for amateur players from Japan and elsewhere, as part of its revised proposal for the labor agreement set to expire on December 1 (December 2 Japan time). If adopted, the system would take effect in late 2027 or early 2028, meaning negotiations originally set to open on January 15 next year would be frozen until then. Oda Shoki, a pitcher drawing attention at Koshien, had already stated, “If an international draft is introduced, I’m also considering enrolling at an American university,” and this sparked discussion on 5ch’s Entertainment/Sports News+ board about the Yomiuri Giants’ moves, the fairness of the signing-bonus system, and how realistic a US college path really is.
MLB Proposes International Draft System — Oda’s Signing Could Be Pushed to Late 2027 or Later
Multiple US media outlets report that Major League Baseball (MLB) has proposed introducing an international draft system for amateur players from Japan and elsewhere, as part of its revised proposal for the labor agreement set to expire on December 1 (December 2 Japan time). The topic came up at the GM meetings.
Negotiations with international amateur players were originally set to open on January 15 next year, but if the international draft is introduced, it would be held in late 2027 or early 2028, with negotiations frozen until then.
Source: news.yahoo.co.jp / Original article here
What people said
The majors move fast on this stuff, not slow like Japan.
Wouldn't this need Japan's agreement too? If it's a rule MLB can set entirely on its own, maybe it could happen fast.
It only applies to amateurs — whose agreement in Japan would even be needed?
Even if he goes to America, at his current level there's no way he jumps straight to the majors — he'd start in the minors.
It's the opposite — if the international draft actually gets introduced, the exodus will go into overdrive.
Right now rich teams have the edge, but under a draft a player's fate comes down to a lottery — of course that'd make guys hesitant to go. Signing bonuses would also be set by draft slot, so you couldn't dump $2 million or $3 million on one specific player anymore.
The international amateur free agent pool money is an allocation system. It's less about who has the advantage and more about how much you can spend on one guy.
What you wrote is exactly right, but rich teams would lose the ability to just buy players outright like before. And honestly, whether it's MLB, NPB, or European soccer, the whole system runs on rich clubs having power — a buyer-and-bought-from relationship. I don't think this works without that, and there's no upside for the rich teams either.
Even before that, Sato from Sendai University is expected to go in the first round of the regular MLB draft next year anyway.
25 is too late. If they'd post him at 20, then sure, the Giants could be an option. Sasaki Roki was supposed to be posted at 21 too — did his team ever actually promise that? Even if they had, the current team president would've just said 'that was the old president's promise, not mine' and refused — that's exactly the mess that happened. Even with an early-posting promise in writing, it means nothing if the team doesn't honor it.
Exactly this — getting a huge signing bonus AND picking whatever team you want is just too unfair.
There's obviously no such thing as going straight from high school to the majors.
It's not that nobody's broken out within 0-2 years of being drafted out of high school, but among the big names, it's been about 15 years since one did. Though by 'big names' I mean guys like Trout and Harper.
Of course it does. And the championship series in the home of this 'real' baseball wraps itself up under the laughably self-important name 'World Series.' And naturally, our own country — whose creed is bowing to America — also has a draft system that locks up amateurs. The whole thing starts from this closed little world, and then they insist on holding 'international' tournaments on top of it — a real duet of absurdity.
Baseball (yakyu) is just a copy of baseball (the American kind) — why would you assume it wouldn't have one? Though for the same reasons, NPB's draft just came a few months after MLB's.
Hiroshima Carp be like: 'What about our Carp Academy?'
Oda clearly saw the lockout coming too. Saying he's also considering a US university makes perfect sense as a statement made with all of this in mind. The real meaning behind it is: whichever way things go, he's heading to America. In other words, NPB is absolutely off the table for him.
Basketball's Hachimura Rui went to the US for college and came out fluent in English.
As for cost, if everything — tuition, dorm fees, meals, all of it — gets fully covered like it was for Sasaki Rintaro, he could go. No idea about his English, but normally you'd be completely lost sitting in class.
That read is basically fair. Oda came up through rubber-ball baseball (nankyu — the softer youth-ball variant) and was already getting attention since his freshman year of high school, but he's not as polished as Matsuzaka was. That said, being able to throw that hard at his age is a talent in itself, so it's not fair to call Oda a nobody. We really don't know yet either way.
Right now he's definitely the No. 1 in his generation. If this kind of trend sticks, eventually the next Matsuzaka-tier or Otani-tier guy is just going to head straight to America too.
According to the Dodgers' VP, he's supposedly on par with Sasaki Roki back in his high school days.
Background and key points of this discussion
MLB has floated the idea of an international draft several times in past labor negotiations; in the most recent agreement (2022), the proposal was shelved, leaving only a clause committing to “continue discussions.” This time it resurfaced as the agreement’s expiration approached. Under the current system, signing-bonus money is distributed within a pool allocated to each team, allowing well-funded clubs to pour large sums into specific top prospects. If a draft system is introduced, destination and bonus slot would instead be decided by something close to a lottery-based pick order, making it harder for deep-pocketed teams to snap up prospects early. Opinions in the thread are split on whether this change protects players or instead strips top prospects of their negotiating leverage and pay, pushing them toward US colleges instead — with past debates over Sasaki Roki’s posting negotiations cited along the way — and the discussion ultimately turned to speculation about Oda’s own career path.
*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Entertainment/Sports News+) thread “[MLB] GM Meetings Propose Introducing International Draft System, Multiple US Media Report… Oda Shoki May Be Forced to Take a Gap Year or Go to College.”
Leave a Reply