Yokohama High’s Starting Lineup Has Zero Players From Kanagawa — 5ch: ‘What’s Wrong With Baseball Transfers Anyway?’

Written by

in

It’s become a hot topic on 5ch that not a single player in Yokohama High School’s baseball starting lineup is from Kanagawa Prefecture. The lineup features players recruited from other prefectures — three from Aichi, two from Saitama, and more — and the fact that several players came up through rubber-ball (nanshiki) baseball rather than the standard hardball youth leagues also drew attention, sparking debate over the pros and cons of “baseball transfer students.”

2Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:04:13.75
So you can make it to Yokohama coming up through rubber-ball baseball.
7Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:07:47.32
>>2
Naruse came from rubber-ball baseball too.
6Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:07:38.42
Wonder how much money flowed to the recruiting brokers.
9Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:08:08.28
Didn't realize it was this common these days
No wonder Mabuchi's been sounding the alarm (veteran coach known for warning against over-recruiting).
13Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:09:44.49
>>9
Meitoku's got its own version of the problem too — they're signing kids while they're still in middle school, so that's questionable in its own way.
11Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:08:22.38
Wasn't the DH, Ajiki, from the Izumi Chuo Boys club team?
14Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:10:29.23
The batting order was different for the Hanamaki Higashi game, but having Chishima hitting 9th is scary.
16Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:11:46.23
Slapping cheeks with stacks of cash to sign players — that's the Kanagawa style.
17Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:12:20.96
They enrolled at Yokohama because they wanted to reach Koshien through it
I honestly don't care if the roster's full of kids from other prefectures
Signed, a Kanagawa native
18Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:12:37.25
The bench and the guys who didn't make the roster are basically all Kanagawa kids 😂
19Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:13:37.62
Wait, Oda's from Fukuoka?
Now that you mention it, I can't even remember who represented Fukuoka this year lol
20Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:15:51.11
Aichi: 3
Saitama: 2
Hyogo: 1
Fukuoka: 1
Saga: 1
Kumamoto: 1
22Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:16:46.28
Any school tangled up with Juice=Juice ends up like this (Hello! Project idol group — running joke on this board)
23Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:17:14.59
Can't they just win with Kanagawa natives?
24Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:18:33.05
Oh right, tomorrow's the semifinal
Wonder if Tetsusaburo's starting.
26Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:21:11.92
These days pitchers who came up through rubber-ball baseball often actually have less wear on their shoulders and elbows.
27Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:22:05.17
There was a Chiba native on the team not too long ago, but they don't seem to be recruiting from there anymore.
31Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:32:30.28
It's totally normal for colleges to recruit nationwide, so why is it not okay for high schools?
67Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:31:29.29
>>31
Go count how many colleges there are versus how many high schools
Besides, college baseball doesn't have this whole prefecture-vs-prefecture thing going on.
32Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:33:33.18
A lot of Hello! Project members move to Tokyo from the countryside too.
33Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:34:05.93
With colleges, you only get called a cheater once they start reaching overseas for recruits.
34Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:41:21.19
They left home and spent three years grinding it out in Kanagawa — that makes them a proper Kanagawa resident, doesn't it?
36Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:42:47.24
>>34
Lmao what a stretch of an argument.
35Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:42:12.21
Oda hit a home run at Kitakyushu Municipal Stadium back in middle school
I assumed that was hardball lol — if it was rubber-ball, that's terrifying power.
39Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:46:05.30
Is spending three years at Yokohama High shagging balls and cheering from the bench actually better for your future college/job prospects than being a starter at your local high school?
47Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:58:02.98
>>39
Shagging balls is the Kanagawa natives' job
53Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:06:41.18
>>47
Kobayashi and Ajiki actually get regular playing time though.
40Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:46:17.12
Honestly, I don't even get what's supposed to be wrong with baseball transfer students in the first place.
42Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:49:31.08
>>1
The only names I can actually read are cleanup hitter Haruto, No. 7 Yoshifumi, and No. 8 Taiga.
43Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:50:05.10
Last year they had a third baseman named Tamenaga who came from Yokohama Municipal Mutsukawa Junior High.
44Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:52:28.52
Saying it like Saitama's fine because it's technically still in the Kanto region lol
45Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:53:36.03
Most regular Kanagawa residents weren't rooting for Yokohama High in the first place, whether they knew this or not.
46Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:55:49.50
With Hachinohe Gakuin Kosei, people welcome players from other regions because it spreads the real, Pacific-side picture of Aomori — the "huh, this isn't the Aomori I imagined" effect.
48Anonymous2026/08/19(水) 23:58:19.47
Yokohama, Keio, Sagami — they're all recruiting nationwide, so worrying about where anyone's from is pointless.
50Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:02:03.13
High school baseball nerds bash rural schools for fielding a 'foreign legion' of recruits, but somehow never go after Yokohama or Osaka Toin — total double standard.
52Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:04:11.70
They say even in the pros, slightly more pitchers actually come from a rubber-ball background
Compared to position players, hardball experience in middle school doesn't seem to give as much of an edge.
62Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:23:33.31
For reference:
Nihon University Fujisawa
Toko Gakuen
Tokai University Sagami


66Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:30:09.42
Kind of sad there's nobody from the 'peanut prefecture' (Chiba, famous for its peanuts).
70Anonymous2026/08/20(木) 00:40:31.72
>>66
Going back further, Hanshin's Ito Sho is from Yokoshibahikari and Oikawa's from Sosa City
Ito Sho played rubber-ball baseball at Yokoshibahikari Town's Yokoshiba Junior High, and two years behind him was Rakuten's Hayakawa, who went on to Kisarazu Sogo.

*This article is excerpted and summarized from the 5ch (Hello! Project board) thread “Yokohama High School Baseball Team’s Starting Lineup… Zero Kanagawa Natives 😂.”

Comments

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *